If we’re going to include Iron Butterfly, there’s also Jellyfish (two foods in one band!). And the Dead Milkmen.
And if we’re including fictional bands, there’s Dessert (alternately spelt Desert, Dessart, and Desret), the girl group from Suicide Club.
And a real, non-stretch:
Coconuts Musume (one of the many, many singing groups that have been part of Hello! Project).
Limp Bizkit
If awful alternate spellings count, then Uncle Kracker.
Hot Fudge (Muppets).
Do tastes count? If so…
Matthew Sweet
Rancid
And then there’s:
Sugar Ray
Peripherly, Canned Heat?
Would give some meaning to all that sterno that I lit to keep the food hot.
Modest Mouse
Eagle Eye Cherry
Counting Crows (Eat crow… it’s a stretch, I know)
Also, any group with the word “kids” in their name.
If cannibalism counts, why not Dead Kennedys?
ABBA is the name of a Swedish herring company.
Mustard Plug
OK thanks Only Mostly Dead for busting [del]my[/del] me on cherry 
Lets allow ficticious bands only if there have been records/cds released under the band name. I’ll add * kid * and * Brothers * as a couple of special cases (bonus points to Usram and Ludovic )
- kid *
- Brothers *
ABBA
Canned Heat
Coconuts Musume
Counting Crows
Dead Milkmen
Don Cherry
Eagle Eye Cherry
Gumbo
Hot Fudge
Jellyfish
Limp Bizkit
Matthew Sweet
Menudo
Modest Mouse
Mustard Plug
Neneh Cherry
Rancid
Reel Big Fish
Ribs & Brisket Revue
Richard Cheese
Rod Stewart
Salt N’ Pepa
Salty Pirates
Sherbet
Sheryl Crow
Smashing Pumpkins
Soup Dragons
Spearmint
Spice Girls
Squirrel Nut Zippers
Strawberry Alarm Clock
Strawbery Switchblade
String Cheese Incident
Sugababes
Sugar
Sugar Ray
Sugarloaf
Sweet Honey in the Rock
Tangerine Dream
T-Bone Burnett
The Apples In Stereo
The Banana Splits
The Byrds
The Cake
The Cookies
The Cranberries
The Eels
The Jam
The Jams
The Lemon Drops
The Lemon Pipers
The Lollipop Shoppe
The Magic Mushrooms
The Partridge Family
The Peanut Butter Conspiracy
The Pop Group
The Raspberries
The Sea & Cake
The Sea Urchins
The Seeds
The Sugarcubes
The Sweet
The Waterboys
The Watermelon Men
Thin Yoghurts
Tim Rice
Tommy Roe
Toni Basil
Ultimate Spinach
Uncle Kracker
Vanilla Fudge
Vanilla Ice
Veruca Salt
Whiskeytown
Wild Cherry
Wings
Here are a few more-Shirley Temple,The Chiffons,Ambrosia,Everclear,and Iggy Pop. Oh,and The Spiders from Mars(candy bar)
How come the list just got a lot shorter?
Thanks, my fault, I trusted Excel without double checking.
1910 Fruitgum Company
A Taste of Honey
ABBA
Ambrosia
April Wine
Bananarama
Black Eyed Peas
Black Grape
Black Stone Cherry
Blancmange
Blind Lemon Jefferson
Blind Melon
Blue Oyster Cult
Bowling for Soup
Brandy
Bread
Buckcherry
Bucks Fizz
Bucky and John Pizzarelli
Buffalo Springfield
Buffalo Tom
Cake
Canned Heat
Captain Beefheart
Cherry Poppin Daddies
Chicory Tip
Chocolate
Chocolate Watchband
Cibo Matto
Close Lobsters
Coconuts Musume
Coldcut
Counting Crows
Country Joe & the Fish
Cracker
Cream
Crystal Waters
Cuppa T
Dead Milkmen
Deathtongue
Don Cherry
Doug Clark and the Hot Nuts
Eagle Eye Cherry
Electric Prunes
Eminem
Enter The Haggis
Fat Mattress
Fine Young Cannibals
Fiona Apple
Fish
Flying Burrito Brothers
For Squirrels
Free Beer
G Love and Special Sauce
Gin Blossoms
Godley & Creme
Grapefruit
Green Jello
Green Jelly
Gumbo
Half Man Half Biscuit
Harlem Hamfats
Hot Chocolate
Hot Fudge
Hot Tuna
Humble Pie
Ice Cube
Ice T
Iron and Wine
Iron Butterfly
Jawbreaker
Jello Biafra
Jelly
Jelly Roll Morton
Jellyfish
Jimmy Buffet
John Cougar Meloncamp
Joseph Lamb
Ketchup
Korn
Kula Shaker
Lamb
Lamb of God
Left Over Salmon
Lemon Jelly
Lemonheads
Light Crust Doughboys
Lightning Seed
Limp Bizkit
Lisa Lisa and Cult Jam
Lox and Vodka
Lubricated Goat
Marmalade
Martha and the Muffins
Matthew Sweet
Meat Puppets
Meatloaf
Menudo
Moby Grape
Modest Mouse
Mudhoney
Mushroomhead
Mustard Plug
Neneh Cherry
Neutral Milk Hotel
Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
Orange Juice
Paul Butterfield Blues Band
Peaches
Peaches & Herb
Peanut
Pearl Jam
Penguin Cafe Orchestra
Phish
Pink Lady
Poi Dog Pondering
Pop Will Eat Itself
Poptart Monkeys
Prefab Sprout
Pulp
Rancid
Red Hot Chili Peppers
Red Red Meat
Reel Big Fish
Reply With Quote
Ribs & Brisket Revue
Richard Cheese
Rod Stewart
Salt N’ Pepa
Salty Pirates
Sherbet
Sheryl Crow
Smashing Pumpkins
Soup Dragons
Spearmint
Spice Girls
Squirrel Nut Zippers
Strawberry Alarm Clock
Strawbery Switchblade
String Cheese Incident
Sugababes
Sugar
Sugar Ray
Sugarloaf
Sweet Honey in the Rock
Tangerine Dream
T-Bone Burnett
The Apples In Stereo
The Banana Splits
The Byrds
The Cake
The Cookies
The Cranberries
The Eels
The Jam
The Jams
The Lemon Drops
The Lemon Pipers
The Lollipop Shoppe
The Magic Mushrooms
The Partridge Family
The Peanut Butter Conspiracy
The Pop Group
The Raspberries
The Sea & Cake
The Sea Urchins
The Seeds
The Sugarcubes
The Sweet
The Waterboys
The Watermelon Men
Thin Yoghurts
Tim Rice
Tommy Roe
Toni Basil
Ultimate Spinach
Uncle Kracker
Vanilla Fudge
Vanilla Ice
Veruca Salt
Whiskeytown
Wild Cherry
Wings
An excellent title for this whole thread.
So Fine Young Cannibals gets in but Dead Kenedys doesn’t?
How did Hootie and the Blowfish get evicted from the list?
Two foods in one (real) name: Chuck Berry
Bees Make Honey
Gravy Train
The Muffins (different band from Martha and the Muffins)
Potliquor