the Christmas Card Rant (long, weak first effort)

This year I made a special effort to mail out my cards before Christmas. Made them from a kit, very simple blue with a tie-on metal snowflake. Extra postage. I printed up the message inside myself, and that took days to get lined up just right. Simple message…Peace on Earth, Goodwill to all…May the spiritof Christmas Live in your hearts Throughout the Year, Love, Kittenblue. Nice, simple. Mailed them out after the last pick-up on the 22nd.

On the 23rd, I get a voice mail from a guy I had dated for three years. Who had said he considered me part of the family, and wanted to stay friends, even though he got married suddenly last November only four months after he broke up with me. I still sometimes babysit for his grandchild, and his son is a friend. We haven’t spoken since his wedding, but I sent him and his bride a card last year. The year before I had given him a set of personalized ornaments for his whole family, so I sent them another ornament in last year’s card with the new bride’s name on it, so that she would feel included in his family. Never heard a word, or got a card back, but that’s okay. I sent them a card this year, and had already decided that if I got no response this year, they are off the list for next year. Now bear in mind this was a three year, platonic relationship. At no point were we lovers. He told me that she didn’t believe him when he told her that, and I cattily said “why would you marry someone who doesn’t believe you when you’re telling the truth?” She and I met exactly once, and the impression I got of her and their relationship is that she is a ball-breaker. She even drives a bigger pick-up truck than him. He is a great guy, a religious, church-going man, and was a good friend. I figured a Christmas card would be an inoffensive way to stay in touch with an old friend. I send cards to lots of people I don’t speak to from year to year, and I’m sure you do too. End of backstory.

So I get this voice mail, in which he is yelling at me. Yelling, in a rage. I’ve never heard him raise his voice. Telling me to never send any communication to his address again and to just get on with my life. I’d quote it exactly since I saved the message, but I can’t bear to hear it again. I’m sitting there, stunned, listening to this. Amazed first that the card arrived the next day from when I had mailed it. And just flabbergasted. This happened on a very stressful day (I work retail) and I really took this angry response hard. I was first embarrassed that my simple card had caused such a reaction, and my first response was to be upset with myself for sending the card. Being so close to a stress-induced emotional meltdown anyway, the call almost tipped me into tears. Fortunately a guy I am seeing called at that moment, and in telling him the story I began to see more to this story.

When I got divorced, my ex-husband would occasionally call me and scream at me like that, especially if I had asked him to do something with the kids that involved me at all. Then he would call to apologize, telling me that his new wife was insanely jealous of me and would scream at him until he’d call to bitch me out, generally with her listening. Then the next time he’d have to call and scream at me, I knew what was going on. Didn’t make me respect him at all, but I didn’t take it so personally any more. Still hurt.

But I realized that this must be what happened with the Christmas card. She got all bent out of shape and made his life hell, and the only way to appease this woman he married was to act as if he was enraged at me too and call and leave that message. Probably with her standing right there, making sure he did it. I should feel sorry for him, considering what his home life must be like now, never knowing when the smallest thing is going to send her into a rage. She probably hits him, too, or at least punishes him for every slight and slip-up.

My first reaction is to take the whole incident and react with dignity and decorum, and just never, ever send a card again. I even pulled the card for his son out of the pile waiting to be mailed, lest he be offended by me mailing something to a whole 'nother household.

My second reaction is to call and leave him (and her) a voicemail, letting them know how that call had ruined my holiday and that they are both assholes.

Of course, I didn’t do that. That would be childish, and petty, and spiteful, and would ultimately make me look bad. So instead, I have been practising what I would say if I ever, ever ran into him again at the store, andI will post it here in the Pit, and get this off my chest and my heart. So here it is.

" I got your voice mail, and I want to reassure you that I won’t ever make the mistake of wishing you and your wife a Merry Christmas again. I was going to react as a mature adult who has unintentionally given offense and apologize, but then I realized that that kind of woman doesn’t really appeal to you, so here it is, in terms that impress you more. You are a fucking asshole, and I hope your life in the coming year is a misery. I sent you a fucking Christmas card, wishing you Peace on Earth, for crying out loud. It wasn’t an erotic love letter. It was addressed to both of you, as man and wife. Yes, it was signed “love, kittenblue”, but that was PRINTED on there…everyone got one signed like that. If you had just ignored it, I would have taken you off the list for next year. But apparently the spirit of Christmas doesn’t even live in your heart at Christmas time, you asshole. I thought you were a good, church-going man, but you are nothing but a pussy-whipped asshole who hasn’t the balls or the backbone to stand up for himself. I understand that saying “I want to still be friends, you are part of this family, etc” is just politeness to someone you are breaking up with, but what I did doesn’t deserve this kind of venom. I hope that the next time you are sitting there in church, you will think about whether the God you profess to love really wants you to scream at people who wish you peace and good will. And rather than feel sorry for you for being stuck with a wife who can’t handle a Christmas card from an old friend, I’m glad your life will be miserable. How many other friends is she cutting you off from? Can you go out with Bill any more? Can you talk to that nice woman at work that you used to help out? Has she cut you off from your ex-wife and your kids yet? Better watch your step, asshole, because if they offend her, you won’t be seeing that sweet grandbaby much. Have a happy New Year, you jerk, and remeber that if you buy her the wrong gift for Valentine’s Day, your life will be hell. But that’s the kind of woman who gets you hot, so go have a great life, and have a Merry Christmas. Asshole."

I said it was weak.

As someone who used to have a fair number of male friends, I can tell you you’re not alone. There is a breed of woman out there who will not allow her husband/boyfriend/significant other to acknowledge that there are other women in the world, and that he may possibly be acquainted with one or two of them.

There’s one guy in particular who I was friends with, then dated for a little bit, then was friends with again. At one point (after we dated) he told me I was one of his best friends in the whole world. When Mr. Athena and I moved back to my hometown, which is also where my friend lives, I made some gestures at being friends with him and his then-fiance. He blew me off every time.

Later I found out that he cut ties with all of his female friends. He was the type of guy who had a lot of friends, and a lot of them were female. Didn’t matter if they were casual friends, ex-girlfrends, or simply acquaintances. If he got “caught” talking to a female in a social situation, she would get in the other woman’s face and tell her to leave her guy alone.

I never got this kind of woman. All I can figure is that they’re very insecure, and think that their guy will very easily be led astray.

You’re nicer than I would be. I’d start sending drippy ‘Really miss you, any chance we can get together?’ love notes each and every holiday.

I mean, if you’re going to get a reaction like you did, you might as well have the fun of winding up his wife deliberately.

Insecurity is exactly what it is. It takes a special kind of person to look at a simple, kind gesture and see a come-on attempt. I’m sorry that happened to you, kittenblue. It was a despicable thing to have happen, especially during the holidays.

I was engaged. We broke up but I remained in contact for about three years, sending him birthday and holiday cards. Then he met the woman he eventually married. She highly objected to him having any contact with me. I let him go, and feel it was for the best. It was hard, but whatevah. He made his choice, and while I truly wish him happiness, I doubt he has found it with her.

I actually thought about doing that! But not drippy. Just to the two of them, like I did with the Christmas card, addressed to Mr. & Mrs…but for every conceivable holiday. And I should mention that I had sent him a birthday card two months before, but it was in no way sweet or sentimental…it was a FarSide card about an elderly guy in a wheelchair popping balloons. And it wasn’t signed Love. Just my name. Now I wonder if she’s been giving him hell ever since then!

I would have gone with this. The time has passed though, for any kind of response that wouldn’t make it look like you’re giving his reaction more thought than it deserves.

It’s their loss. I’ll never understand people who act like that. None of us have enough good people in our lives, and here they are, throwing a nice gesture in your face.

Are you still going to babsit for his grandchild? Better clear it with his wife first. :wink:

The only thing I would say about how you handled this is that it’s not fair to you OR his son to pull his card from the mailpile. Not his fault that his Dad married a jealous, raving lunatic, and he deserves your good wishes. You deserve to send a holiday card to whomever the hell you want to send one to.

I don’t understand that mindset, either. I briefly dated a guy who was like that. No male friends for me. No exes, certainly. No lesbian friends, either. He trusted no one, least of all me, despite the fact that I am trustworthy. Once I saw what was going on, and realized that he was reading from a script that had nothing to do with me, and therefore could never include my wants or needs, I ran in the other direction.

Happy holidays, kittenblue. Your cards sound lovely.

You bitch.
But seriously, if you’re too nice to feel some smug satisfaction at the state of Mr. Pussywhipped Asshole’s marriage, I’m happy to do it for you.

This is perfect. I’d mail it to him. Seriously. I might even be inclined to address a seperate copy to his wife, to make sure she gets to see it.

How about “Do you scream at your other mistresses too?”

You didn’t do a thing wrong and have nothing to regret! Get rid of that recording; it will only serve to remind you of how much his words hurt. It’s good that you wrote it all down here instead of mailing it out – as tempting as it was.

She probably pitched a bitch and he took it out on you or she made him call. Either way, he’s a jerk. Be glad he is someone else’s problem.

Next year’s Christmas greeting?

Clear your mind. New Year. Refocus. Bad man go away.

Peace.

I suggest that you send him an early Valentine’s Day card. Here’s what you write:

"Wow. Thank you so much for the head’s up re: my Christmas cards. I just thought that I was wishing everyone peace on Earth; I wasn’t aware that I was actually sending out booty calls in letter form. Your voicemail set me straight and better prepared me for the onslaught that followed.

You see, I sent everyone the same card with the same wording, and if it was so offensive to you (who I considered my good friend) I could only imagine what everyone else in my life must now think of me.

Sure enough, my postman hasn’t delivered my mail in days, my drycleaner can’t even meet my eyes, and my co-workers have filed a joint sexual harassment suit. Don’t even get me started on the ‘Let’s Just Be Friends’ speech my dad pulled me aside to deliver on Christmas Eve. Can you say ‘uncomfortable’?

Anyway, you have set me straight, and I now see the error of my ways. I will stop relentlessly pursuing you, one greeting card at a time."

I (heart) Susie Derkins! (And I mean that in an admiring way, not in an over-the-top sexual greeting card kind of way).

I’m sorry you got shouted at and I think you have nailed the reason.

I had a couple of good friends who got married to women who promptly said they couldn’t waste time playing chess or bridge with me. Ever.
One friend got divorced (not because of the above) and we are best mates. I’ve never heard from the other again.

I think you should do whatever makes you happiest in this situation.
Sending a righteously indignant challenge will no doubt satisfy you, but will raise the stakes and may cause a future fracas.
How about writing a tremendous response, then burning it? lots of symbolism there!

I think we should all send kittenblue Xmas cards next year!

I’m sorry you feel bad, getting yelled at isn’t fun.

however you state in your OP that you haven’t talked to him since his wedding, which means he ignored gifts and cards before. He’s now clearly stated he wants no further communication from you.
I suggest that may be you safest action. I don’t know your jurisdiction, but in some places some of the suggestions made here can get you into potentially legal hassel. you don’t want to be Accused of harrassement.

Susie, may I put you on my payroll?

I suggest you set this bit to music and record it. I’d buy it!

I would be so tempted to leave that voice mail.

I am in no way defending this new wife of his, but there are men out there who keep their female friends and guess what? Not all of them are Betty and Archie.

It has been my experience that some (not all) of those friends either start competing with the wife (as in let’s share an anecdote that relates how close we came to Doing It or even sharing the time we Did It back in the day-this has happened to me, btw) or else hubby uses these friends to complain about new wife–a sort of emotional cheating–(and so has this). It ain’t pretty. I tend to look at female friends of my husband’s slightly askance now. I don’t do anything close to what has been described here. :eek:

I think this woman is driving this nonsense and I in no way accuse kittenblue of doing what I described. But it does happen.