Nothing posts :Post 90, 119, 125, 186, 206, 211, 503, 1940, 2223, 2667
Drinking posts: 559, 566, 1612, 1631, 2215, 2294, 2349 (also talks about Dawn)
Rule posts: 419, 426
Correction posts: 1187, 1601
Gender: 1729, 1817, 1839
The vast majority of the rest of his posts are just fluff. No real analysis, much like the ones above, except with these I bothered to turn them into links.
post 101 votes for Nesta, after s/he had voted for him. Nesta is scum, we know that, neither of these 2 were in any danger, and it could be scum covering for scum. Or not. Could just be day 1 “fun”
post 405 FOS Hocow, and votes for Autolycus. He mentions the idea, later brought up, of Auto running a double bluff
post 436 unvotes auto, votes to join the lynch mob to get Enfant Terrible. He lays down a trust/distrust list. Trusts glee, Gadarene and zuma and distrusts auto and hocow. No reasons given for any of these, except “auto for being a dick”
post 580 responds to a post from rysto, about the DR, and how the DR is just “whistling in the dark”, mentions death of DET. No analysis.
post 812 responds to post by lakai, about how his posts have no value, says he will post value, and talks about being a guy. His promise of posts with value are a long time coming, if they ever do. They don’t, not until post 1600 (I will get to it) and the math posts.
post 814 -responds to post by fretful, talking about people who switched from auto to EF vote day 1
-talks about hocow again, says can’t define but gives vague reasoning about being a cop and not wanting to out himself, or spotting a hint from someone else and not wanting to out them
-votes hocow
-never explains the switch, beyond it being day 1 and someone dies most likely on a bandwagon
post 861 -responds to hocow, about the FOS, again never says why, just makes a little comment about “voting for him to see what happens” again.
post 1178 -talks about how much thread has grown, unvotes hocow and votes gadarene. No reason given.
post 1186 talks about BM being a vig, and killing at behest of town. No suggestions as to who, nothing important said here. See a pattern yet?
post 1212 -talks about switching votes once BM announces target, nothing else here.
post 1251 -talks about me falling on my sword, unvotes gadarene, votes for me, assassinate Zuma. Nothing else (you know like analysis).
post 1263 -answers me, as I asked him why he thinks BM gets a choice, says nothing beyond oops sorry, I just vote like a townie.
post 1266 responds to Starvingbutstrong proposal of conditional VIG kill, he agrees with the idea. Says nothing else.
post 1600 -something useful, for the first time. Talks about masons and counterclaiming, and how counterclaims may be good for the town, as it gets 1 scum for sure.
-FOS hocow again, but saying does not want to explain further
(Why the hell not? If he was a cop don’t you think he would have investigated more then one person by now? If not he is a lousy cop. I think its just the idea of trying to show cop like attitude while FOS a known non scum is it because he is scum?)
post 1707 -quotes post by glee, which talked about the BM kill and how it pretty much makes BM look good to her. Also hypotheses that nesta was killed by SK to extend game, and talks about the benefit to the SK of announcing vig kill as that allows the sK to choose different target
-malacandra responds with reasonable response, saying its in SK’s favour to shorten not extend game, then talks about how he is uncomfortable with the SK running around, and wants him dead anyway he can be killed
-also mentions that maybe BM is scum, and scum killed Winston smith, admits unlikely but not worth dismissal (further attempts to muddy water maybe?)
post 1708 -wants vig kill on hocow again
post 1711 -response to post by kivvik about SK hitting BM, Malacandra reminds about DR
post 1713 -talks about assumption of DOC protecting BM, again issues caveat that BMmight be scum, but says happy with assumption he isn’t
-talks about trawling thread and getting nothing, but maybe that’s because he is a n00b (due to warning, that is how he spelled it, not an insult)
post 1715 -talks about how SK/VIG don’t know everyone elses roles, and how the scum might have killed to cover BM
post 1717 -offers 2 possibilities, BM is VIG or BM is scum, says him being VIG more likely
post 1720 -talks about how BM head is on the block, and how the town picking a vig kill allows him to say ooops sorry
-also talks about who killed what in the night, and how its more likely that SK got Nesta, and the scum went after BM who was protected by DOC
posy 1721 -random kills are bad, talks about how its good for game to go on as scum might get in an argument and out themselves (odd what with his new posting doesn’t matter stance)
post 1726 -who the doc should have protected, how it should be random
post 1727 -Zuma had asked if BM was not the VIG, shoud VIG out himself
-says no, and how BM could just be vanilla running interference for VIG or how he could be scum and scum will kill who he says unless he says scum, and then they won’t.
post 1730 -hypothetical “if I was SK, I would want VIG out ASAP, and wouldn’t defend the VIG when no FOS was at me” (I am not really sure of the point of this post)
post 1744 -game theory about whom DOC is protecting, says he believes BM is VIG, talks about randomness, etc
-again hocow asks why the FOS, still no reasons given, says it’s a hunch, reluctant to explain as it will give away someone else. Says its better for town
(come on, still on hocow? For so long and no reasons given? In all fairness he has come up with an excuse recently)
post 1842 -says he sucks at this game, likes to only argue game theory and math, unhits Hocow, as know is no longer suspicious of said shout out that he still won’t name. (He has now)
post 2091 -quotes Kat, as Kat FOS’s him
-apologizes for always going after hocow, says he thought he spotted a cop shout-out first day, but again refuses to actually talk about it, makes vague threats against the one who asks for him to explain
-talks about SK winning if they engineer a mob victory, votes for FF and vig kill FCOD
post 2095 -talks about how FCOD claims to have blocked him, 2x in fact, and that it didn’t affect the killing
(why did FCOD say he blocked malacandra 2x? For that matter, why me 1x?)
post 2128 -reiterates that FCOD blocked him 2x, and the night kill dropped once which disallows him being a loose cannon (unless he is leing, which he was), also talks about it being a small chance that he is scum, and that the more he convinces the town he is town, the more scum will value his life. In other words the scum will kill him, but that that would be ok because if he dies and power roles survive.
post 2209 -claims to just be a citizen ; claims to find jsextons claim fishy, as someone as experienced as him would know the DOC in the open is useless
post 2383 -FF goes down for sure, and encourages pima to speak up about GF., and talks about vig kill
(where is your math now? Oh wait, it was because you were happy? You were giddy? Huh?)
post 2386 -talks about FCOD validating him as town (huh? When did he do that? With his blocking?) means nothing, and how it doesn’t mean he is scum either
-vig kill FF (still no math? Oh right, giddy, I forgot)
post 2417 -responds to FOS by hocow, who says
“Malacandra, I have never been so suspicious of you as I am right now. I noticed you voted for a VIG kill of Fern Forest, but did not respond at all to the claim of Auto being the Godfather. I think you may be trying to help your team by voting for the SK, but you are also being on the sly about a Godfather attack. Perhaps, you thought you would side with the town on one issue, thereby hoping we would overlook the fact that you didn’t touch the GF claim. You’re officially number one on my list of unconfirmed players.”
-blames hamster for eating his post, says he say analysis of FF, and autolycus but doesn’t want to start the countdown
-wants SK dead
-no real analysis here, or his math again
post 2419 wants pleonast to out the remaining masons, and says hey we can play chicken with scum that way. (great plan), asks for dissenters. I promptly dissent, as that was a very bad idea IMO.
post 2428 -responds to me, about why masons shouldn’t claim. I used the idea that he himself had talked about way back in post 1600. He seems to have forgotten the only useful he has posted up to now. I wonder why? Could he be fishing for all the masons?
post 2526 -responds to BM talking about idea he had proposed earlier about masons claiming, says it’s a bad idea now, and how unconfirmed townies make it easier to hide beat cop
-votes autolycus
post 2677 -talks about how there will be lots of Qs if SK isn’t killed tonight, pima.
post 2720 -FINALLY talks about his suspicions of hocow, and how he thought aguecheeks response to something (he doesn’t say what) of “ho-ly cow” was a disguised crumb. No matter that it doesn’t say what kind of crumb. And now his math appears. Why did it not appear when it might have done some good? Oh, because he knew FF wasn’t scum at the very least. Now he wants to throw some suspicion of pima.
-talks about how scum want to kill SK too. Of course they do. That is why your math didn’t make an appearance until today. You knew we were going after SK at best, town at worst
post 2721 -says Fretful is correct, glee is wrong, and why is glee wrong? Maybe scum ? slight FOS at glee
post 2737 -responds to lakai voting for him, not with a defense, not with anything useful, just with oh god as if we haven’t lynched each other enough
post 2738 -his math makes another appearance, wonders why he didn’t notice it before. Talks bout the beatcop is useless at ID power roles
-talks about how anyone who argues against plain facts (all the while ignoring the fact the cop is right 50% of the time) should be viewed with suspicion
-again says he is sorry about the hocow thing, and wanted to make sure that his suspicions of aguecheek being beat cop were not ID’d.
-says agrees with lakai and that the ID of the SK or GA can never be confirmed (well so what? You have a better idea on how to get the SK?)
The rest of his posts are our little fight, and more math. Again no analysis, nothing but the fact that I FOS’d him, and my saying the math doesn’t matter, which you know it still hasn’t been shown that it does. Definitely not at this time. Maybe later, when they aren’t a lot of people still left, but not now.