You get one free food for the rest of your life - What'll it be?

Nowhere in that paragraph is any inkling that it is his definition of “free,” much less an exhaustive definition. In the absence of qualifiers or modifiers, “free food” means I don’t have to pay for it. I doubt that I would have assumed otherwise unless he specifically said “free doesn’t mean you don’t have to pay for it.”

Free doesn’t mean you don’t have to pay for it.
mmm

You win the Best Loophole competition, rowrrbazzle.

But I must now create - and invoke - the butterfat clause.*
mmm

*Butterfat shall not be allowed as a choice on account of I said so.

Then I have my answer! I’m a giant Coca-Cola fanatic.

Popeye’s spicy fried chicken. Mmmmm

Primanti Brothers corned beef and cheese.

Yeah, I found that out the hard way when I tried to walk out of the grocery store with a cart full of Pepsi Free and Tide Free.

I think this was one of those examples of someone replying to the thread title, not the OP.

White Castle cheeseburgers - Ambrosia!

But I still get my vodka - right?

I was going to say cheesecake, but then I closed my eyes and stilled my thoughts and a vision came. Well, I say vision, but it wasn’t visual. It was a taste, a taste that I have been avoiding for a long time because it isn’t good for me.

Cream cheese avocado dip. Ideally, together with Granny Goose Hawaiian Chips. Although if that would make the dip alone bad, then I’ll skip the chips. Mmmmmm. Lovely decadent stuff.

I second Chick-Fil-A, but I’ll go with their regular chicken sandwiches.

First sugar, now butterfat, dang. Can I choose butter itself?

That’s a fair call. Allowing “dim sum” would be like allowing “tapas” in Spanish cuisine, or “hor d’oerves” in French. You’d might as well allow “Chinese menu – chose Column A or Column B”.

Sauced pasta