Evil Dead Mafia II - Teaser and Sign-Ups [Game On!]

[Normal_Phase]

@Telcontar

@Idle_Thoughts

Getting scared, are we?
Look, you’re not going to change my mind. You and OAOWs are the only two voting for me, for one. You both have been the most aggressive in not believing me and questioning it when, as you pointed out yourself, it could have been I was some sort of investigative role. Well, I was. And now I think you were trying to force me to claim. Nothing you can do to change my mind.
It’s okay to be scared, though. Your days are numbered in this game, good reason to be scared.
And I’ve already pointed out where I thought Guiri was fishing when I addressed her about it…so go back and find it and stop skimming.

So, i’m beginning to get annoyed with you in a non-game sense.

I EXPLICITLY DISCOUNTED THAT YOUR CHANGE OF HEART COULD HAVE COME FROM AN INVESTIGATION

Which is pretty much what a scum would do, wouldn’t they, if they wanted to keep up the pressure without any suspicions of fishing? Whether they really believed it or not? I don’t see that as a point in your favor.

Read that. then read it again. then read it again. Prior to your claim, to the best of my knowledge NAF would come up as scum to all investigations. So why would I ever have assumed that your change of heart would come from you being an investigator? If I thought it was possible you were an investigator, I probably would have given you more slack to avoid forcing a claim. Hell, if I were mafia then I would probably have given a suspected investigator even more slack because they’d eventually claim. What you’re saying just doesn’t make any sense. If your claim is real, then you have 1.) a role that no one has heard of before (well, it sounds a bit like Denathor’s false claim, but that’s about it) 2.) the only town role that could possibly have confirmed NAF as innocent last night. Expecting people to have played as if they knew what you were is silly.

Again, it makes sense from a scum perspective. Not-scum Idle is all over NAF, all the way up to Dawn. Five seconds after dawn breaks he’s changed his mind, with BS reasoning to boot. Honestly, what can that say to scum, other than investigator? Unlike the town, they know it’s not scum BS. What makes more sense?
– Idle’s being weird, but it means nothing
– Idle’s an unconventional sort of investigator (see Guiri’s question about the Book that Idle just linked)
– Idle’s some bizarre third party that needed to change sides as regards NAF for who knows what reason

NAF: Idle lists about 9 players who found his behavior suspicious and 4 who he thinks were role fishing (a claim he has not substantiated). If at least some of them weren’t scum, I’d be shocked. That’s a third of all living players.
[/QUOTE]