But you see, my job is not to spend substantial amounts of company time cleaning up the messes of an incompetant co-worker. If I have to spend X hours a week (in my case, generally about 5) clearing up bullshit messes left behind by (for example) the lady who subs for me on weekends, then that’s 5 hours I’m not spending performing my own work - a net loss to the firm. If I have to spend 5 hours a week cleaning up stupid bullshit mistakes she made because she refuses to learn how to perform basic tasks, then that’s a little more than 10% of my work-week lost to preventable error.
Why would you not want to know one of your employees is incompetant?
Other people’s incompetancy frequently affects my job performance.
Let me give you an example: My boss works 6 days a week. Therefore, he has three assistants on a rotating schedule. The main person (me) working weekdays, a second person (C) working weekday evenings, and a third person (S) working only Sundays (usually a 4 - 5 hour shift).
S is fundamentally incompetant. She refuses to learn (or use) any of the procedures in place. She won’t use document styles, can’t file documents properly, and fucks up financial monitoring tasks with a regularity that’s positively astounding. Any work she performs must be redone. Quite often, it takes exponentially more time to redo the work than it took her to perform it in the first place. As an addition, she regularly renders office equipment unusable (she’s killed three PCs this year alone - largely through particularly boneheaded downloading that infected them with malware sufficiently virulent to kill the machine - only purest luck has prevented it from bombing our servers according to my Help Desk guys).
S performs 5 hours of “work” every other week (on average). It takes me a an average minimum of 5 hours per week to clean up her messes (in three years at this position it’s never taken me less than 3 and often more than 10 hours to do triage and clean up).*
Hence, mathematically, it’s sucking up twice as many manhours to repair her incompetance as she even works. And, the hours her incompetance sucks up are peak hours, as opposed to her own hours, which are not peak. By “peak”, I mean regular business hours when my boss, his clients, the other departments of the firm, and various regulatory agencies can expect to have my full attention on my actual tasks - as opposed to having to blow those hours cleaning up stupid bullshit messes that wouldn’t exsist if S had anything resembling “competance”.
Why in hell would you not want to know about a situation like that?** As a professional person, I’m operating under the assumption that part of being a professional person is bringing issues to the attention of my supervisor - in case he or she isn’t aware of them. If I see something going really wrong, how is it not incumbent upon me to point it the hell out to someone who might be able to fix it? There are a host of reasons a supervisor might not have noticed an incompetant person - and one of them, to be blunt, is that their co-workers might be covering up for them in the name of being professional. If I’m repairing S’s fuck-ups before they become sufficiently critical as to cause a major malfunction (as I am), if I don’t speak up, how will my boss ever know there’s a problem? My boss has no idea really what I do - or how I do it. If everything appears to be functioning normally (because I’ve fixed the gross negligence of S), how would he know something’s wrong if nobody tells him because of a short-sighted policy like yours? You’d really rather your employees just let the house burn down without shouting fire?
*I’m averaging over the week, naturally - quite often her fubars are of such nature as to be uncovered some time other than first thing Monday morning. They crop up throughout the week. Even on weeks when she wasn’t in on the Sunday beginning the week, I inevitably find (and correct) something. I’ve never gone a full week without something cropping up.
**I have pointed out the situation with S to various persons. Frequently, and with increasing vigor. The reasons she hasn’t been replaced have largely to do with the nature of her position (extremely part-time hours, and my boss is highly difficult to work for) and the fact that my boss is a fucking loon.