I realized my second vote looked bandwagon-ish when I posted it. But, as has been reiterated, I was suspicious of Malacandra since Day 2. I had even voted for him previously. I was just glad to see someone else’s FOS pointed the same direction as mine.
BTW, I’m a she. 
First, I’d like to propose a naming convention for all Dopers. Men must have a name that ends in a hard consonent or the masculine ‘o’. Women must all have names that end in the feminine ‘a’. Therefore, from here on out I will simply be Brew. I also propose the name changes of Malacandro, StarvingButStronga, and howcowa.
Queuing, I see your reasoning for voting MonkeyMensch. I would be with you on that if you can explain away my reasoning for not voting. Why would a mafia switch their votes from who they knew was not mafia to a person who they knew was mafia. I could see that happening as a smoke screen if their brother mafia was already doomed to have their neck stretched, but to change a vote that makes the top two tied? I can’t see a reason a mafia would do that.
I suppose MM could be the SK, but I’m not willing to vote on a wild guess.
Vote cowgirl
In addition to what Lakai said, her unvote/revote of MadTheSwine worries me, specificially the “But for now, I am not convinced enough to drive this bandwagon, so unvote MadTheSwine.” and then “This is a bandwagon I would rather get behind. unvote Malacandra, vote MadTheSwine.” Makes it sound like a bandwagon for MTS is okay as long as she’s not the one who might get blamed for it.
To be honest I don’t know that I have a great reason for that. Yes, MM did switch his vote onto SP. He had to switch his vote to look townie. Maybe he was confused as to who was leading? Maybe it was just a smokescreen so he (or someone defending him) could say just what you are saying. There is no way that throughout this game scum have not voted for scum. It has to happen at some point. While that point worries me, from what else I see seems to point to scum, to me at least. I believe MM to be scum do to a totality of evidence, and will not be swayed by one point. Particularly since the bandwagon had formed on SP, and it seemed somewhat inevitable that we were going to get enough votes to lynch him.
Here are the posts of posting history, as well as analysis if they came in a different post and defenses if applicable
brewha’s analysis of Lakai (sort of, due to coding issues, used the post he quoted BM)
Monkey Mensch’s rebuttal and my rebuttal of his rebuttal
Lakai’s post about cowgirl/smitty/cowgirl and his analysis of
Fretful on ArizonaTeach and ArizonaTeach’s answer
StarvingButStrong on Brewha and analysis of
ArizonaTeach on StarvingButStrong and StarvingButStrong answers
Kat on Fretful Porpentine and the verdict is
People who asked for an assignment but have not yet submitted:
Cowgirl who was suppose to do Kat (allergies aside)
Aguecheek who was suppose to do Rysto.
For what it’s worth, that was actual suspicion, because his arguments against me didn’t make any sense, and he seemed really desperate to throw accusations in an apparently random direction. I didn’t vote for him because after looking at this other posts, I didn’t see anything that looked especially suspicious to me.
Actually, I was talking about my post in the 1500’s, but that still isn’t 500 posts, so I don’t know where that number I mentioned came from, to be honest.
And you’re still (intentionally?) misunderstanding – the 2nd and 3rd people to go along with the plan were scum. Is it any stretch to think that the 1st person was, too? I’m not talking about who ended up voting for the plan, I’m talking about the first few people who said the plan was a good idea in the first place! Why are you defending **Malacandra ** so hard?
Everybody supported the plan. Well, almost everybody; I really don’t have the time to look back. My issue was with the **way ** the bandwagoning began, and the posting pattern of scum latching on to **StarvingButStrong’s ** proposals and votes.
Votes are all over the place, its still anybodys lynch.
2- Malacandra - (ArizonaTeach, hocow)
1- Aguecheek - (MonkeyMench)
1- brewha - (lakai)
1- cowgirl - (kat)
1- Lakai - (brewha)
1- MonkeyMensch - (Queuing)
1- Pygmy Rugger - (storyteller)
24 hours 15 minutes left before nightfall folks. Time to start making up your mind.
And, as a reminder, a no lynch vote is always a possibility. It hasn’t been discussed since the game started, but it is possible.
Does anyone have the time to do Queuing? I’ve been asking myself why he is so trustworthy. I know the town was pretty hell bent on lynching him back on day two, but for some reason (which I can’t recall) he has gone from least trusted to more-or-less trusted.
I’m beginning to not trust Queuing - for two reasons. First there’s his dogged pursuit of Monkeymensch. I don’t know for sure if Monkey is a town or mafia, but there is at least one event that makes him more likely to be town than mafia.
Then, there’s my case against Lakai. OK, I could be wrong about him, but I’m quite certain he’s scum. Queuing didn’t even entertain my accusation. He just brushed it off and went on to make a different case.
Anyone else have an opinion about Lakai? Anyone want to wade through Queuing’s posts? I’m gonna go back to the day two mess and see if I can find what detracted from the mistrust toward Queuing.
Sorry, I didn’t see the assignment on Friday evening when I had time, so I bit the bullet and did Queuing instead. It’s all coded and bolded, but probably contains a lot of my shorthand notes, 'cause it was frigging long, and I am loath to go over it again…
And I just tried posting it and it seems I screwed up the coding. Give me a bit.
Looking forward to your Queuing report. I went back over the day two voting. I still don’t have a good read on Queuing, but it is leaning less scummy than it was before.
I did want to adress this issue, but couldn’t at the time of my unvote. After I was certain that Autolycus was the Godfather (yes, I now realize that I was very wrong), I didn’t see a reason to delay the lynching.
After thinking about it for awhile, I realized that there was a very good reason to delay his death. If he were the GF, mafia would be popping up out of the woodwork to defend him. Since, I could see no way to defend his remarks, those that were actually defending him were likely mafia. I couldn’t come out and say that that is why I unvoted him, because the mafia would clam up about it. Of course, this would have only worked had Auto actually been the GF…
Nothing posts: 21, 60, 87, 145, 223, 229, 435, 444, 446, 453, 455, 474, 486, 516, 549, 563, 582, 973, 982, 1004, 1034, 1072, 1081, 1110, 1112, 1129, 1239, 1241, 1245, 1258, 1302, 1318, 1367, 1409, 1493, 1496, 1608, 1614, 1616, 1626, 1640, 1642, 1646, 1651, 1683, 1758, 1763, 1770, 1799, 1876, 1881, 2008, 2110, 2112, 2120, 2160, 2181, 2208, 2249, 2274, 2297, 2302, 2308, 2312, 2323, 2342, 2344, 2352, 2403, 2414, 2425, 2480, 2413, 2523, 2560, 2637, 2642, 2648, 2652, 2877, 2928, 2944, 2961, 2964, 2997, 3026, 3054
Post 155 – Rules recap
Post 237 – Discusses 1st night dead, notes that all three played the previous game
Post 253 – Agrees w/ Fretful Porpentine that it makes sense to go for those who played in the last game.
Post 262 – Responds to MadTheSwine discussing possible grudges vs. returning players, asks if it was random or revenge. “Can’t be coincidence…” If revenge, should we lynch a returning player?
Post 268 – Asks if people should post their experience. Claims he read 1st thread everyday, suspected Suburban Plankton of being mason, agreed that sturmhauke was seer in the forbidden thread
Post 304 - Responds to Rysto (pres #300), that Mafia could determine false cops quickly, since they know who’s scum and who’s town, therefore finding real cops. Rysto was replying to CaerieDD, re: chrisk’s suggestion, re: “cop results.” Agrees w/ Rysto, suggests striking chrisk and ET from those to be killed now. Not because he believes chrisk (he doesn’t), but because the latter should always give his info. “We wait until he sees a bad guy…kill that bad guy…If right, maybe he’s a cop. If not, then he’s dead. I know there is only a 50% chance he is right…” Suggests acting on what info we have, regardless of the truth. Votes sturmhauke, because “he played the best…from the last time, and did not get killed.”
Post 310 – respond to Rysto, who didn’t think we should kill sturmhauke, rather we should keep him. Finds it suspicious that he was not killed, while others who didn’t play as well were. Asks how killing good players is good for the town. Mafia and SK need to play well to win also.
Post 327 – doesn’t trust sturmhauke, Gadarene, pimaspinner, Trusts Pleonast, ChrisK.
Post 367 – agrees that dnooman was the mafia kill due to spreadsheet and skill at guessing roles. Analyzes OAOW complaining about night posts and rebutting chrisk, re: night posts. Still trusts chrisk. Nothing on Captain Carrot. Suggests OAOW was killed by SK, carrot by the Vig. Wants to hear from Autolycus. States that he’s got a couple of distrusts and one vote due to his prolific posting. Claims he won’t stop. Trying to see the experience of playesr and catch them in a lie. “If you lie once, you should die.” Confirms sturmhauke vote.
Post 368 – adds to chrisK posting cop results that got cut off.
Post 437 – defends posting as requested by Lakai, zuma, who voted for him. Re: asking for experience – trying to find out if people would lie about it. Re: 304/367 – re: voting for sturmhauke. Admits the reasons aren’t good, but claims that no one had good reasons. Vote was based on who’d been killed, not what’d been said. Defends self against Pleonastfor trust of ET and ChrisK. Confirms distrusts – sturmhauke, already stated, Gadarene for night posting and not saying much…no longer true. Reasoning same for pimaspinner.
Post 442 – vote count, but notes can’t find where Winston Smith voted for him.
Post 464 – defends v. Pleonast, who claimed he was squirming, re: chrisk. Pleonastdoesn’t trust him. Appeals to BlasterMaster and storyteller’s expressing the same sentiment.
Post 471 – defends v. zuma, re: fishing for lies by asking for experience. Claims zuma is accusing him baselessly. Stated that he’d claimed that it might or “might not” have been a good idea (he did). States that not everyone is good at deception…”who knows what will find out by asking for more information?”
Post 507 – agrees to a countdown after a vote (several others, pro-countdown in nothings)
Post 581 – re: only two kills, wonders who didn’t get one. (CaerieD later confirmed by BlasterMaster). Analyses CaerieD’s posts, mistrusting BlasterMaster, and the “Menocchio crumb.” Notes she voted for sturmhauke. Notes BlasterMaster suggested SK kill CaerieD. Pushes to lynch either sturmhauke or BlasterMaster. Due to lack of time later on, votes BlasterMaster.
Post 599 – lists all trust lists. Figures it’s ‘cause he didn’t want to lynch ET, fishing for experience, and being too defensive. Joke about talking too much. Claims this will be the last time defending him self. Props to Rysto for his analysis and vote for chrisk, won’t change vote, though.
Post 679 – responds to BlasterMaster’s post on strategy and CaerieDD’s suspects. Notes that BlasterMaster did not post the fact that BlasterMaster was on her distrust list. Concludes that BlasterMaster is “scum and must die.”
Post 687 – Calls out all lurkers to post, including nesta and brewha, Suggests leaving chrisk alone, due to doubts. Firm FOS on BlasterMaster and Pleonast.
Post 968 – reconfirms FOS of BlasterMaster, states that he thinks he was CaerieD’s breadcrumb. Will gain more info by lynching BlasterMaster. Discusses reasons for not thinking Menocchio was breadcrumb, but won’t for him. Reconfirms “lynch all liars.” Claims to have jumped no bandwagons. States reasons for mistrust of sturmhauke again. FOS BlasterMaster again and Pleonast. Agrees w/ Lakai, re: lynching Pleonast or BlasterMaster for best info. Defends chrisk again. States known facts several known facts, re: previous posters. Concludes that it’s best to lynch BlasterMaster. Vote count. Claims Citizen. Makes it on to several trust lists as a result.
Post 980 – responds to zuma, re: BlasterMaster as breadcrumb, people posting experience. Proposes to believe all role claims and all crumbs until proven.
Post 987 – responds to zuma, re: Q’s thinking is hilarious, asks him to tell how he thinks it is rather than just cutting and pasting.
Post 991 – getting pissy w/ zuma. Asks for proof that he’s discounting the “obvious” breadcrumb, claims he never has. Doesn’t think zuma is scum, pushes for BlasterMaster again. Claims not to be on a bandwagon.
Post 992 – wants an answer from zuma.
Post 1018 – responds to nesta stating that CaerieDD’s suspicion of BlasterMaster is reactionary. States that prior to CaerieDD, BlasterMaster was generally trusted.
Post 1024 – Doesn’t think the day should end yet. Wants a defense from BlasterMaster. States that everyone in danger should defend themselves. Vote list.
Post 1033 – States that he never accused BlasterMaster of being gung-ho. He himself is very active player. “number of posts do not indicate anything.” Voting for him for the breadcrumb and that he lied (lynch all liars). Reclaims citizen.
Post 1044 – responds to BlasterMaster who claimed to have defended lying, re: trust lists. He lied, lynch all liars. BlasterMaster’s defending his math posts, states that beat cops are useful, not 100%, but better than his 1/31 chance. “If I know someone is a beat cop, and they say X is scum…I am going to vote with them.” Pooh-poohs BlasterMaster’s math posts. Claims great analysis was done by Rysto. Reconfirms voting with CaerieD’s post. Thinks both he and BlasterMaster will die soon.
Post 1049 – responds to glee, thinks that once you get 6 votes, consider defending yourself. Looking forward to JSexton. Vote count.
Post 1051 – responds to Pleonast asking him to link to where BlasterMaster lied. States that BlasterMaster admitted that he lied on his mistrust list, who and why he put them there. Doesn’t link. (BlasterMaster responds in 1053)
Post 1056 – posts other people’s statements, re: BlasterMaster.
Post 1058 – States he and BlasterMaster are going in circles, everything that’s been said has been said, no new info, reclaims citizen.
Post 1077 – responds to JSexton’s analysis of him as scum. Defends fishing for players, analysis by timestamp, chrisK as cop – “All claims should be believed.”, the crumb silliness.
Post 1087 – responds to BlasterMaster’s Vig claim, states that he thinks BlasterMaster is the SK (1st time saying this, after JSexton did). Doesn’t believe the claim. Still votes BlasterMaster. Likes Rysto’s direction of Vig killing, suggests Pleonast, Gadarene, himself.
Post 1088 – wonders if a win condition is met and he’s the SK BlasterMaster wins. What then?
Post 1094 – wants to hear storyteller.
Post 1098 – “if the SK lives, he wins.” Doesn’t care who the Vig is. One of 4 people should be dead by day’s end: BlasterMaster, Pleonast, Gadarene, himself. Unvotes BlasterMaster, still believes he’s SK, but willing to direct kill, votes Pleonast. FOS zuma, suggests gadarene vig kill.
Post 1104 – asks brewha for SK suggestion and whether Miller should block SK.
Post 1107 – Tells Autolycus his vote is useless, pick someone else.
Post 1118 – 4-5 people on different sides: BlasterMaster, Pleonast, zuma vs. Gadarene, himself. Gadarene’s death could give some info, though. Rather have Pleonast or zuma die. FOS BlasterMaster, Pleonast, zuma, storyteller, sturmhauke, hocow, Autolycus. storyteller for being on Pleonast/BlasterMaster trust, sturmhauke, hocow for not posting and random, Autolycus for his posts.
Post 1122 – responds to Pygmy asking BlasterMaster who the Doc is. Says he doesn’t since he killed CaerieD. SK or mafia might know doc, but not BlasterMaster.
Post 1194 – responds to JSexton responding to his defense. States it’s not hard to look up info. States he never said he believed chrisk to be a cop. States no one knows the breadcrumb, he believes it’s BlasterMaster.
Post 1203 – swan song, asks town to direct BlasterMaster kill Pleonast or zuma. If everyone’s town, look to Rysto’s posts and lynch JSexton.
Post 1225 – responds to zuma, re: zuma’s choices of who to kill, BlasterMaster does not choose his kill.
Post 1231 – Responds to zuma on who BlasterMaster should kill. FOS and vote now zuma.
Post 1234 – Doesn’t want zuma to have BlasterMaster vote on his kill. Urges Gadarene to vote himself, and pimaspinner. Wants BlasterMaster to kill zuma.
Post 1256 – Again with the BlasterMaster doesn’t get a vote. Wants lynches of (in order) zuma, Pleonast, BlasterMaster, storyteller, Malacandra, sturmhauke, JSexton, hocow, Autolycus. States most people have defended. Pleonast has claimed Mason, does not believe him either. Claims town.
Post 12751275 – in case of a tie and therefore BlasterMaster gets to pick kill, unvotes zuma, votes Pleonast, wants zuma assassinated.
Post 1282 – plays martyr (the game will go on!), restates not believing BlasterMaster, assassinate zuma. If scum, go after Pleonast (who he doesn’t believe either) and vig kill JSexton. Claims vanilla citizen.
Post 1289 – Wants everyone to vote for his side or JSexton/zuma’s and allow BlasterMaster a choice. Vig gadarene if Q scum, vig zuma if Q town.
Post 1297 – reiterates above to zuma.
Post 1300 – reiterates above to JSexton
Post 1307 – calls the “other side” juvenile and dumb. States they fake role claims, allow a tool a vote and “crap posts.”
Post 1310 – asks zuma why he’s waiting for BlasterMaster’s input. Calls him scum.
Post 1322 – vig plan again.
Post 1336 – to zuma – the plan again.
Post 1344 – states he was just playing around, being mean to zuma. Doesn’t want a whole bunch of nothing posts (!) for mafia to hide behind. After yesterday.
Post 1346 – to JSexton, doesn’t want a mason to out themselves confirming Pleonast.
Post 1355 – martyrs “please don’t unlynch me…I’m still dead.” Unless…go for zuma (joking).
Post 1369 – Asks to die. zuma claims mason after.
Post 1404 – doesn’t believe zuma (after Pleonast confirms). Maybe real masons just haven’t posted yet. This is either a scum conspiracy (revealed after his death and zuma’s assassination). More roles to kill from scum. Or town’s a big clusterfuck and mafia’s laughing their asses off. Lists sturmhauke, Fretful Porpentine, StarvingButStrong, smitty, hocow, kivvik, Aguecheek, ArizonaTeach as low posters. If second scenario, go for them.
Post 1414 – Agrees w/ BlasterMaster that BlasterMaster kills who we say or we kill him. Should get 2 kills/day w/ vig, 1 from mafia, 1 from SK. Best interest for everyone to get the SK.
Post 1416 – martyrs. Kill him, kill zuma. If zuma didn’t lie, go for low posters.
Post 1423 – states Pleonast had no reason to claim w/ 6 votes (that was okay earlier).
Post 1429 – asks BlasterMaster why he thinks hocow is the SK. Can wait to tomorrow if he thinks it’s a scum trick. “Believing…who the SK is is helpful to all.”
Post 1455 – responds to glee, stating that there’s a good chance the real masons haven’t read the thread yet. Re: votes for Gadarene, if town, kill zuma, if scum, kill him. Claims citizen, distrust of BlasterMaster is fading, but doesn’t necessarily believe role claims. Asks for no more role claims.
Post 1459 – asks how best to accept a mason role claim. States have been believing all role claims no matter how stupid. Asks masons to direct BlasterMaster to Aguecheek (1st FOS) or JSexton. Can explain (never does).
Post 1463 – accepts JSexton’s clarification, re: no more confirming needed of masons.
Post 1474 – stands by analysis of town v. town or huge mafia plot. Thinks it’s town v. town. New scum list – sturmhauke, Fretful Porpentine, StarvingButStrong, Smitty, hocow, kivvik, Aguecheek, ArizonaTeach. Votes Aguecheek.
Post 1521 – responds to JSexton saying he was scummy, now seems town. States JSexton had everything completely wrong. States he was wrong re: BlasterMaster, zuma, Pleonast. Pushes to vote on things known, not things guessed. Restates scum list, no changes. Doesn’t think any main players are scum Votes vig kill of Aguecheek if Gadarene town, himelf if Gadarene scum.
Post 1540 – mostly nothing, agrees w/ Autolycus that Autolycus’s list needs to post more.
Post 1682 – (Winston Smith, nesta are dead) states Q, BlasterMaster, zuma, Pleonast need to shut up. They were all wrong. Lists low posters, lists day one votes. Those who voted ET, 5 are confirmed town (“assuming we believe all role claims, as this has been my strategy since the beginning, it isn’t changing now). Lists day 2 votes (omits Aguecheek vote for him). Comes up w/ some correlation for FCOD, ArizonaTeach, storyteller. Wonders about non voters from day 1 (lists them). Wonders re: brewha voting for BlasterMaster, Q, Gadarene…kept jumping on bandwagons. FOS MonkeyMensch for “acting in concert w/ nesta,” no voting and bandwaggoning. Not casting a vote yet. Wants confirmed townies to vote 1st. Suggests 28 townies left. Scum: brewha, Monkeymensch, Aguecheek, FCOD. Calls on low posters to speak up. Aguecheek responds that he missed A’s vote for Q and that he’d already defended his one major action (sturmhauke vote), for the exact same reasons as Q.
Post 1688 – responds to brewha defense, which was that Gadarene/Q on opposite sides. States he and Gadarene were on the same side. Aguecheek later points out that Q skipped over 2 spots that could reflect badly on him.
Post 1734 – apologizes for getting post counts wrong (small post), doesn’t respond to Aguecheek or sturmhauke directly.
Post 1795 – lists post counts, agrees lynch all lurker isn’t good, but Smitty, Fretful Porpentine and sturmhauke still don’t post much. Helpful in the last game doesn’t help. Asks Kat about conclusions from here. Asks Fern Forest about math and usernames.
Post 1866 – asks storyteller whether the FCOD vote still stands or going for pimaspinner?
Post 1870 – responds to Suburban Plankton about BlasterMaster picking his kills. Doesn’t think BlasterMaster is mafia. Thinks Suburban Plankton discussing it is suspicious, felt it was a done deal. Don’t worry about vig kill yet.
Post 1899 – responds to Fern Forest asking miller to block hocow. If hocow is SK, he/she can just choose not to kill. No way to know who SK is until someone kills them. If the SK has not been killed by the time odds are evened, then lynch BlasterMaster to eliminate possibility of him being SK and the killing of extra people. Concetrate on scum…forget the SK right now.
Post 1904 – appeal to Fern Forest. Please forget SK and concentrate on mafia.
Post 1929 – tells MadTheSwine not to worry about the SK. Should not be killed tonight. Only kill mafia. Getting snippy.
Post 1943 – clarifies that we should kill the SK, just not tonight. Emphasizes that SK has to kill 27 people, and that we shouldn’t worry about it. Refuses to say anything more on it.
Post 1951 – refuses to discuss SK having to kill less than 27 people with Aguecheek.
Post 1952 – Day 1, 2, and 3 vote lists.
Post 1963 – thinks that JSexton and pimaspinner are scum, as well as FCOD. FOS Aguecheek, MadTheSwine and MonkeyMensch. Votes pimaspinner, vig kill FCOD.
Post 2006 – accepts pimaspinner’s claim, unvotes pimaspinner, votes FCOD, vig kill Suburban Plankton
Post 2107 – unvote FCOD after miller claim, vig kill FCOD. Doesn’t think cops should investigate twice. 50/50 is good enough. Votes Fern Forest.
Post 2118 – unvotes Fern Forest, votes JSexton, per zuma’s request (‘cause he’s voting with the masons).
Post 2129 – tells pimaspinner to state who she’s investigating. Bad idea for GA to protect because it’s only a one shot deal.
Post 2140 – responds to BlasterMaster’s posting about mafia leaving him alone (re: no Dr for him), ‘cuz he might be useful to go after the SK. Doesn’t think BlasterMaster’s that valuable. Cops are more so. Doc should protect cop.
Post 2158 – unvotes JSexton due to Doc claim. Lists confirmed town. Asks whether other cop should claim, GA should protect them, JSexton protects himself.
Post 2173 – doesn’t want to lynch Fern Forest. Wants MonkeyMensch or Suburban Plankton instead, lists reasons, votes Suburban Plankton. Suggests BlasterMaster not test FCOD’s claim, but have millers go for scum (listed as MonkeyMensch, Fern Forest, sturmhauke, Aguecheek).
Post 2177 – ditches role claim idea. Believes JSexton, want him to protect pimaspinner, but random may be better. Thinks we’re screwed if the cop’s lost.
Post 2187 – suggests leaving Suburban Plankton as the vote for now.
Post 2191 – agrees w/ BlasterMaster’s plan, re: JSexton.
Post 2195 – states doctor is not as important as a cop.
Post 2198 – states we may have a GA who can target the 2 cops. Doesn’t belive JSexton over pimaspinner.
Post 2201 – no use investigating JSexton. pimaspinner is more important. (Suburban Plankton hung)
Post 2357 – searched all Suburban Plankton’s and kivvik’s posts. (kivvik, FCOD, zuma dead)
Post 2360 – no doubts re: pimaspinner and BlasterMaster. Waits for Fern Forest result for pimaspinner. Don’t go after JSexton.
Post 2370 – lists kivvik posts, thinks it clears Fretful Porpentine and Autolycus.
Post 2376 – votes Fern Forest per pimaspinner’s investigation of SK. Other cop investigate someone else. 50/50 is fine by him.
Post 2382 – unvotes Fern Forest, votes Autolycus, vig kill Fern Forest.
Post 2393 – wonders why the SK left pimaspinner alive. States if he was SK, would’ve taken the risk.
Post 2400 – agrees that it’s weird Fern Forest talked a lot about the SK, and didn’t try to kill pimaspinner. Lynch Autolycus, vig Fern Forest. “We need to get the SK.”
Post 2424 – doesn’t want masons to come out. States that if Pleonast dies, and a mason is targeted and claims, he will belive it absent a counter claim.
Post 2442 – lists Suburban Planktons posts. States that it leads him to believe that Autolycus is the GF, glee, sturmhauke, Aguecheek needs to be investigated. And him.
Post 2443 – responds to cowgirl, weird that Lakai defended Autolycus. Wonders if the mafia plan was for Autolycus to roleplay.
Post 2469 – agrees w/ BlasterMaster, re: Aguecheek, Lakai as scum, can’t remember reasoning for Pygmy Rugger. No feeling for glee.
Post 2470 – responds to cowgirl, re: FCOD “blocking” Malacandra. Thinks it’s in Mal’s favour.
Post 2479 – wonders who pimaspinner should investigate. Wants to lynch Autolycus now. Investigation list – glee, Lakai, Aguecheek, sturmhauke, Pygmy Rugger.
Post 2486 – thinks Autolycus’s hint, re: MadTheSwine is a hint to Autolycus being a cop.
Post 2490 – FCOD post analysis, believes JSexton’s claim, wonders about FCOD trust lists. Wonders why glee gets all the attention. Wonders why Aguecheek is on the distrust list.
Post 2512 – responds to Lakai responding to his suspicions – wonders why the anger. Distrusts him defending Autolycus and mentioning glee.
Post 2547 – thinks pimaspinner investigation list of Lakai, pygmy rugger, Aguecheek is good.
Post 2555 – responds to Fern Forest, who he’s willing to lynch due to 50/50 odds of a correct read by pimaspinner. Asks who BlasterMaster should target if Autolycus is the SK and not Godfather, realizes in 2560 that if Autolycus is SK, BlasterMaster won’t need to target anyone. Wonders why we should wait for JSexton’s views. Until his claim is verified by death, doesn’t trust him. Want to let pimaspinner investigate who she wants. Should tell us so the other cop can investigate someone else.
Post 2587 – responds to JSexton wondering why he was cleared. States that he isn’t, along with JSexton and Rysto. But there are better targets right now.
Post 2597 – wants Autolycus’s defense
Post 2719 – (Fern Forest, BlasterMaster, JSexton dead) Didn’t think we did anything wrong, cop said Fern Forest was the beat cop, doesn’t want to worry about math, it’s 50/50. SK is now a danger to both factions. No one to vote for.
Post 2739 – doesn’t want to argue about math. Boils down to 50/50.
Post 2763 – votes Malacandra for posting about math. 50/50 is the way to go. Thinks he has been seen as town “due to my posts.”
Post 2768 – dismisses Malacandra’s math posts. Wants a reason for a vote for him.
Post 2771 – dismiss math.
Post 27732773 – dismiss math.
Post 2789 – suggests pimaspinner not investigate Lakai, wants someone new. Will vote for pimaspinner – 50/50 is good.
Post 2797 – dismiss math.
Post 2800 – dismiss math.
Post 2804 – dismiss math, accepts 50/50.
Post 2805 – responds to Lakai, dismissing math.
Post 2810 – dismisses math, promises Malacandra analysis.
Post 2821 – Malacandra analysis, claims there’s not much there, only math.
Post 2822 – responds to why he got defensive – called a moron, never answered accusations. If that’s good enough to lynch him, go ahead.
Post 2827 – analyzes Malacandra posts, suspicious ‘cause there’s nothing there. Only asking for some people to out themselves and math. Isn’t sure if he’s scum, to be honest, though.
Post 2848 – notices he still has lots of votes, hopes it’s because of his talking, not because of Aguecheek’s FOS as SK. “Ballsy to hide so much in the open,” but he’s not that smart, nor is he the SK. Malacandra hasn’t posted much. He’s looked at hocow, will post analysis, suggests everyone do so.
Post 28502850 - hocow analysis. Concludes townie.
Post 2851 – notes Malacandra never voted for 12 hour countdown.
Post 2874 – responds to Aguecheek role claim. Promises to post Aguecheek post analysis.
Post 2882 – states Aguecheek analysis supports claim.
Post 2884 – Aguecheek analysis. All seems to fit claim Doesn’t want to risk lynch. Wonders why never investigated MonkeyMensch.
Post 2886 – suggest believe role claims, everyone vote for Malacandra, him. Or vote for MonkeyMensch.
Post 2909 – MonkeyMensch analysis. Claims a lot of nothing posts. Constant FOS of brewha. Read the thread a lot, no analysis. FOS scum Investigation list: glee, brewha, MonkeyMensch, pygmy, Malacandra.
Post 2913 – respond to cowgirl, re: posting anaylsis of those who’ve been nightkilled.
Post 2917 – concludes MadTheSwine will die. Investigate list: (no change)…oh, and him, ‘cause he talks a lot.
Post 2919 – asks Fretful Porpentine if he’s got brewha’s voting pattern.
Post 2927 – unvotes Malacandra, votes MonkeyMensch.
Post 2940 – likes Aguecheek reporting first, don’t know why he should investigate him, but whatever.
Post 2985 – (pimaspinner, glee dead), wants to hear from sturmhauke and Aguecheek to report findings.
Post 2992 – warns vs. cowgirl posts (pre v. post). Promises Fretful Porpentine analysis. glee was taken out by the SK to cast suspicion his way. glee on top of his investigation list.
Post 3001 – per brewha/sturmhaukehauke, will look at storyteller and StarvingButStrong.
Post 3009 – do storyteller first ‘cause StarvingButStrong isn’t pinging scumdar. Doesn’t trust Aguecheek. Wonders why Aguecheek investigated him. Dismisses Aguecheek investigation.
Post 3018 – agrees cop is good mafia cover. If he lives 2 more nights, should lynch him. Asks brewha why MonkeyMensch isn’t scum. Opinions on Malacandra? (never responds to Aguecheek response on 3019)
Post 3021 – prelim storyteller analysis. Really likes it. Concludes town. Votes pygmy rugger. Scum list – Pygmy Rugger, MonkeyMensch, Malacandra, brewha. Promises MonkeyMensch analysis.
Post 3024 – storyteller analysis.
Post 3025 – voting for Pygmy Rugger ‘cause storyteller did.
Post 3029 – responds to brewha, thinks it’s good to analyze everone.
Post 3043 – thinks Rysto is trusted because of spreadsheet and good advice. Kudos to brewha.
Post 3044 – analysis posts.
Post 3049 – dismisses brewha impression of MonkeyMensch, posts why. Stronger FOS of MonkeyMensch. suggests other analyses of people, tries to assign them. Promises Pygmy Rugger analysis.
Post 3050 – repeat.
Post 3057 – assigns analyses.
Post 3064 – assigns analyses.
And that’s what I’ve got. There are some editorials of mine in there, thoughts that poked up while I was reading. Some I erased when the questions were cleared up, some stayed in because the question was still there, some stayed in because I forgot about them and wasn’t going to go back and look for them. There were no more posts by the time I finished, and I wasn’t going to refresh looking for more, either.
Thanks for all the heavy lifting, everyone. If only I could decide who to vote for. It’s too soon for me to vote anyway (remembering what happened last Day).
List of Suspicion on those who haven’t voted yet:
Aguecheek
cowgirl
Fretful Porpentine
Malacandra
Menocchio
Pygmy Rugger
Rysto
StarvingButStrong
Get your votes in, lest ye be scum!
Bolding mine:
Just a reminder. **Rysto ** will be out of the game until Wednesday. (Not that you didn’t know that Pleonast, just that seeing **Rysto’s ** name on your list reminded me to remind you guys.)
Hey, you’re not on that list! I thought I voted yesterday, my bad.
I’m going to vote cowgirl, for reasons i’ve expressed previously.
Writing quickly to say sorry for my nonparticipation over the last few days. New Jersey Comcast sucks, and I experienced all kinds of cable and Internet interruptions over the weekend. Fortunately, I am now back at work, with a reliable connection and a bit of free time this afternoon. I’m’a gonna’ do a bit of catch up reading and be back with further thoughts later.
But on first glance: wow. That’s a lot of very impressive work by everyone. This may take a while.
Oops, I forgot about Rysto. I’ll still shame him for not voting, but don’t think anyone should vote for him.
Confirmed Townies are not on the list (me and sturmhauke). Menocchio is probably excused as well, but isn’t absolutely confirmed.