I agree 1000% with goboy. The smoldering volcano of need bit is not going to help.
You need to charm her, capture her heart, and let her not your intentions with a little panache. A lighthearted touch is also best so she doesn’t think you are a psycho, just fun.
Try this:
By yourself a black mask, a cape, and a long-stemmed rose.
The next time she comes into your store, tell her to “wait right here, you’ll be right back.” Grab her hand and look into her eyes when you say it, but don’t bet over serious about it.
Go in the back. Put on your mask and cape, and grab the rose between your teeth. Sneak out the back, and enter from the front.
Call her name and snap your cape.
Walk over with a flourish, and present her the rose on a knee.
Stand up, and look at her a moment.
Say “I am the bandito of love. And I have come to steal your heart. But like all noble banditos, I only steal what is rightfully mine. I have come to rescue you from the clutches of the foul and vile [insert boyfriend’s name here,].”
Take of your mask. Smile winningly. Open your arms.
“and now you must kiss me.”
Stand and wait. Either you have made a legendary fool of yourself the likes of which they will speak of with profound awe for ages to come, or you are about to get some serious smooching.
Make it light hearted and fun.
She may kiss you, or she may not. She might be thinking about it, so don’t panic if you start feeling like a fool.
If you think she’s thinking about it, but embarassed and a little charmed say ironically “I see that I have caught you off guard and left you stunned, my beautiful mountain flower. Fine, do not kiss me. Let me stand here in my cape looking mysterious while my heart breaks. I don’t mind. But at the very least will you allow this noble bandito to take you out to dinner tomorrow night? I promise to leave the cape at home.”
If she has any kind of heart she’ll agree. She can’t help but being charmed. Then if you blow it at dinner it’s your own fault.
And I wouldn’t have suggested this, but any woman who spent the night with you on the seawall is looking for you to convince her, that your better than the slug she’s with.
If he’s as bad as you say. You can’t fail.