Thread Killers Official Scorecard

For some reason, I have no problem finishing stupid projects. Now I will have to work on finishing valuable projects.

Below are the killer efficiency ratings for the following combined fora:

The BBQ Pit
MPSIMS
IMHO

It is also possible that some Cafe Society threads were counted, though I tried to take them out when I decided it was time to stop and do something productive.

The period considered is any thread with a last post between 12:00am 10/4 and 11:59pm 10/14. See my previous post for details. For the combined fora list, I have upped the minimum qualification to three killed threads in the period.

Some very high numbers resulted from people experiencing a very recent burst of activity after a long period of no activity since registering.

The first list gives our top twenty killers. To weed out flash-in-the-pan mercenaries, I have limited the list to assassins with at least 700 posts. The second list give the complete results.


Effic Kills Name
===== ===== ====

 38.8  14   Rilchiam
 33.7   7   rocking chair
 28.4   5   Podkayne
 24.5   5   PunditLisa
 24.4   3   pezpunk
 22.6   6   Dijon Warlock
 22.1   4   cazzle
 21.7   3   Baker
 21.0   5   Quasimodem
 19.5   3   DAVEW0071
 17.2   4   Cartooniverse
 15.7   4   Annie X-mas
 15.6   4   Zyada
 15.2   5   Rysdad
 14.9   3   Strainger
 13.7   3   Amazing Tiki God
 12.1   4   GuanoLad
 11.5   3   bean_shadow
 11.5   5   vanilla
 11.3   7   Persephone




Effic Kills Name
===== ===== ====

107.1   3   KeithT
 73.2   3   BigGiantHead
 83.3   3   mornea
 68.1   3   furt
 59.7   4   Iguana Boy
 56.6   3   freshmeat
 55.6   3   tsarina
 39.0   3   5-HT
 38.8  14   Rilchiam
 37.5   3   quinoa
 37.0   3   occ
 35.7   4   mobo85
 35.3   6   whistlepig
 34.5   3   scredle
 33.7   7   rocking chair
 32.3   3   Neurotic
 28.4   5   Podkayne
 28.0   3   White Lightning
 26.8   3   clayton_e
 26.4   7   saepiroth
 24.5   5   PunditLisa
 24.4   3   pezpunk
 23.4   4   Chickenhead
 23.3   3   Shera
 23.0   4   TheOtherOne
 22.6   6   Dijon Warlock
 22.1   4   cazzle
 21.7   3   Baker
 21.0   5   Quasimodem
 20.1   3   Chrome Spot
 20.0   3   Çyrin
 19.5   3   DAVEW0071
 19.0   3   celestina
 17.5   6   zoogirl
 17.2   4   Cartooniverse
 16.3   3   Vinnie Virginslayer
 15.7   4   Annie X-mas
 15.6   4   Zyada
 15.2   5   Rysdad
 14.9   3   Strainger
 13.8   3   bluethree
 13.7   3   Amazing Tiki God
 13.7   3   Slip Mahoney
 12.8   6   gatopescado
 12.1   4   GuanoLad
 11.7  17   Violet
 11.5   3   bean_shadow
 11.5   5   vanilla
 11.3   7   Persephone
 11.0   4   Cougarfang
 10.9   3   Nacho4Sara
 10.7   7   CrankyAsAnOldMan
 10.7   4   Crusoe
 10.7   3   ruadh
 10.2   4   Fiver
 10.1   4   KKBattousai
  9.4   3   Ferrous
  8.7   3   lno
  8.1   5   bibliophage
  8.0   3   Miller
  7.7   3   Green Bean
  7.5   3   Dale the Bold
  7.5   3   Mercutio
  7.4   3   Rue DeDay
  7.4   3   Zette
  6.9   6   dropzone
  6.6   3   Ethilrist
  6.5   3   Scotticher
  6.0   3   elfkin477
  6.0   3   Osiris
  5.9   6   Arden Ranger
  5.9   3   beatle/Ringo
  5.7   4   Anthracite
  5.7   3   screech-owl
  5.4   6   iampunha
  5.3   4   lieu
  5.0   3   matt_mcl
  4.6   3   Johnny L.A.
  4.1   3   ultrafilter
  4.0   3   Badtz Maru
  3.5   3   erislover
  3.5   3   Zenster
  3.3   3   GingerOfTheNorth
  2.9   4   Guinastasia
  2.6   3   handy

Oh, and if anybody needs a baseline:

There are currently approximately 90,000 threads, 18,600 users, and 1,658,700 total posts. Let’s assume the 80/20 rule, so 80% of those posts were done by 20% of the people.

That gives us 72,000 threads, 3,720 users, and 1,327,000 total posts. For simplicity, lets consider each of those threads kills, giving us 72,000 assassin posts.

That is 19.35 kills person and 356.72 posts per person. This is a baseline kill efficiency of 5.4.

Now, I’ve given this entirely too much thought and am going to go do something indicating the presence of a life in my life.

I am in awe of you, obfusciatrist. In your honor, I am adding your info to my seldom used sig.

obfusciatrist:

You are out of control. I love this place. Way to run with it man. 5.4 huh? I wonder how that compares to some other message boards . . .

DaLovin’ Dj

I know I’m breaking a few of obfusciatrist’s rules, but…

DaveW
195 posts in 11 months (including this one)
6 threads killed in timeframe
DOs and MDs (in Comments on Staff Reports)
Point of Order in re MPSIMS v Cafe Society (in ATMB)
NIM! Arrrrgh! Help! (in GQ)
Colloidal Silver Generators? (in GQ)
Are employers legally required to give you breaks? (in GQ)
Yes, It’s Another Moon Hoax Thread (in GD)

Efficiency rating (without GQ or GD): 33.8

Efficiency rating (with GQ and GD): 101.5

Not too shabby, but I see I’ve gotta start working…

I don’t know whether to be bummed or proud to be in the top 20. Given the company I’m keeping, I think I’ll be proud.

BTW, Rysdad, I love your sig!

Wow. To plagiarize another of our more famous members: Evidently, I rock!

And personally, I think I deserve to be allowed in that top-ten group. I don’t have over 700 posts, okay, but I’ve not been a “flash in the pan mercenary.” It’s just that I only reply to threads now and again. Don’t have a high enough opinion of myself to be throwing my voice into the fray all that often. Give me time, I’m sure I’ll keep slaying threads all the way up to 700…

One semi-valid question, though, obfusciatrist. How do I get the second ranking spot even though I obviously only have the third-highest score? Is this a poll-driven thing, like college football rankings? :wink:

  • Dave
    (who’s only recently discovered the “ego search,” and wouldn’t have come in here otherwise)

I kill fully 10% of the threads that I post to. My ability to make a thread die will never cease to amaze me. The majority of my kills come in GQ, so I figure I am just naturally the final authority on things…but watch out, I’ve had some pit kills – this thread could be on its way to extinction!

Here, for your personal edification, is the complete list.

GQ:
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=11587
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=23317
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=77556
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=78508
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=79864
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=95458 (*)

IMHO:
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=64668

The Pit:
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=7662
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=10477
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=78164

E == (K/(P/(M*3))100 == (10/(100/203))*100 == 600

Good luck beating a 600 efficiency rating! (Ok, I recognize obfusciatrist said that GQ threads were to be ignored, but I couldn’t resist their inclusion.)

(*) This thread has a few days left until it reaches the time limit, so it could technically be revived.

PS: This is post number 100 for me! :slight_smile:

Sorting error, BigGiantHead, simple sorting error. Though I am sure that if you try hard enough you can earn the second spot.

SDP, that is why I used the 700 post rule as slightly more valid. The whole equation assumes that a person posts are generally spread through the entire period of their membership. By your date and posts, you should have about 5 posts per month. You have at leas the 10 kills you mention in a two week period. You were posting way over your historical norm, skewing the results badly. This is what I meant by flash in the pan, simply that your posting activity in the considered period was way above normal. Not that you would be gone quickly.

Hey! No fair! I was on holiday between your two check dates!

I’m not just a thread killer, but any threads I start get two replies maximum.

Sucky.

One of the reasons, i think, I’m a threadkiller is because the meat of the thread happens while I’m asleep, and I wake to add my lonely view long after everyone else has moved on.

I killed just about every thread I ever posted in, and I think I deserve to win this prize because I even killed some that I NEVER posted in, just by THINKING about posting on them. I’m not proud of it, but I think of this as a small but deserved consolation prize for being so boring.
P.S. If this thread dies now, you’ll have absolute proof of my “ligamenicide” superiority. Or do I mean “inferiority”?

At this rate, I should make that my sig. :frowning:

See?!! See: I told you I was a thread killer par excellence.
About 12 hours without a post after my last post on this “thread killer” thread! Do I get a prize? What is the prize? Can I get to pick my own prize?

See?? Need more proof?? I RULE. Ruling this bit of thread killing is marginally better than ruling nothing at all. I think I deserve at least an Ode to a Fine Threadkiller as a prize. Since this is in the Pit, I’m sure I need remind noone that “fuck” rhymes with “lame duck”, and “felch” rhymes most admirably with “belch”. <insert smiley>