I was lying, like you told me too. Sheesh. No giving hints via confusion smileys. 
Oh, did I say that out loud?
Ah. So as I understand it, this is strictly worse than Haggle. I gotcha.
-Meeko
Who is glad he sat this one out.
BillMc
NAF
pedescribe
MadTheSwine
Paulwhoisaghost
picker
sinjin
FCoD
ArchiveGuy
Cometothedarksidewehavecookies
Are we allowed to trade story pieces via PM?
Wrong order. 
It shouldn’t be TOO hard. If I were playing the game, I’d ask everyone to post, say, a keyword in their sentence…or ask around things like (example): “Does anyone else’s bit talk about birdcages?”
It is impossible to work out if nobody gives some info. You all need to work together for a bit and at first…and stab each other in the back LATER.
Yes.
And your order is wrong. 
By the way…the guesses actually ARE subtly getting closer and closer here and there, so apparently the game can be figured out.
Apparently Jack likes matches.
And there’s a bear! A hungry bear…
–FCOD
Willing to trade story pieces straight up… Send me a PM with your piece and I will reply with mine.
No takers?
Idle, I’ll trade you my story piece for any story pieces you may have. eh?
I don’t have any parts.
Well… this game isn’t gonna be any fun if no one posts…
BillMC
picker
sinjin
MadTheSwine
NAF
ArchiveGuy
pedescribe
FCoD
Paulwhoisaghost
Sometimes there’s only one way to go where you want to be.
Oops… that should say
BillMC
picker
sinjin
MadTheSwine
NAF
Cookies
ArchiveGuy
pedescribe
FCoD
Paulwhoisaghost
That’s not even all of the people!
But no.
What makes you think you have the ending part? 
Picker want to swap story bits? umm… assuming that wasnt your story bit that is…
You’re a funny guy… thanks for the mod assisted WiFoM. A little unfair though don’t you think?