Sandalwood or cedar. I like rose and a few other florals, and some of the lighter citruses, but I’m pretty allergic to a lot of artificial scents so it has to be from a botanical source (even then, something like lavender, which I really like, will make me sneeze and have itchy eyes).
Dr. B’s Peppermint soap. Or Grandpa’s Pine Tar.
Zumbar’s sandalwood-citrus is hands down my favorite. It’s too darn expensive for daily use, though. 
I like Ivory, it reminds me of my childhood. In summer, my Mom would make a picnic supper and Dad would take us to “the old swimming hole” where they went when they were kids. Mom would always bring a bar of Ivory (it floats) so we could bathe in the river. Probably be hard to do these days, w/ all the pollution.
This are my two personal favorites.
Although I have been partial to Grandpas Pine Tar lately.