Evil Dead Mafia II - Teaser and Sign-Ups [Game On!]

[quote=“Natlaw, post:2898, topic:555493”]

Of course your claim fits perfectly since you claimed after those facts were put out in the open.
Probably a null tell is the fact that powers very similar to yours were part of a cover role in the original Evil Dead. Oy! link please? :stuck_out_tongue:
Your wish is my command.

Town Ash:

But things did change for weak Ash, who gained some powers over time. Cookies can relate that better than I can, since she was weak Ash.

However, there was also Evil Ash:

And, actually, McGinty’s claimed role here looks most like Almost Human’s “Creepy Guy with a Shovel,” whose role I am hunting down right now.

Fair point, but it gives me too much credit. Coming up with something so perfect straight off the top of my head, and writing the claim to fit so nicely with storyteller’s style, is far beyond my skills.

And, while I don’t expect any of this to convince people of my innocence, there’s also the question of why OAOW’s results were so oddly specific in the first place.

Sorry, I’m not following you here. What is it you think I’ve lied about?

The one I meant was the one MHaye fake claimed (I believed him :frowning: ).

You claim to have blocked anyone targeting Idle Night Two but as far as I can tell I wasn’t.

Oh, here it is:

Firstly, I didn’t protect him. I set up a trap to kill anyone who killed him.

As for my reasons, they were as follows:

*Based on events to that point, he seemed fairly likely to be innocent, and very unlikely to be lynched.

*He seemed like a very experienced and clever player.

Hence, someone who non-teammates (whether mafia or third-party) would prefer to be rid of, and someone who any town vigilante would be unlikely to target.

The reasons were much the same as those for ed, with the added point that Normal Phase and I have played a ton of games together, and I’d feel a particular satisfaction if I avenged her murder.

By that point, I was increasingly convinced of Normal Phase’s innocence, ed had slapped me all over the thread in the wake of my foolish outburst, and my PC had died. Absent the opportunity to properly research and consider my decision, Normal Phase became the default choice (a position made more secure after her role reveal).

I meant that the protect and trap powers made little sense as day powers. By the letter of my role PM, I could use them, but it’s hard to see why I’d ever want to. I never suggested that I couldn’t daykill.

Hmm… That is a little odd.

The exact wording:

I guess the phrase “prevent your target from being acted on” means I prevented your action from affecting Idle, while the canceled night prevented you from making the action in the first place. Otherwise, I can’t explain it.

Here’s the results PM I got after Idle’s death:

(Note: I didn’t get results PMs for the untriggered traps I set on all the other nights)

Hal Johnson is right about brewha Johnon being right!

Rrbba!

You’re saying by that that no one approached me last night (besides you)? If true, does that make the block on TexCat proportionally more likely to be the cause of there being no kill? (Or conversely, brewha lying, I guess.)

I have a few issues with you saying you’re not capable of fudging up a Storyteller-style role PM. From my experience of you, you absolutely are.

With Cookies looking a likely PFK, I’m now wondering if the events of last night might have cooked up between you and OAOW to make you both look good – he accuses you, but you have a nice explanation … and if either of you does go down, the other doesn’t look to be on the same team.

I’m not remotely sure about any of this, mind you, but I don’t want the above possibility to be forgotten, going forward.

I’m having a horrible week from a time-to-participate standpoint; apologies to anyone who’s expected my input.

No, I used a different power on you:

“1B - To set a trap. Choose a target (not yourself), and you can blow anyone who kills your target straight to hell. Won’t help the initial victim, though. Requires two shells - remember, this is a horror movie, so nothing you shoot dies on the first hit - but no shells are expended if the power is not triggered.”

You didn’t die, so it wasn’t triggered.

Thanks, but you over-estimate my skill as a villain. Remember, I haven’t had tons of experience like you have. :wink:

A truly fiendish plan. I almost wish it were true. :cool:

huh? N2 dead were Omi by Cookies, Astral by Tom Scud, Idle by self, and Rysto by scum. Not sure what Mrs. McG had to do with any of it.

If McGinty is lying then she probably wasn’t protecting Idle but probably trying to kill him. The problem is as you point out that we already got three other kills that Night so McGinty being another isn’t that likely (so I might be wrong about how Story resolved our (claimed) powers interacting).

Ahh. Idle would have been a likely target for scum, since he was going to brand at least one of them. Though by the same token, I suppose he was also a likely target for protection. Do we think that Ed’s extra kill would have a one-time thing, or would it be every night? That’s the only likely way for 2 scum kills isn’t it?

USC Johnson is right about Hal Johnson being right about Brewha Johnson!

Rrbba!!!

Anyone wanna explain what the heck this is all about?

nevermind…

Unvote Cookies
Not sure if it’s needed to
Final vote Cookies

Y’all are a talkative bunch.

We don’t have cookies on this side :frowning:

The Prince of Blades, special ed’s predecessor in Evil Dead 1, had the following abilities:

The ScumBoard linked to doesn’t seem to exist anymore.

It’s not clear how this would have worked out, as the person who played The Prince of Blades was lynched on Day 1.