Yeah, it is subjective - my threshold was when voting for the runner up would not have changed the outcome (your macey vote and the late Millit votes) and votes made for MHaye Day Six.
Maybe the phrasing ‘Reasons X Is Not Scum’ is confusing. I took it as ‘votes town would make, but scum most likely would not’.
Since Zeriel missed votes the first four Days and isn’t posting a lot, I double checked whether his MHaye voted should place him that low on my list or not. His vote is about MHaye missing his promised analysis and the slip about Hal, pointing out it was not forgotten public knowledge and mentioning it again Night Five. Day Six he only makes short posts that he doesn’t trust MHaye.
So he didn’t try to stop MHaye’s lynch D5, which scum JSexton did. I think JSexton was not alone though, so most likely a scum in the other unknown Hal voters (brewha, Nanook, Natlaw and special ed, but I known for sure I’m town).
This one stands out because of special ed quote, not Zeriel and since he never responded to it, I’ll ask again what he meant by it:
-Cookies never described her abilities (unless you think her mostly dead killer story was the little white lie). The role PM she posted certainly didn’t contain (movie) Ash-like powers.
-Should I read the second sentence as: ‘Movie Ash-like without the movie Ash powers’ (as I did here calling them imaginary due to the color) or is it a slip ‘Evil Ash-like without the Evil Ash powers’?