Why Isn't Adoption Seen As Responsible?

Oh, I absolutely agree. I’ve pointed this out to him as diplomatically as I can, but I don’t think it made sense to him.

I didn’t know about the correlation between mental illness and teen pregnancy (and I’d be very interested in seeing a cite), but it makes sense. In 2005 USA, there is no reason not to use birth control. Minor girls can get it, confidentially and free, from the local public health or planned parenthood. And even if your hormones get the better of you in an unplanned moment of passion (and really, what could be a better description of your teen years than that?), you can get morning after pills, also for free.

People will all of their mental capacity realize this, and usually take the necessary steps, so it makes sense that most of the people who allow a pregnancy to happen have diminished capacity, somehow.

There’s also the public aspect of pregnancy. Most women will eventually “show” to a large degree. Their pregnancies become obvious and public. I can imagine not wanting to deal with people’s questions and judgments.

Abortion is private. Lots of women have abortions who never speak about it, ever. It’s hard to be that private about a pregnancy carried to term (though my sister did it. The first anyone knew about her pregnancy was when we were told there was a new family member).

The cite is a book called Launching a Baby’s Adoption, by Patricia Irwin Johnson. And I’m doing facts from memory. In fact, took a bit of digging to find the book. Couldn’t remember the author or the title - just what the book was about and what the cover looked like (adoption book with a purple cover, lets go find it on Amazon!).

Oh, Eureka, what I’ve read and been taught supports your thoughts as well. The decision to abort and the decision to make an adoption plan (which is the “correct language” or was eight years ago when we did the work for our son) are two seperate decisions. The decision to abort is usually made and acted on fairly quickly - within a matter of weeks early in the pregnancy. Its a point in pregnancy where even people exicited about their future parenthood can be ambilvent about their pregnancy. Once its acted on, there is no turning back. The decsion to make an adoption plan is one that a women makes and acts on over a period of months, with it being possible to change her mind and back out at any time - in some states months after the placement is made. The pregnancy gives her a chance to bond. And the pregnancy becomes a committment, a lot of work - and the baby the reward for the work.

By the way, in addition to the links between mental illness et.al. and teenage pregnancy, I also understand that teenage women who place their children for adoption tend to be brighter than those that decide to parent. Which makes sense, they are making a decision at a level of abstraction beyond the moment and “my cute baby.”

Well, I’ve never been diagnosed with a mental illness, although people close to me think it’s likely I’m clinically depressed. Since I don’t remember feeling any differently my whole life, I’ve not explored medication. I’m also supposed to be higher on the curve than average, but this place tends to make me feel dumb.

I did experience a teenaged pregnancy, and I did put my son up for adoption. I was extremely under the age of 18, and felt I had no options. I was a naive young girl who didn’t know anything about public assistance, my parent’s refused to help and I felt backed into a corner. Was it the best decision for my son? Well, I’ll never know, will I? My brain tells me yes, of course it was. I could not parent a child sucessfully while I still was one myself. However, not a single day of my life goes by when I don’t wonder what happened to him. Is he well, safe, loved? Were his parents people I would like and admire? He’ll be 30 next august. Old enough to be married and possibly raising a family of his own. Am I a grandmother? And yet every single time I hear anything about abuse of adopted or foster children I get an extra cold chill. The script goes something like this:

Logical Self “He’s a grown man”
Emotional Self “If he lived that long”
LS “Adoptive families are screened”
ES “by the same people who were supposed to be following that childs well-being”
LS “you were in no position to raise a child”
ES “but if I had fought harder for someone to help me?”
etc…

It never goes away. My oldest daughters birthday is just two days off from her brother’s. I can’t even celebrate her birthday without already feeling the sadness that comes from his, 2 days later. Does he think about me? Am I evil in his eyes? Did anyone ever think of me kindly, or was I always the enemy who might steal “their” child? For the record, I would never contact him. I made a deal. I hate it, but that’s the way it works. I signed away all my parental rights. He may not even know I exist, and I would never risk rattling his world that way.

I’ve never had an abortion, so I don’t know how I’d feel after that. But I assure you that adoption is never, ever over. I did feel him move, I did talk to him, and hold him in my arms just that once (which in those bad old days I had to blackmail the authorities into allowing by refusing to sign any paperwork until they brought him to me, and then the nurse never left the room, and I didn’t get a chance to count fingers & toes.) I did not name him, because I could not bear the thought of the one thing I could give him being taken away, and I now regret that decision because I don’t have a name for him, he is always only “my son”.

Adoption is a responsible thing to do. It is however, a much much harder thing to do than most people will ever have to do, at least in the western world. And you are asking it of a young woman who has not yet had the chance to develop much in the way of resources. I am pro-choice because I would never have the temerity to force someone down my road.

Thank you for sharing your story, GillianBoardman. For the record, I would have made the same choice in your shoes. I was 18 when my son was born, and I had my mother’s support (we lived with her until he was 5. Without that, I never could have done it.

The odds are greatly in his favor that your son is healthy and well. He probably is much better off, given your awful circumstances. You did the right thing.

Is there any sort of service that lets you somehow give him permission to contact you if he goes looking for you, but doesn’t contact him? Would you be interested in it if something like that were possible?

There is a registry in the state in question. My information is listed. I rather think that by this age if he was interested I’d have heard about it. I completely understand why he wouldn’t be. After all, he has no way of knowing if I ever got my life straightened out, there is the fear of hurting his new family, and the fear of rejection by me. Still, I keep hoping against hope that perhaps one day he’ll be at my front door, or at the very least that he knows I love him. That he was unplanned but not even for a single moment unwanted.

I also had a teenage pregnancy and gave the child up for adoption. I often received reaction about how irresponsible I was (and I was - we didn’t use protection, obviously) and thought that it would have been so much easier to have an abortion. It was a shameful time.

I am fortunate in that it was an open adoption (the adoptive parents were my next door neighbors) and the Dad is a high-profile guy in sports. My son is now a college athlete so I have glimpses into where he is and what he is doing, but we have never had contact. Like GillianBoardman, I would love to meet him, but I made this commitment, and the choice is his.

Back to responsibility, for me the irresponsibility of the unplanned pregnancy trumps the “responsible” decision re adoption, in both my mind and societal perception, as far as I can tell.

It feels as if by making the best possible decision for him, I chose the most painful and sometimes-shameful course for myself. Which is the nature of parenting, some might say. :wink:

NHNG

I have nothing but respect and admiration for a woman who choses to give her child up for adoption. Adoptive parents are screened, and while bad cases do happen they are by far the minority. My aunt and uncle attemped to adopt a deaf child (one of their sons was born deaf) and were denied because they couldn’t give the child his own room. I vividly remember walking into our hockey arena several years ago and having a friend run up and throw her arms around me: “He’s ours! He’s ours! No one can take him away now!”

I have made the decision not to have children because I don’t trust myself to always do what is right for a child. I would probably make a good parent now, when I’m nearly 45, but I don’t think I would have when I was younger.

To feel a child grow inside of you and be able to give it up so it will be able to get the care you are not able to give it is the highest love you can give, IMO. You are totally, selflessly concerned for your child. Too many women keep kids they really can’t (or won’t) take proper care of. In that situation I don’t think the child wins.

I think he knows.

I also wanted to thank you and Heidi for sharing your stories. I’d like to think that if I ever ended in your situation (God forbid) I would be able to be as strong as you.

Thank you for saying that, but I wasn’t strong, I was backed into a corner. I hope it was the right corner for my son, but I can’t take any credit for that decision. It was not my choice. The strength came later in learning to deal with the decision. I made a lot of bad decisions for several years after that, all stemming from resentment of my parents over the situation. But, if we are lucky we all grow up, and so did I. I’m ok with my parents, I’m ok with my subsequent children. And for the most part I am at peace with what happened. But I couldn’t walk away from this thread, so obviously there are still some issues.