Reminded me of Herman’s Head, of all things. Cast of quirky young up-and-comers with a few respected veterans thrown in, unusual concept, starts out very funny with some truly brilliant moments, not afraid to get weird, highly enjoyable for about the first half of its existence, eventually settles into various conventions, eventually falls into a rut, eventually makes some VERY bad decisions, but manages to leave on a relatively high note and before getting truly execrable. So…a solid thumbs-up.
And (you probably saw this coming), I’m going to have to go completely against the consensus on Fez and Laurie. These were the two characters that did not work for me at all. Okay, Fez. I could envision a character starting as a moronic, pig-ignorant, stumbling, incoherent, constantly embarrassing buffoon being successful, so long as he eventually grows out of it, or at least develops some kind of twist. “No! Forget it! I’m through being an embarrassment to others! Which is also why I’m never going to tell you about Kelso’s bizarre addiction to…er…oh, wouldn’t you like to know!” But he never does, and it got freaking old. Along with that “guess the nationality” that wore out its welcome about midway through the first season. As for Laurie…look, I’ll make it real simple. Overbearing twit who gets away with it most of the time and at least serves some purpose (C.M. Burns, Bender, Mayor of Townsville, Bushwhacker Bob, and, yes, Jackie): potentially good. Completely obnoxious, irredeemable eternal Karma Houdini: freaking dreary. No, not aggravating, she didn’t even rise to that level. Nobody even tried to make her anything resembling a human being, she was simply a collection of irksome qualities with a face and voice. That “good girl/bad girl” crap just compounded it.
Other than that…liked. Yeah, it was good. Not blisteringly witty like early Friends, or endearingly poignant like The Cosby Show, or unrepentantly off-the-wall like Perfect Strangers, but it had top-notch acting (have to agree with everyone who said that Kurtwood Smith and Topher Grace put on a clinic) and really respected the source of material, and…well, I almost never considered it a waste of time. (Heavens, I do use that damning-with-faint-praise thing a lot, don’t I?)
The only real surprise for me was that this was what launched Ashton Kucher’s movie career. “Big lovable lunkhead” isn’t exactly a challenging role.