[QUOTE=Wile E]
I am also disappointed with the way everyone seemed to turn their backs on him. Charlie is not exactly the most useful person but he has always tried to help. As someone else commented, considering the things Sawyer, Sayid and Jin have done and how they seemed to have been forgiven, they could cut Charlie a little slack, too.
[/QUOTE]
I’m sure it won’t last indefinitely. Other Losties have had backs turned on them, but this group doesn’t seem to hold a grudge too long. Sawyer was persona non grata for a bit, but everybody seems fine with him now. The crowd of watchers turned their backs on Kate when Sawyer revealed that she had tried making a fake ID and was trying to usurp his place on the raft (and that she was the one the marshall was guarding), but she didn’t stay shunned that long.
I agree with your assessment – Charlie may not be using right now, but he’s still an addict, and he’s been hanging onto those statues as a safety blanket, knowing that they are still available.
I also don’t mind that the flashbacks haven’t been the big “shocker” ones that we got in the first season – they can’t ALL be like that. I think the reason they felt more awe-inspiring in the first season is that was when we were learning the “secrets” of the characters for the first time. New flashbacks about the same characters will reveal a little more insight into the character, but unlikely revelations on the same magnitude of the first one. For example, some have commented that the one real interesting flashback was Eko. Well, he’s a new character, and that was the first “story” we’ve seen on him – of course it is!
On Charlie, while there was nothing unexpected in this one, I think it did give us a little more insight into his character. Specifically, some background to illustrate why he’s so protective of Ethan. Even though they were both addicts, Charlie still seemed to be more responsible than his brother when it came to Liam’s baby – and more interested in the child’s welfare, and the family. Then Charlie felt abandoned when Liam decided to shape up – AND betrayed (very understandably) when Liam sold Charlie’s piano in the process. Charlie is still grasping for family – he wants desperately to be part of a family again – he’s been trying to fill the role of provider and caretaker since Ethan was born. I think part of what pushed him over the edge into this episode was being shunned by Claire in the last episode. He was desperate to get back what he had before, and not willing to be patient and let things cool down slowly. His addict-style behavior pushed it along, too.
Although, we may also be seeing the beginnings of whatever the “sickness” is that got Danielle’s crew. (Michael, then Charlie). I haven’t discounted that as a possibility.