I’ve also been sort of on the edge of what women consider attractive for much of my life. Let myself go only a little, I was invisible. Lose a little bit of weight and go to the gym a little bit, the difference in attention was striking.
But in my life I’ve known five people who had huge success rates with women. All of them for different reasons.
A) Had the conventionally attractive things going for him. All of them, and a lot. Tall medical student who spent a lot of time in the gym. Rich family, but they insisted he work for his spending money. Spent his first year of med school as a bouncer, said screw that and made massive amounts as a model. Has since gotten very rich. No one batted an eye at his success with women.
B) Certainly did not have any of those advantages. Easily describable as a friendly orangutan with a mild concussion. Scruffy but easy talker, paid a lot of attention to the person he was talking with, witty and did not palce much importance on sex.
C) Tried hard. Average looks, good talker, went out three nights a week and mostly came home alone, but came home with someone frequently enough that the total numbers racked up. Seems to have mostly gone for top lookers though.
D) Lives very close to the surface of his mind. Absolute honest, passionate about whatever he is doing, totally confident, full of energy. Above average looks, get into fights. The attraction he has on women is somewhat legendary. Women say the charisma is coming off him in waves.
And then there is E. E is abit like finding a place where gravity works in reverse. I cannot explain E. No man can. A woman once said “hes got game” but refused to say any more.
E is grossly fat, of intermittent hygiene, talks loudly and never lets anyone else get a word in edgewise. His subjects are Doctor Who and Marvel Comics with some brief forays into closely related matters. This draws in the best looking women. He never goes for anything but the top. And pulls like clockwork. Has for 30 years, even during the dark decades when being into comics and doctor who was socially disapproved of.
I did not believe it when I heard it. I have seen it, and I am still not sure if I believe it. E is some kind of supernatural phenomenon, not bound by the social laws of lesser mortals.