Mafia: Evil Dead - DAY/NIGHT EIGHT

The Game Room
61

pedescribe, Mason
Hockey Monkey, Mason

Almost Human, Backup Doc
amrussell
brewha
Millit the Frail
Nanook of the North Shore
Natlaw
Rapier42
special ed
Total Lost (not scum)
Zeriel

MOSTLY DEAD
hawkeyeop, Alpha Redshirt (Vanilla)
Mhaye, Demon Moose, (Scum Investigator)
macey, The Prince of Blades (Scum Strongman)
JSexton, aka Evil Ash, a Scum Special
NO LONGER ALIVE
Pleonast, the Sorority Treasurer (Mason)
NAF1138, Vincent, the Dog Who Knows Things (Investigative)
Diggitcamara, The Inquisitive Fool (Special)
Thing Fish, The Religious Figure Having a Crisis of Faith (Investigative)
CometotheDarkSideWeHaveCookies, Ash (Special)
Chucara, Beta Redshirt (Vanilla)
Hal Briston, Alpha Redshirt (Vanilla)
Dotchan, Alpha Redshirt (Vanilla)
bufftabby, The Skanky Vampire Demon (Scum Roleblocker)
peekercpa, Predator (Third-Party Serial Killer)
Blaster Master, Freddy Krueger (Third-Party Serial Killer)

End of Day One:

macey (9) - brewha, hawkeyeop, hockey monkey, special ed, dotchan, JSexton, pedescribe, Rapier42, Millit the Frail
Thing Fish (4) - total lost, peekercpa, Pleonast, Chucara
Chucara (2) - NAF1138, Diggitcamara
Pleonast (1) - Thing Fish
peekercpa (1) - Natlaw
CometotheDarkSideWeHaveCookies (1) - bufftabby
Blaster Master (1) - Cookies
Rapier42 (1) - amrussell
No Vote (7) - MHaye, Blaster Master, Nanook of the North, Zeriel, Hal Briston, Almost Human, macey

End of Day Two:

Peekercpa (6) - Nanook, Brewha, Blaster Master, Special Ed, Rapier42, Mhaye
Dotchan (4) - Amrussell, Total Lost, Hockey Monkey, Natlaw
Hawkeyeop (2) - Pedescribe, Almost Human
Chucara (2) - NAF1138, Diggitcamara
Blaster Master (2) - Peekercpa, Chucara
Diggit (1) - Millit
Cookies (1) - Hawkeyeop
No Vote - Dunno

End of Day Three:

Chucara (8) - Diggitcamara, Natlaw, Almost Human, Amrussell, Mhaye, Millit, Special Ed, Rapier
Blaster Master (1) - Chucara
Amrussell (1) - Pedescribe
Cookies (1) - Brewha
Almost Human (1) - Total Lost
No Vote - Dunno

End of Day Four:

Blaster Master (7) - Natlaw, Dotchan, Brewha, Millit the Frail, JSexton, Hockey Monkey, Mhaye
Hockey Monkey (1) - Almost Human
Hal Briston - Cookies, Amrussell, Pedescribe, Blam, Special Ed
Cookies - Hal
Mhaye - NAF

Day Five vote count:

Hal Briston (5) - Brewha, Nanook, Jsexton, Natlaw, Special Ed
Mhaye (4) - Hal Briston, Zeriel, Dotchan, Cookies
Brewha (2) - Amrussell, Total Lost
Almost Human (2) - Hockey Monkey, Pedescribe
Nanook (1) - Millit the Frail
JSexton (1) - Almost Human

Day Six vote count:

Mhaye (5) - Zeriel, Nanook, Pedescribe, Special Ed, Total Lost
Nanook (3) - Millit the Frail, Dotchan, Brewha
JSexton (3) - Almost Human, Amrussell, Natlaw
Special Ed (1) - Mhaye

Day Seven vote count:
JSexton (5) - Almost Human, Amrussell, Natlaw, Special Ed, Total Lost
Amrussell (4) - Rapier, Millit the Frail, Jsexton, Brewha
Special Ed (2) - Zeriel, Pedescribe
Almost Human (1) - Hockey Monkey
Nanook (1) - Dotchan
Natlaw (1) - Nanook

62

On the assumption that scum tried to save Jsexton, I’m going to [color]Vote Brewha[/color].

I don’t like the case against Millit.

I’ll try to back later today with more analysis.

63

Bah.

Vote Brewha.

64

Yeah, you know what? I like that alot, because look at Day Six. Brewha shows up there, on Nanook. And then on Day 5, he’s got the lead vote on Hal.

This is just as damning for Millit (and myself) as it is for Brewha, but I don’t like the case against Millit, it feels like we’re reaching with that one. And since I’m Town, that leaves Brewha.

65

I just don’t know on the Millit case. She seems to have been completely off the radar to me - which is exactly how scum would want to play.

And after Amrussel’s exhaustive and thorough case, I can see that her play could definitely be pro scum

Vote Millit The Frail

And on the assumption the the sky is blue, I’m going to ask Rapier what he’s on about.

Jsexton was scum. Scum getting lynched is bad for them. Wow, quite the assumption you’re making there Rapier. Really reaching on that one!

Unless you are trying to say that my not voting for JSexton is the same as trying to save him. If you look back, I voted Amrussel early on and then was gone for the weekend without internet access. I had no idea that the votes were building for JSexton, and wasn’t really here for it at all. If that can somehow be construed attempting to save JSexton, I’d love to know how.

Granted, the early vote was invalid due to not unvoting Nanook - but I didn’t know it at the time.

66

Wow. Hit a nerve, did I?

The pattern is pretty plain, Brewha. Every vote you’ve made, with the exception of your Day One open against Macey, has clear anti-town motivation. Day Two, you voted for Peeker, an admitted killer. Day Three, you voted for Cookies, whom we now know to be a power role of some sort (and possibly the only chance we had to get rid of the mostly-dead). Day Four, you’re early on the Blam-wagon. Day Five, you helped vote Hal off instead of MHaye. Day Six, you’re the late vote on Nanook, while we know now that the other two voters are known scum. Day Seven, you’re the late vote on amrussell.

Sorry, man, but you’re a better lynchee than Millit. How’d you manage to be right there with the Town on both our PFKs, but you haven’t managed to hit scum at all? And don’t tell me about Day One, thats the best time for scum to distance themselves from eachother.

67

No, didn’t hit a nerve. Just did a poor job of explaining yourself. I like this one better.

And, what exactly are you sorry about? Sorry that I should be lynched? That’s a pretty messed up thing to say. If you are town and I am scum. You shouldn’t be sorry. If you are town and you think I’m scum, you shouldn’t be sorry.

But, if you are scum and you know I am town - and you know I shouldn’t be lynched - then I see the reason for your apology.

68

I appreciate the sentiment, but it’s Almost Human you have to thank.

69

I understand that no one’s going to believe me for saying “I am Town.” But honestly, there’s nothing I can do. I haven’t seen anyone get out of a hole like this in this game without a roleclaim of some sort. Hey, I’m a Beta Redshirt. There you go. I’ve got nothing. Bad play is not always a scum tell; in fact I expect the remaining 1-2 scum are hanging out right in the middle. They have control of their image in the game. They can vote for town or they can vote for other scum, and they KNOW who is whom. If they have any sort of decent strategy, they’ve kept themselves neutral, as far as voting patterns go.

Honestly, I’m getting tired of playing anyway. I kind of suck. :stuck_out_tongue: But I will attempt to keep the spreadsheet going after you all kill me, because some of you find it useful. I may or may not update it tonight; I’ve got plans.

70

Aw hell, that sure doesn’t sound like scum response. I need to look closer at Rapier anyway

Unvote Millit

71

Dude, you know this is a game, right? Getting lynched sucks. If I manage to convince folks to lynch you, I’ve ended your fun, for this game, and I don’t mind using a turn of phrase to indicate that.

But keep having fun with attacking my verbage, rather than address the points of my case against you. And knock yourself out with that closer look at me, while you’re at it.

I’m quite good with my vote now.

72

I’m going to agree with Rapier on this one–I frequently feel bad when someone is going up to the block, especially if I’m not sure. I actually almost got lynched once for expressing that exact sentiment for Fluiddruid–who was town–but an investigator saved me.

73

P.S. My post count has dropped tremendously because I fully expected to get killed last night, and the night before. So I had sort of written this game off already.

74

Hmm. That’s weird. It’s us against them if you ask me. And if I know I got scum pinned, I don’t feel bad. I guess it’s just me, huh?

75

Hey, Rapier. You know this is a game, right? No need to apologize ( I mean other than for voting for a townie). My boss would be quite happy to see me lynched - I’m spending way too much time here.

I’d honestly be happy to be done with this game. We’re so far ahead at this point that my lynch really wouldn’t make a difference. But, I’m not going to do anything to hurt the town and it’d be nice to be alive when we win.

76

perhaps you got protected, eh?

I just realized I’d never voted. I’ve gone through Almost’s cases again. I did recheck her facts on **millit **and found no flaws.

The case against **brewha **seems weaker, but still interesting.

I think this weekend might provide me the opportunity to do some massive re-reading. These past few days have been hectic with children with shingles, band concerts. For now, I’m going to me too again and

vote Millit

Hopefully the case stands, but if not, at least we’ll find out if killed beta redshirts eliminate mostly dead Scum.

77

Funnily enough, the same argument applies to you and you even voted late for macey. I agree about Millit though, but I haven’t looked enough at you or brewha Today to warrant a vote.

I did look at Millit and special ed. My vote for special ed is mainly based on him almost always voting late for the lynch candidate and explicitly wanting to vote with town. The crux is whether he was bussing his fellow scum:
-macey could be, it was after his flip out
-MHaye not unlikely, since he didn’t even protect himself
-JSexton is a gamble though, it required scum to give up on him since there where others to vote for. But they did have reasons to think saving JSexton was a lost cause:
Almost Human just claimed, was unvoted by Total Lost and pedescribe, who jumped on JSexton. So it did look like the confirmed block was going for JSexton. special ed followed and perhaps was stuck when pede turn on AH again.
Yes, both JSexton and ed could have voted amrussell, but that would have looked really scummy if amrussell had turned up town.

Another point in his defense was setting up the questions for Diggit. Could the Deadites have known Thing Fish dead due to investigating a Demon (and not a vigilante kill). bufftabby would need to have gotten a PM like Cookies did after BlaMs attack. But this is too much speculation though, so I think it is more a town tell.

The other thing I found on re-read was special eds response to Blaster Masters dead (starting from this post). He tells us to ignore any claims by BlaM, but like I thought then there was definitely some truth to them. We know now that it was mostly truthful: we got further evidence for a doctor, Cookies was not just vanilla and dotchan was Alpha.

My vote is staying on special ed for Today, Tomorrow I’ll recheck on Rapier42, brewha. Also don’t like the low contributions from Nanook and Zeriel.

I’m at work so, Story could you post a vote count? Or maybe someone else.

78

Hey guys. I really need a sub in the offboard site game which I’m modding. Is there anyone available? Brewha? Millit? Anyone?

79

Sorry Pede. I can only do mafia one at a time. Like I said above, I think I’d get fired if I tried to do two!

80

Well, it looks like I’m on a field trip for the rest of the day. So, I’ll just have to vote now and leave it.

[color=blue]Vote Millit the Frail[/vote]

Actually, Pede. If Millit is the last scum and this game is over today - I’ll sign up.