I had two that were in close competition. Casdave got there 1st with my personal number 2 choice of Achey Breaky Heart - Billy Ray Cyrus.
I must confess to being shocked to have worked my way through some 160 posts, and that not one of you had remembered the nasally challenged, lyrically constipated Dean Friedman with Lucky Stars.
I can’t quite express how disturbing I find him. I have scared myself badly by visiting his website and spotting more of the songs he penned. I am now off to lie down in a darkened room.
I assert that the early 1970’s includes the bulk of the worst tunes, for some reason, probably cocaine.
Sometimes When We Touch
Convoy
Shannon (drifting out to sea?)
How Much Is That Doggie In The Window?
(It Was) An Itsy Bitsy Teeny Weeny Yellow Polka-Dot Bikini*
San Francisco (Flowers in your hair)
Teddy Bear
Hooked On A Feeling
I Write The Songs (Anything by Manilow, by definition)
Young Girl, Get Outta My Mind**
song actually used for SERE training (albeit played at 78 RPM) to break down prisoners will to resist
** DNA testing recommended by authorities for possible link to unsolved crimes
Honorable mention goes to anything by the Cranberries, with that… that… horrible vocalist is all I can say. Might as well listen to fingernails on a blackboard. AAARrrggggh.
Amazon’s customer reviews page for Kathie Lee’s CD Heart of a Woman on which you can find the worst song ever recorded in pop history, “Heartache, Heartache”, gives a few choice reviews.