Just had to fire my newish therapist. Damn.
TLDR version: The guy wouldn’t do what I asked.
I’ve had more than my share of therapists and through a long process of elimination have found out some things which do and don’t work for me. I’ve finally gotten to the position where I can be upfront with a counselor about my needs.
So a couple of months back, I decided to go back into therapy for depression, anxiety and other issues. I call a counseling center and talk to the intake person. She asked that I look over the profiles of the therapists and see if I had any requests.
I send an email summarizing my issues and say that it looks like two particular therapists may be good matches, and what I specifically liked about their profiles. One of the therapists (I’ll call him John) has that he sees himself as a partner in the process. I like that as I’ve known too many therapists who want to push their solution.
John is available and he emails me. I respond again with a summary of my issues, and tell him I’m really happy to read that he likes being a partner. I let him know that (1) I’ve got some really deep issues relating to the severe abuse I had as a child, (2) that I’ve had years of therapy and have found some specific techniques which do work and others which don’t, I briefly outline some of them, and (3) while I need to continue working on deeper issues, I really want to first concentrate on getting into a good routine, including getting exercise. This is to help me stabilize my emotions and which will help me work on the deeper issues. I also wanted to work on things, such as consistently getting housework done which have helped in the past, but which I’m not doing well now.
I also acknowledge that this is probably a really direct email and if he doesn’t feel comfortable providing therapy given my many requests, that I would completely understand.
He replied that he was cool with it and looked forward to working with me.
We start the therapy, and he just doesn’t want to do what I have asked. When I talk to him about it, he says that he’s not particularly strong in that area. OK, but let’s work on it. No, he continues to steer the conversation into the direction he wants. I have a harder time being as direct in person and I get frustrated. I talk about wanting to work on my routines. He thinks it’s better to discuss what is happening in the session first.
We go through this several times. He has a month’s leave and in his absence, I work on some issues myself. Things start to feel much better. He comes back and emails me that he’s ready to resume. I let him know that I really, really want to work on the stuff I’ve asked. He says that he’s learned that he needs to respect my wishes.
And then he doesn’t. We have two sessions and he’s really happy with the progress.
Then we run into a major problem. I had had an issue with my wife and he gave some advice. Fine. Standard stuff. Then he asks if there wasn’t something I could do to help strength the relationship. I ask for clarification and he was thinking that maybe I could do more housework.
Fuck. That really pissed me off. He didn’t want to discuss it when it was my idea, but now he was all over it because it was his idea. It was at the end of the session and I just left, I told him I was too upset to talk about it.
The next week he emails and hopes we can resolve the problem. It’s “better” for me to face my issues. I decide to try to give it one more shot and go back in.
When I reiterate what I was looking for in therapy, and point out that I had been very clear from the beginning, he got really defensive. He said how much time he had spent outside our session thinking about what I wanted, etc. and that even though he normally doesn’t do what I’m asking, and that he really isn’t good at it, he guessed that maybe he could try.
Oh, and he just wanted to point out that he was really super excited about a point which matched his expectations.
I said that it was obvious that his heart wasn’t into it. He got defensive again, and said that he didn’t know how else he could help me. I agreed. I didn’t see how he could help me, either. I paid in cash, as I always do. Got up and walked out.
I felt really down for a couple of days, but typing this out, I’m feeling much better about my decision.