I suppose my piece might not be the end…
BillMC
ArchiveGuy
Cookies
Paulwhoisaghost
picker
NAF
MadTheSwine
pedescribe
sinjin
FCoD
Alright… Idle said we might have to work together to get this thing figured out… so her’s hoping I get some info out of this.
Today, 09:27 AM
Idle Thoughts Idle Thoughts is offline
Charter Member
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Arizona
Posts: 3,972
Send a message via AIM to Idle Thoughts Send a message via Yahoo to Idle Thoughts
Story bit.
The End.
It’s just me and story online right now.
Psst, story, I will trade you my bit of story for all the bits of story you have.
Seriously though folks, I am willing to do one to one trades of story bits with anyone who is online at the same time I am. I am not interested in sorting through the lists you post and figuring things out from there. Join me in my quest to narrow the pool. I figure if 5 of us band together we can make the possibilities small enough that we can force guess the rest.
Cookies
BillMc
NAF
Paulwhoisaghost
picker
NAF
MadTheSwine
pedescribe
ArchiveGuy
FCoD
sinjin
I don’t expect to get much more with negotiating, but at least that NAF is an honorable man of his word…or is he…
Er… I meant:
Cookies
BillMc
NAF
Paulwhoisaghost
picker
MadTheSwine
pedescribe
ArchiveGuy
FCoD
sinjin
That one makes more sense. Though I think mine can’t possibly be right where you have it. I would guess:
Cookies
BillMc
Paulwhoisaghost
NAF
picker
MadTheSwine
pedescribe
ArchiveGuy
FCoD
sinjin
All are wrong, however **Cookie’**s post 65 has the most people in the right places and **Paul’s **post 62 is the MOST correct so far (in terms of people being around ALL their right places).
NAF you’re colder than Cookies is.
Cookies
BillMc
NAF
Paulwhoisaghost
picker
ArchiveGuy
MadTheSwine
pedescribe
sinjin
FCoD
Nope, but you’re still a little over halfway kinda close.
Really, impressive that you can do it so well without anyone much else revealing what parts they have (yet) or making hints as to what part they have…or having guessed and put themselves in a list where they think they are themselves yet.
But then again, I knew it wouldn’t be extremely hard. Over time it’ll get easier and easier. I wouldn’t be surprised if someone got the correct order tomorrow…but just remember…
it takes working together a bit.
So I hope those silent so far will come in at a point and give a little. 
Cookies
BillMC
NAF
ArchiveGuy
picker
MadTheSwine
pedescribe
sinjin
FCoD
Paulwhoisaghost
Cookies
BillMC
ArchiveGuy
Paulwhoisaghost
NAF
picker
MadTheSwine
sinjin
pedescribe
FCoD
Really?
Interesting.
The other guess is off.
This one is more correct and probably tied for one being the “most right” so far if not THE most right so far.
Cookies
BillMC
NAF
picker
pedescribe
ArchiveGuy
MadTheSwine
sinjin
FCoD
Paulwhoisaghost
Idle, closer or further away than my last guess?
Paul, PM on its way.
Please take “most right so far” very liberally. MOST RIGHT SO FAR could still mean it’s pretty wrong. 
It’s hard to say.
Some things are right in this one that you had wrong in the other…but other things are wayyyyy off (that weren’t in the other). : p
Cookies
BillMC
NAF
pedescribe
picker
ArchiveGuy
MadTheSwine
sinjin
FCoD
Paulwhoisaghost
How about now?
Why am I getting the feeling that the cake is a lie?