Unaccounted for deaths:
Chipacabra N1 (according to Hal, scum killed MHaye N1)
Omi No Kami N2 (Hal: non-deadite kill)
Special Ed N3 (Since he was Scum Strongman, I’m assuming Tom Scud would need some help killing him???)
This seems to confirm Mahaloth’s census of 2 third-party types.
I suppose theoretically if you had chosen the correct player on a Night I was able to watch them hand the Book to someone else, I could have corroborated your findings. Not that that would have confirmed either of us, but our roles could have meshed in that specific instance.
NETA:
Oh, crap, I forgot that Telcontar killed Chip, according to our masons.
Strongman usually indicates things like an extra scum kill or the ability to kill in spite of protection, not that the Strongman is him/herself more difficult to kill.
Corrections:
-NAF was killed N4
-Tom Scud raised squirrel D2, kills Astral N2
Comments:
-Omi’s dead suggests the other PFK has a killing power but there is no extra kill Night Four.
-Total Lost should claim her actions completely so Normal Phase could choose to confirm them. Also her role overlaps with USCDiver.
-There is a similar overlap between Oy! and OaOW both claimed an investigation that used public knowledge but Oy! confirms OaOWs action N4.
Vote Tom Scud
If we do hear a loud curse at Dusk using that White Powder might be a good choice to use on me, Oy!. It should cancel the Dread Curse I think. But if it remains silent Normal Phase would be a better choice to shurg of any Dread Darkness.
Assuming all are telling the truth that should neutralize Tom Scud (and in that case: holy shit Batman that party at your cave was nothing compared to the power synergy here).
But I don’t believe all powers are town (and the remaining scum just claimed vanilla). I feel there is a scum investigator and godfather missing but not sure if that directly points to OaOW. The not telling Tom Scud had the Book Day Four is a bad mark though.
If Mrs. McGinty is a vigilante type it’s important we discuss possible scum in case she wants to submit an action in advance (which I learned the hard way forgetting it last Night 
).
I forgot I still have a vote on Hal.
Unvote Hal
Vote Tom
Sure. I don’t really see anyone getting much from it - but I don’t mind sharing:
My first response:
The I send Storyteller this (I LOVE the way we can put in powers in advance and I just wanted to use the opportunity):
I did change my mind and later I made Night 4-action into this:
You’re no fun. :mad:
edit: double post
I explicitly deny responsibility for Omi’s death, and all other kills.
I didn’t say I’ve done nothing.
I leave for work in about 9 hours, after which I won’t be online until next week. I’ve already got my orders in for tonight, but if a quick case can be made for me to turn the boomstick on someone, I might be persuaded to change my mind…
It’s too bad about the one-day delay on the White Powder.
I love how you didn’t realize that at first. 
Confirmed:
3. Normal Phase - Mason and Investigator
-investigate Telcontar killed Chip N2
-investigate Mahaloth taking the census N4
9. Stanislaus - Mason and Investigator
5. Tom Scud - Redshirt (PFK)
-stole Necronomicom N1
-protected self D2, D3, D4
-raised zombie squirell N2
-killed special ed N4
Claimed Actions confirmed by confirmed:
Yes – probably not a straight serial killer, as no one has claimed any stopping action that night, and even the (or “a”, who knows) scum roleblocker is dead. Not certain, but likely.
It does – this is a significant reason for my current suspicion of her, because the scum must have been drooling at the thought of that Book, if only to keep it out of town hands. It doesn’t make sense that they would have no book-related powers at all; likewise no reason I could see why town would need two such dedicated roles.
USCDiver has the considerable mark in his favor of his having presented the killing case against peeker. While that being a really good bussing isn’t completely out of the question, I see no real reason to suspect him unless Total Lost first flips town.
I still believe Oy to have begun the game as town, though I remain unsure about what she is now. I’m virtually positive that OaOW did investigate you on night 4 – even if both are scum or something, I don’t think she’d make such a claim if she couldn’t back it up, not with me still in the game. But that doesn’t remotely excuse OaOW’s lack of speaking up about Tom Scud yesterday, nor his lack of breadcrumbs even earlier. How freaking difficult can it be to use “Tom. Probably. Has. The. Book.” as the first words of sentences first thing in the morning, or some such? You know people are going to go look if you die and flip “town investigator”.
Also, unvote Tom Scud
[b]vote: Natlaw**
vote: Natlaw, rather.
Let me help out there, Normal:
unvote Nanook who I still think is scum
vote Natlaw
What could possibly go wrong?
You don’t get lynched and Natlaw dies in your place? That would sort of suck.
You could hand me the Book in that case, to make up for your error.
Conflicting/overlapping claims:
We have a one-shot mass blocker (Drain) and a role-blocker (Brewha)
We have a book-watcher (Diver) and a book-hunter (Total Lost)
We have a two multi-tool roles - Oy! and OAOW
We have two Coroners: Hal can tell whether Deadites killed a body; OAOW can tell what powers a dead player had.
Also, whatever Rysto the Grave Robber could do.
UNOFFICIAL votes:
**Tom Scud: 12 **OAOW(2612), Total(2615), Hal(2619), Drain(2623), Stanislaus(2624), Oy(2629), lilflower(2634), brewha(2639), USCDiver(2651), Mahaloth(2653), Cookies(2709/2726), Natlaw(2725)
Natlaw: 4 Nanook(2685), Tex(2688), Normal(2734), Tom Scud(2736)
I didn’t find a vote for Mrs. Mc.