The best store-bought eggnog, in your opinion

I am talking “Holy Crap! Now That’s What I Call Eggnog!” good. No alcohol added versions, please.

Please ignore this post.

I don’t see the point of eggnog without alcohol, so don’t buy it, and even if I did the Canadian versions would likely not be available in the US and vice versa.

Food & Wine lists their favourites after testing over a dozen. No doubt one of these is locally available…

Excerpt:

  1. Hood Golden Eggnog
  2. Turkey Hill Egg Nog
  3. Cream-O-Land Holiday Style Eggnog
  4. Farmland Fresh Dairies Premium Egg Nog
  5. Ronnybrook Farm Dairy Egg Nog
  6. Organic Valley Eggnog Reduced Fat
  7. 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Eggnog
  8. Trader Joe’s Egg Nog
  9. Southern Comfort Traditional Egg Nog
  10. Lactaid Lactose-Free Eggnog
  11. Califia Farms Almond Milk Holiday Nog
  12. O’ Nog Non-Dairy Oat Beverage
  13. So Delicious Dairy Free Coconut Holiday Nog
  14. Malk Holiday Nog Almond Malk

https://www.foodandwine.com/eggnog-taste-test-11866043

America’s Test Kitchen recommends aging homemade stuff for weeks. They also have non-alcoholic versions more up your alley, but aging it requires alcohol to sterilize the egg.

Excerpt:

How to Make Aged Eggnog

Follow the steps below to make the smoothest, most-well balanced egg nog. Or, if you have a favorite eggnog recipe, use 1 1/2 ounces of 80 proof liquor for every egg, and leave out the dairy until serving.

  1. Stir together a dozen beaten eggs, 1 1/2 cups of bourbon, 1/2 cup of cognac, and 1/3 cup of dark rum; add 1 1/2 cups of sugar.
  2. Refrigerate the 18-percent-alcohol mixture in an airtight container.
  3. After three weeks, pour the base through a fine-mesh strainer to remove any egg solids.
  4. Mellow out the mixture with 6 cups of whole milk and ½ cup of cream, bringing it down to about 8 percent alcohol

Source:

The Best Eggnog Is Old Eggnog | America's Test Kitchen

Personal favorite.
Store bought.
Non-alcohol.

Moderating:

Way to fully ignore the OP. Seriously, if you were a problematic poster this would be warning level thread shit as a first reply.

I’ll just hide your post.

The Southern Comfort version is my go to.

We have a local dairy called Loch Mead that makes my personal favorite commercial egg nog. I allow myself one quart per season and mostly put it in coffee. No alcohol.

Is it alcohol-free?

Yes. Find it at your favorite grocery store. I think I used Jim Beam once instead of SC. A little nutmeg, if so inclined.

Plus, it comes in quart sizes — for those of us watching our weight — because I could down a whole gallon in one sitting.

Yes. I’ve seen it in the dairy section.

My Daddy always had alcohol Southern Comfort in an eggnog. He generally purchased his nog from the Grocery store in a 1/2 gallon milk jug thingy. I don’t remember its name. But I’m sure it was a generic type thing. He dolled it up with spices and Southern comfort and called it his own. With flair.

He was a mess, that man!

(His pro-tip: a dash of white pepper added to the half gallon)

When we were kids, the neighbor would use the most disgusting rotgut in his nog. Plus it was watery. Very unsatisfactory.

Agreed. It’s super rich and creamy.

I like Hood Golden eggnog. I’m always disappointed when i try other brands. I usually add a dusting of nutmeg, but it’s really good without adding booze.

(Boozy eggnog is almost a different category, honestly, although i like it, too.)

The Southern Comfort Brand and Hood are the ones I like best. Something off about Turkey Hill.

Reminder to all, this thread is not about adding alcohol to Eggnog.

Many brand taste a little “off” to me. Not spoiled, just like there’s something unpleasant lurking there. I wonder if it’s an attempt to make them taste like they contain booze.

:: wink, wink :: :grin:

Hood Golden for the major national brands.
There’s a local one from Purity Ice Cream that is outstanding, but really pricey.
Never seen Southern Comfort nog.

Southern Comfort is really good (and I’m talking about the non-alcoholic version) but my favorite is Darigold, specifically the “old fashioned” version.