Rock on, Shroom! In my experience most men are not too receptive to the toy idea. Usually I can talk them into using it, but I have to buy it alone. Once they realize the awesome, god-like power and beauty that is the vibrating sex toy, however, it’s their new best friend.
A bullet is probably your best bet, especially if you guys haven’t experimented with vibes before. My best friend works in a sex shop and I often hang out there with her, and the bullet is by far the best-selling item. Of course, it really depends on whether or not your girlfriend wants penetration or clitoral stimulation or both, because bullets are too small to mimic a penis, though the vibrations of the bullet inside are pretty nice regardless of size. I personally don’t find inserting plastic in my hooha very satisfying, and it’s not enough alone to get me off, so I stick with bullets.
Also, the bullet can be used for anal purposes as well because it’s small, just buy some Anal-Eez first.
If you guys are looking for a toy to use together, I highly recommend what is sometimes called “the Wand.” (I wish I could give you the real name but I’ve forgotten it, I can tell you Doc Johnson made mine). It’s got a vibrating tip roughly the size of a fingertip, attached to a flexible wand eight inches long, with the controls at the bottom. You can bend it to fit the curve of your thigh, turn it on, and not worry about it during all the bumpin’ and grindin’. It’s especially hands-off if you’re doing the missionary thang.
I have plenty of experience with sex toys so let me add that in my opinion, the simpler the better. A lot of the new toys are just too damn complicated, do too many things at once, and then you get so caught up in working them that you kill the mood.
Also, the kind with the thumb dial that you use to adjust intensity tends to last longer than the ones with remote-control buttons.
One more thing: those Rabbit-style vibes with the tip that is supposed to stimulate your clitoris while the dildo part is inside can be painful. I have used several but they never seem to fit right, if that makes sense, so it makes me hurt, which is not fun at all.
Thanks for the tip, Geobabe. My new toy is definitely going to be a vibrating cock ring.