Um… I too had a handlebar moustache until recently. More of the Salvador than the Irishman. I’ll tell you more than you ever wanted to know about 'em, but I’ve never consulted an official guide or anything. I’ve used two types of wax. Hold on a sec and let me check the bathroom…
Okay, first, there’s the “chapstick” style. It’s a hard wax, about the consistency of a good caranuba paste wax, comes in a stick just like the lip stuff. Harder than chapstick, which I regret to say I have also tried in a pinch. This parictular stuff is pretty good, and will hold a one-inch moustache in a Snidely Whiplash for at least half a day without reapplication, and a good shorter handlebar in an upturn curve for most of the day. It doesn’t really dry; you just have to shape it and sit still for a couple of seconds. It’s ingredients read:
Petrolatum, Candelilla Wax, Hydroxylated Lanolin, Castor Oil, Microcrystalline Wax, Beeswax, Fragrance, BHA & BHT
It is distributed by: Cook Bates/Cosmetico Co., Inc., Venice FL 34292.
I give the above address because it is the only tolerable moustache wax I ever used. It came in conjunction with a nice little kit (wax, scissors, comblet, twizzler) I got one Christmas, so I don’t know how much it costs.
The paste stuff that comes out of a toothpaste tube sucks. It’s not nearly as strong when it dries and is more prone to “breaking,” when the 'bar separates into two or more separate strands, and you wind up looking like you have Vishnu dancing on your nose, or worse, a well-used metal brush. On the other hand, it’s not nearly as brittle, so it may be intended for the more natural look.
Care and feeding of a handlebar is kind of a pain. It requires near constant trimming, and if you’re a tweaker like I was you wind up crinkling the ends and have to trim those, which makes it hard to grow past a certain length. Only once did I grow it long enough to sport a Rollie Fingers-type 'stache that curled back on itself, but I was happy when I did because it stuck together better. The stache is shaped by thumb and forefinger. That can be a technique all to itself. In my case, one half always wants to curve up, while the other naturally goes down, so I had to be very careful which direction I was twisting. I never got the hang of that twizzler thing; it might have been thrown into the kit merely as a novelty.
I used to wash the stuff out nightly, but I drink a lot and I sometimes wind up in strange places. Results of sleeping on a waxed moustache vary from hilarious to disastrous. Girls seem to get a kick out of a mildly mussed-'stache, especially when one end turns up and the other down, which mine was prone to do. Somewhere in the middle it looks sort of like having a toilet brush on your face. At the extreme end, a solidly waxed moustache can actually break, forcing a scorched-earth trim job and weeks or months of recovery. Plus, you look like a total idiot until you can get home. It was this latter outcome which put my latest efforts to rest.
There is one other thing about handlebar moustaches which should be mentioned. People tend to laugh at you, or possibly with you, when you’ve got a really good one. There is just something silly about a crazy waxed 'stache that really brings out the mirth in people. I always liked that.