Star Wars: The Bad Batch on Disney + [Open Spoilers]

Not a bad finale.

Unless I missed something (and I was a bit distracted while watching at points), I don’t think they ever revealed what the deal was with those super duper commandos. The most common theory is they were clones of Tech or something. They went out of their way even in this episode to never show their faces.

Hemlock says it (paraphrasing), “If you survive the conditioning, you’ll make excellent operatives.” They are regular clones who have been conditioned to be super-soldier slaves to him.

Ah, I did hear that and did not make that connection. Thanks.

Umm, doesn’t the Empire know about Pabu? Wouldn’t that be the first place they would look for the Bad Batch (et al)?

Brian
May the 4th be with you!

Maybe after Hemlock’s death, no one left actually cares?

Yeah all the data was lost. Anyone who knew there was anything special about Omega was either killed or on her side. I guess though someone does take up the mantle because we know that Palpatine does indeed get his clones.

It sucked.

I mean, it was a great season finale, but a lousy series finale. A whole season setting up a bunch of mysteries, and then… nothing. No explanations on what Project Necromancer is. No explanations on why they were collecting force-sensitive children and what they were doing with them. No explanations on the super-commando clones. What the hell?

Seemed obvious that Project Necromancer is whatever ended up producing Snoke and Palapatine II (so they must have recreated the project later). As for the rest, I don’t disagree. But my expectations were middling – I think Bad Batch was a fun series, but it never seemed any better than “this is fun kiddified Star Wars stuff” to me. The finale met that low bar, IMO.

Maybe, maybe not. Anyone can make guesses, but a fanwank is not the same as thing as giving viewers a satisfying resolution. If it’s so obvious, why didn’t they just confirm it?

It all reeks of J.J. Abrams-style “mystery boxes”.

I hated every second of this stupid show but I stuck with it thinking it would come together in the end. That there was a greater purpose, a hidden connection, an invisible piece of the puzzle. So in some ways the ending was perfect because it fit the rest of the show, but overall it was just hot garbage of nothing. Just a shaggy dog story or close enough to it for my taste.

Oh, wait. i didn’t hate every second. I liked when Kanan/Caleb got away

All these interstitial Star Wars series, set during the dark times of the rise of the Empire, can only do so much with satisfying endings, because it’s still a bleak time period where many more atrocious things will continue to happen. So any tantalising things left hanging are sure to be addressed one day, but saved up for other shows.

This was just one story in amongst many, and it set some things up but not to pay them off; that’s for future stories. I know that’s unsatisfying, but it’s just how producer Dave Filoni thinks.

I hope we see more from Omega, though. That’s a character with potential.

At some point, I’m going to get tired of him jerking me around. You want to make me happy? Write a good story, with a beginning, a middle and an end, and when you’re done, write another one. It’s as simple as that.

The show was uneven but this season was over all better.

I forgot to add in my last post… I am starting to wonder if I just don’t like SW at all any more. I hated Andor, I didn’t like Obi Wan very much, Ahsoka was a let down. I didn’t like Book of Boba Fett, although I still did like S3 of Mando… mostly. I didn’t like the Empire shorts yesterday, but I did like the last batch of Jedi ones.

I even tried to watch TLJ yesterday, which I’ve always really liked, and I just got mad at it and had to turn it off. I, like everyone else seemingly, hated ROS. So if very little is bringing me joy and happiness… maybe I just like the first trilogy and Grogu?

Hated Andor? Insanity!

I’d place Bad Batch as better than most of the recent live action stuff and could have come together a bit better at the end. More mature and even darker than much, most, of the live action, not as much as Andor. Not as good as Clone Wars or Rebels. Or S1 of Mando.

Unfortunately we know Project Necromancer gets restarted and succeeds without Hemlock. And since Omega contains some secret sauce for it she may be destined for a bad end in some future show.

Clones age quickly but Omega less so? What is going on elsewhere in the SW universe as she goes off to join the fight?

I’m somewhere between? It can be both. Both so many threads left loose in so many stories many of which not all viewers have watched, or remember even if they did? It makes the attempts to use them later unsatisfying too.

As illustration: I just quickly watched the first Empire short and I know of Morgan Elsbeth, mainly from Ahsoka. Clearly she’s also on other episodes of shows I’ve missed or forgotten. I imagine there are some viewers who are thrilled to see her origin story but it is not interesting as a stand alone to those who are anxious for those bits of lore.

There’s a difference between leaving a loose thread or two, and setting up a season-long mystery and not solving it.

Do we? We don’t know what it is. We can guess what the writers will eventually tell us it is, but nothing more. That’s the thing about fiction: there are no solutions to mysteries until the writers write them. We can guess all we want, but we can’t actually solve anything because the solution doesn’t exist.

So yes, Necromancer can be the “somehow” in “Somehow, Palpatine survived.” But the next series can suddenly decide it’s something else entirely. We have no way of knowing until they tell us.

Also, on a much more nerdy note, how could Tarkin be referring to Project Stardust, when Galen Erso, who gave it that name, only became involved in it 5 years later?

My understanding was that Erso was involved very early, then left the project (and presumably tried to hide out), and at the beginning of Rogue One was forcibly brought back (Krennic said “we were this close…” or something like that). So in his early involvement, he named the project.

My understanding is they need Omega’s blood because without it there was no way to make a Force-sensitive Palpatine clone.

Project Necromancer

"As you know, M-count cannot be directly replicated from the source. However, Nala Se found another way which is why she aided in Omega’s escape. The young clone’s blood is the only binder that’s proven to be compatible with their DNA to recreate their M-count levels. "