[QUOTE=cthiax]
I think that treating “sexual identity” (gender preference) as a political issue is the problem, frankly. (And I see your :rolleyes: , and raise you a ;j - I was being tongue-in-cheek, but I’m sorry if I mischaracterized your argument).
It’s not something on which opinions count, just like race, to be triple double straight up frank. If you think all Chinese people should die, you are wrong. If you think it is wrong or bad or weird to be gay, you are wrong. That’s it. I know some people disagree…and I think they’re wrong.
Religion, politics, and abortion are all things with which there are valid arguments on either side of the debate. There is no valid argument for excluding visible queer people because there is no valid argument for excluding visible straight people. Heterosexuality saturates the culture, especially at a place like WoW, and what this policy does is put queer players there permanently on the defensive and in the underground, and that is wrong.
[/QUOTE]
There’s a perfectly valid argument for excluding visible displays of homosexuality (not using the word queer as it feels antiquated to me) is because it causes a brouhaha, and this is Blizzard’s world and they have a right to set the tone in it, especially since it is a fantasy universe.
Also, there’s nothing saying that it’s an absolute “right” that being gay is okay, that’s a whole other ethical debate, though, but to present anything as not having “any valid argument” is in itself an invalid argument.
All this policy does is tell homosexuals to not flagrantly flout their sexuality in THIS SPECIFIC MANNER. I truly think that if there was a guild that advertised itself as a “Heterosexual friendly guild” it wouldn’t be accepted.
It’s in the presentation, really.
Heterosexuality may be “in your face” but Blizzard isn’t concerned with the composition of WoW guilds, it is concerned with public chat and such and public perception within the servers, that is why I think Blizzard would quash any guild that advertised itself as being supportive of ANY sexuality.
The only reason you’re seeing this through the lens you’re seeing it through is because homosexuals are a lot more likely to advertise a guild for themselves than heterosexuals since most people will just assume that most people are straight anyways.