Not really an IMHO advice thread, not really a Pit rant…
I am so Marcia Brady. There are two guys vying for my attention. I sometimes wish I were Jan. 
About four and a half years ago, I met this nice boy called Danny. We went out for a few months, but his feelings for me got really romantic and I didn’t reciprocate. So I had to dump him. 
I’ve only ever dumped a few guys; usually I’m the “dumpee.”
I was out one evening with another ex, Sean, and I introduced him to Danny. They went on to live this happy (?) living together thing for a couple of years.
So Danny calls me up last night and tells me he and Sean broke up a few months ago, and that he lives down the street, can he come over?
So he did. And my feelings for him are different. He’s not the sharpest tool in the shed, but he’s sweet, romantic, and friggin hot as hell.
Now there’s the guy I met last week, and Danny. I don’t know which one to go with.