I have recently seen several different candidates mentioned as the most popular. I suggested that the A thread had the most replies and the If LotR Had Been Written By Someone Else!? had the most views.
In the interest in fighting ignorance, albeit Mundane & Pointless Stuff here are the forum by forum results.
Game Threads generate the most replies but not the most views by a long shot.
The most viewed thread of all time on the SDMB is If LotR Had Been Written By Someone Else!? Followed by Scylla’s brilliant The horror of blimps.
It turns out the most posted to is actually the a thread. It had 5,337 posts
Threads with most replies.
TGR: Mafia V: The Cult of Sekham 4353
GQ: Are scalar weapons for real? 1,017
BBQ: Lying whore. 1,707
MPSIMS: a 5,337
Café: #1 All Diablo2 Talk here… 2,814
Café: #2 If LotR Had Been Written By Someone Else!? 2,041
IMHO: Spit or Swallow? A followup poll TMI? 1,032
GD: Fork Hillary 3: The Final Forking 2,949
ATMB: The SDMB is switching to paid subscriptions 668
CCC: Flight and the Conveyor Belt 536
CSR: Edgar Cayce 183
Threads with most views.
TGR: Werewolf a game Part 2 (this time with MAFIA!) 90,284
GQ: Is there any reason that semen would be bad for my fish? 76,117
BBQ: The horror of blimps392,132
MPSIMS: Funny things said during love making/intimate moments… 89,528
Café: If LotR Had Been Written By Someone Else!?472,509 (BTW: 2nd in Café is only 47,356)
IMHO: Very vaguely creepy. 37,501
GD: I waterboard! 155,246
ATMB: Sticky: Beginner’s Guide to Glossary of Terms on Straight Dope Message Boards 14,130
CCC: Damn fool war21,324
CSR: Why you should never sign the back of credit cards6,035
This mundane and silly service brought to you by Jim.