The Most Maudlin Song Award goes to...

First one that came to mind! I only heard that song once in my life, on the radio, IIRC 1972 at age 14, and I still sing it in my head occasionally (though I don’t remember many of the words.) Love that song! It’s a riot.

Good one.

Doesn’t ANYTHING by Air Supply qualify?

ah yeah, of course.

No kidding!

Without listening to the ones I don’t know, I award this the winner so far!

Delighted to hear it.

What do you get if you play a country song backwards?

You get your dog back, you get your truck back, you get your girl back …

Bonus points for truly stupid lyrics. And yeah, the “Oh no”.

Looking forward to having time to don my headphones and listen to the ones I haven’t heard!

My Little Home In Tennessee, by The Carter Family
A lot of you probably never heard of this one. My father used play it on his guitar and sing it. As a child I always found it upsetting and didn’t understand why he would sing something so maudlin.
I think what does it is the line “How I wish I’d never caused her pain”.
He grew up in the Pennsylvania Appalachians in what was literally a little shack (like in the song) so I suppose it resonated with him. I don’t think he ever played it again after his mother passed away.
(It’s the first song in this clip).

Pretty much all the Bee Gees’ 1960s stuff, but special mention to How Can You Mend a Broken Heart and I’ve Just Gotta Get a Message to You.

Man, I now feel sorry for Dan Fogelberg who made a career out of maudlin’ songs, but, going by this thread, is apparently forgotten today. :frowning:

Leader of the Band

Same Auld Lang Syne

Make Love Stay

I love(d) SALS - a very pretty song. On the other hand, you can hear the hippie/drippy pretentiousness behind the writing of “Make Love Stay” in the liner notes:

:rolleyes:

Oh well, it’s a different time now.

don’t give up on us by DavId Soul and as long as we’re talking Rod McEwen how about MacArthur Park

Ninja’d on MacArthur Park but I cant believe that no one has said patches by Clarence Carter

That’s pretty flippin bleak, but what makes it really stinging is the sardonic observation “sunshine walked beside her”.

Oh great my computer decided to update when I realized I was thinking of “Tecumseh Valley”. Which would also count.

The winner has already been mentioned above and it’s, of course, “Rocky” by Austin Roberts which includes these awesome lyrics.

Some other candidates that haven’t been mentioned yet

“Don’t Cry Daddy” Elivs Presley
“Love, Me” Collin Raye
“Paint Me A Birmingham” Tracy Lawrence
“Morning Side of the Hill” Donny and Marie Osmond

“In The Ghetto” by Elvis. I cringe when I hear this song. It enrages others!

It’s not exactly satire, though, since it was something that actually happened to Shel Silverstein. He called up the mother of a girl he was in love with and found out (for the first time) that she had left town to go get married. Of course, Silverstein could laugh at himself as good or better than any of us, so he probably wrote in more maudlin details in order to get over it.

How many country western singers does it take to change a lightbulb?

Five. One to change the bulb and four to sing about how much they miss the old one.

I’m tellin’ ya, you guys are all also-rans. “I Want a Pardon” has to take the cake. It has all the ingredients:

  1. Dead parent, in this case executed in prison.
  2. Crying Child
  3. Praying Mother (“the angels above…”)
  4. Jail
  5. Actions just barely too late to save the condemned…

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N9XkKOjBTwk

Also, it was written in the 1920s, and recorded by various and sundry country artists over the years.

Ya just can’t beat it.

:slight_smile:

John Prine - “Hello in There”. Jeez, makes me feel guilty for just being born.

“You’re Beautiful” by James Blunt.

My favorite glurge:

(as in, I actually like these, but, still…)

Three Cigarettes in an Ashtray–Patsy Cline

Jolene–Dolly Parton

They’re actually kind of the same song, thematically…

Tell Laura I love Her.

Check out the works of Karl & Harty, and others of their ilk:

I Love the Hymns They Sang at Mother’s Grave (“they’re the only things I find that can bring cheer To an orphans life that is so sad and drear”)

The Lightning Express (“I’ve got to get home and kiss mother goodbye Before God takes her away”)

I’m Just Here to Get My Baby Out of Jail (“she kissed her baby boy and then she died…But smiling”)

The years from 1890 to WWI were also quite good for maudlin. In addition to Baggage Coach Ahead there are also such gems as Hello Central, Give Me Heaven ('cause my mommy’s there). I’d list others but am feeling entirely too lachrymose…

Clarence Carter’s Patches. Whenever I mention this song in any maudlin song thread people think it’s a different song by, um, Bobbi Goldboro maybe? Sorry but Clarence walked 10 miles uphill to school both ways while suckling baby pigs and picking cotton along the way. All because his mother just could not deal.

The Streets of El Paso.

A Pair of Brown Eyes, The Pogues.