ETA: Okay, more seriously, I’m not sure I’d want to ask the Giant Brain anything. Sure, it’s omniscient, but that doesn’t mean that it’s honest, or that it has the same priorities and values I do. (“Should I bet everything on red?” “Emphatically yes! (Because I want you to lose your money and end up homeless and destitute, mwah-ha-ha!”)
No, it’s an attempt to ask three-questions at once. Since saying neither saying the word “yes” or “no” once can answer the question adequately, it’s clearly not a simple yes or no question. It’s like trying to get around the “three wishes from a genie” rule by wishing for more wishes. Nobody’s fooled.
Do you spend most of your time laughing at us (humans)?
If I kill myself will I still get to be with Alvin in the after-life?
Is some other species really in charge and we (humans) do not realize it?
I must be the only one who doesn’t give a shit what the meaning of life is.
I can’t really believe none of you would ask something closer to “why didn’t she do x…?” or “what if we had done x instead of y…” or “how would my life be different if I had decided x?”
For all the intellectual and philosophical masturbation we love here, I know I’d sleep a lot better with answers to some much more simple questions.
No, it wouldn’t because whomever wasn’t the favoured religion would simply claim that either the so-called “God” you met with was a demon, anti-christ or deceiver sent to test the faith of the true believers and that you are an instrument of evil. If anything, it would prompt a higher level of tension and lead to bloody conflicts as they went to war over the whole question/answer issue.
I disagree. The question is the logical conjunction of three statements, and therefore a single yes or no is an adequate (if unsatisfying) answer to the question.