Hm. Reading the posts in isolation, I guess that’s defensible; I still think that back in the context of the discussion at the time, when several other people also suggested peeker give out at least his title, the context was that of “so in the event of a counterclaim we can evaluate fairly”.
Not saying it was a bad Day 1 vote; but I still think part of your premise was faulty.
Don’t you mean Day 2? ColdPhoenix was here all of Day 1.
I voted you on Day 3 for what appeared to be the same opportunistic lurking ColdPhoenix had seemed to be doing on Day 1, which was the primary motivation for my vote. On Day 3, after a 2 day absence, you placed the final leader vote a couple of hours before the 24 hour limit and then disappeared for several days. I voted you and then you reappeared 30 minutes before Day End. You have since been much more active and involved!
Sorry for my absence- RL intruded.
Vote CiaS. A great pickup by AllWalker, and town’s got some momentum at last.
Tha A-l curse strikes again. 
AllWalker is the one who doesn’t dissolve in water.
D’oh!
Consider me duly poked, after screwing up as a sub for Days 2 & 3. I was truly away from the board for just about all of Day 3, and that’s my own fault. (On preview, you could probably strike “much more” from that last sentence and still be correct.
Since Today’s lynch is all but certain (and Cat has had plenty of chance to rebut the case against him), what else do we have to talk about?
At this point, roles we have evidence for are the Politician (who is probably Town, or could be Third Party, simply because the role would be ridiculously overpowered for scum) and the Vigilante or Serial Killer. I’m starting to think that there might not be another investigative role out there; that between the Bling Brothers, the recruiting mason (doh) and Griff’s various toys we’re supposed to create a pool of confirmed town and go after the scum that way.
I’m actually not sure what good fully claiming does us. The only plus side I see is that if we DO have a SK instead of a vig, it will force this fact into the open, or else force the SK to claim vig, in which case they can be lynched at Town’s leisure once we think all the scum are gone.
Gryff (1):
Guiri (1): CiaS
CiaS (11): Scudsy, Gryff, Boozy Squid, USCD., Norm Phase, DB, Guiri, AllWalker, Scuba, Alky, tilta
It won’t make much of a difference but OreDigger77 voted CIAS in post #2086 and One And Only Wanderers voted CIAS in post #2109
Ok, what do we have for WoW’s on Chronos and CIAS so far? Nothing on Day Three, right? Night Two?
Right. I did walls for both Chronos and Cat on night 2, and Cat (for whatever it’s worth) did a Chronos wall on Day 3.
I think we’ve gotten everything out of Jimmy’s posts that we possibly can, but someone feeling like a completist might want to go back and re-WoW him and compare with Cat’s version, assuming Cat flips scum.
Do you have a link to the post where you did those (and Cat’s as well, why not) for quick reference?
Links to both (as well as my preliminary post-CHronos-lynch rundown here). Also my post from earlier Today reviewing my Cat wall and glancing over Day 3, wherein I join the smudge-Tom wagon by smudging myself. Going back, he also pushed the Drain Bead is a Bomb thing on Day 3.
Interestingly, Cat shares your reading of those posts.
Okay, I’ll summarize the pair of them for Night Two/Day Three.
Another quick reread of the two walls side by side; not much I can find going on there; other players’ attitudes towards Chronos seem to have been more revealing.
477: endorses the “there must be scum pushing the Drain Bead wagon” argument.
890: takes a pointless poke at Drain Bead
1196, 1278 - repeatedly accuses Tom Scud of being third-party thief
1403 - first serious discrepancy I’ve found in the Cat vs. Tom walls; Cat thinks Chronos is in favor of a DB on DB block; I [correctly] say he says it’s inferior to a Daphne lynch.
The only thing there of potential value is 477. At this point I think we can assume there weren’t a large number of scum on the turn-1 DBead wagon, though that doesn’t mean there weren’t any (by 477, Cat hadn’t yet voted her).
We now know the alignment of 3 of the players on that wagon, and they’re all Town. Not sure how much weight to place on this, as it was part of a pile-on onto peeker.
Irritatingly, the previous post blows my Night 3 five-player list almost completely out of the water.
Just a brief note before my impending lynch to say have fun all.