I am not sure whether revealing my idea does harm or not at this stage, but I will try anyway and you can judge yourself. As Chronos wrote in the Signup thread he distributes roles among us players like this:
The last sentence means that the information provided so far is incomplete and thus ambiguous. The quote is a hint, but it is not enough to find out what a character can or is supposed to do - yet.
I think the ambiguity does not apply to Villains: they know their role perfectly well. But it applies to the other characters: we are still in the dark. And it shows.
Could a Villain please be so friendly and confirm whether I am on the right track or not?
Perhaps the vagueness simply is in that we do not know what power roles are in play, but once those roles are revealed in the course of the game, we will. For instance if there are multiple deaths overnight (or none) we can infer certain information from that.
Hi all. I haven’t played Mafia before, but I have played an IRL game called Werewolf, which I think is similar. So I may or may not have any idea what I’m doing.
My favourite Shakespeare play is Twelfth Night (TBH I’m not familiar with that many of them, but it’s a fun one).
You control your own vote. Other people control their votes. If someone is voting for someone and you don’t think they should be, all you can do is to vote for someone else to try to put them ahead. Or try to convince them to change, of course.
Been playing since 2009. It’s, well, almost impossible most of the time. You have to go on motivations and honestly, just feel out the vibes people give off.
Well, the flip side of that is that playing on a message board, we do have an exact log of everything everyone has said. So it’s possible to do things like “On Day 2, you said this, but now, you’re saying this other thing, why the change?”.
For the record, every player has posted at least once in Day One except Thing.Fish. (That doesn’t bother me, as it is Sunday and the game started early.)
It does mean someone is fooling me, though. (I say this because I have it in my head that everyone who posted seems Towny, but we can’t all be Town.)
Hi everyone! Just noticed this had started! So happy to be playing Mafia again, and especially with you wonderful people. I think this is my first game since the Championships two years ago, which kind of melted my brain.
SunUp asked about the kinds of roles we might expect to see. Literally anything is possible (except recruitment, which means players can’t switch from Town to Scum teams).
But the most common roles we see are some variation of the following (obviously the names may also vary):
Cop: Investigates target and learns their alignment. The most powerful role.
Doc: Protects target and prevents them from being killed. May or may not be able to protect self.
Vig: Kills target.
Roleblocker: Prevents other players from using their powers. Variation is Jailkeeper, which also prevents the target from being affected by the powers of others.
Watcher: Learns who else, if anyone, targeted their target with a power.
Tracker: Learns who, if anyone, their target targeted with a power.