Hmm. Not really crazy about this performance. Melissa was yelling, and she was completely flat, which is unfortunate, because she could have been great. Lurve the outfit, though. Very Jessica Sierra.
I thought Melissa was pretty good.
I can’t be objective when it comes to Heart.
If Melissa says “You know " one more time. . .”
I thought Melissa was okay, not great, but not as bad as Simon said.
I’m disappointed that Paula seems sober tonight.
Big Bucking Chicken? Is that what that commercial is saying?
I love Lisa! The guitar thing was awesome. I wish they hadn’t straightened her hair, though, she was so stunning and now she look a lot plainer.
Melissa is a real dark-horse. I didn’t even know she existed until the top 24 and at first I thought she’d be another Becky O’Donohue type. But she gets better each week and I thought she was great tonight. I love her vocal quality.
What was that??? What was the rumour?
Why does Ryan keep picking on poor Kevin Covais? Not nice, Seacrest! Give the poor little tadpole a break, will you?
What in the world is wrong with the girls. Kinnick is killing this song.
Thre was a rumor that Kat had a bun in the oven.
I think this may be it for Kinnik. I like her voice, but it’s too jazzy for Idol.
Pregnant from Kevin?
The judges are sober this night…
KarlGrenze, I’m with you – everybody sounds sub-par tonight, and I do think the band might have something to do with it. Maybe they all have the Singapore-Sling-swine flu or something …
No, Kinnik! Don’t admit you weren’t perfect! Gaaaaah! Have you learned nothing?
I thought Kinnik was better than Paris tonight at least for picking a song that doesn’t suck.
Miss Piggy has sold out – she’s promoting pepperoni! That’s just not right.
Yea, Kinnik wasn’t too good, and she herself admitted it…
McGee or McVee or whatever is the best tonight so far. That’s not saying much, I know.
Oh, Kat, connecting yourself in any way with The Constantine? Oh, just … no. At least you sound good, if … listless. Technically phenomenal, but … I don’t know, rhythmless or something. Perfect pitch can’t make you Aretha, sadly. But you’re the best so far, so good on you.
Yep, best so far.
The band sucks! The music sucks!
She did good tonight, I didn’t expect that from her!