My kids got the occasional swat on the bottom, but it generally wasn’t more than two or three swats, and by the time they were 6 or so, even that had ceased. Mostly it was an attention-getter on a diapered bottom when they were toddlers to get them to turn their attention away from whatever they were doing that was either dangerous or something they knew was naughty. I tried one time, and one time only, to swat snowbunny’s rear with the back of a hairbrush. It being a plastic hairbrush, the handle promptly broke off, leading us both to laughter. And that was the end of spanking.
After that, I tried to find a punishment that consisted of taking away a privilege that was something they really enjoyed doing. The single most effective punishment I found, which only works if your kids are bookworms but WOW is it effective if they are, is to deny them the “privilege” of reading for some period of a few hours. While teachers and other parents were absolutely horrified that I would even contemplate such a thing, I only had to impose it one time, as snowbunny can testify, and after that just the threat was sufficient to change the behavior. That and the Look, of course.
I truly do not understand how parents can raise children without perfecting the Look. I strongly advise you add it to your arsenal as quickly as possible, LiLi – even toddlers learn its effectiveness quickly, and it is, frankly, the single most effective parenting tool I’ve ever discovered. It works great with strangers’ misbehaving kids, too, especially when used with a quiet voice. A polite phrase to “please stop running so you don’t get hurt” in a store to a strange child, accompanied by the Look? Gets results almost every time! 
I agree that common-sense parenting is the best way to go, and you’ll find wonderful advice and suggestions here. Besides, tinyninjachef is going to be a perfect child, anyway! Aren’t all Doper babies perfect? 
To my joy, with about 30 pages to go in my transcript, the witness changed his answer from whatever the question might call to to one single phrase: “Fifth Amendment.” In addition, the attorney is asking the same series of questions about a series of transactions, so between macros and cut and paste, I’m actually typing about one line out of ten. If only the whole 200+ pages had been like this!
Back to Mr. Fifth Amendment. And an attempt to get my latest earworm out of my head. They mentioned a guy named Spaulding in the transcript, and next thing you know I’ve got “Hooray for Captain Spaulding, the African explorer!” stuck on repeat in my head. Sometimes I really do not like the way my strange brain works. :rolleyes: