Johnny_Bravo:
Three cultists have been daykilled. Mafia appears to have been planning this for a while.
If we accepts that they’ve been planning this, then it also stands to reason that they planned this patsy business as well. I noticed that hawkeye and Texcat’s claims were very close to one another.
If the plan has always been to confuse things to try and engineer a patsy lynch (and force the cult to redirect), then it makes sense that a scum hawkeye would claim so as to let Texcat counterclaim.
Meanwhile, Biotop (who I think is scum) backed up hawkeyeop immediately after his claim but gave nothing substantive. He gave equally non-substantive approval for your post which predicted hawkeyeop as town and plumpudding as scum. Just general vague approval.
This last bit is pure WIFOM and should be taken with a big grain of salt, but they put in the order to kill MHaye, who basically didn’t play yesterday. You’re the one making cases and you’re the one who’s been keeping the vote records updated. You’re the more dangerous townie right now. Unless you’re completely wrong.
Even without that hammer rule, town is going to have to follow the lead of the only confirmed townie and follow his vote completely or we risk losing.
Yes, I was a bit surprised to still be alive. Being completely wrong is a possibility, as I have a history of being 100% certain while also being wrong. But there is another side to this coin. Perhaps the question is, not why was I left alive, but why was MHaye killed? At the end of Day 10, he made this observation:
Evening all.
I’m not doing very well Mafia hunting Today.
I have to admit that most of Today I’ve felt that Johnny Bravo was a potential Mafia suspect. The main reason is that, a couple of times Today, he’s been discussing Mafia data and talked about how there are two Mafiate votes unaccounted for.
There are three Mafia.
The second instance was in [post=20073095]D10.098[/post], in the penultimate bullet point. The first seems to have run away. I’ll post it if I find it.
Back in post [post=20073131]D10.100[/post]we see Johnny repeat a pattern of “I want to fimd a Mafiate” while placing a vote on someone he thinks has a good chance of being a Wolf. This is reminiscent of several of his anti-Cult votes, but has the advantage of being aimed at an alleged scumball.
One of the things that caught my eye was in [post=20066497]post D10.010[/post], where Johnny is arguing that he is not Mafia. He says, in closing: -But he overlooks one thing.
Bufftabby was not the Alpha Wolf.
She may have been arguing for a Johnny kill for all 8 Nights she was alive, but if the Alpha Wolf wanted to kill someone else, that player would be the one killed. Consequently Johnny’s last point carries no weight.
That being said, the vote leaders are Zeriel 7 and TexCat 5. I have had a vague and unsubstantiated feeling that TexCat is scum most of the game, but I suspect thgat a large part of it is…
wait for it …
[spoiler]a grudge.
It goes back to her role as Ra’s Al Ghul the Serial Killer in Storyteller’s Arkham Revisited game I referred to a few times. Even though she helped us win.[/spoiler]
As for Zeriel, he seems under suspicion for low participation, so I’ll pass on a vote for him.
Vote Johnny Bravo.
I’ll be watching robots bashing each other to bits for the next while.
Note where he says that Johnny has been discussing Mafia data and talked about how there are two Mafiate votes unaccounted for, when there are actually three Mafia. Johnny’s reply was as follows:
That’s a rough typo, I’ll admit. I don’t know if I just counted the red names in the deceased list and counted Hal twice or what.
I’m not sure about the rest of it though. I’ve been spending more time looking for wolves because we have more data for going after wolves. We’ve never lynched a Mafia so we don’t have voting records for those.
And yeah, bufftabby isn’t the alpha, but there are some questionable wolf kills. They knew for certain that Lightfoot wasn’t Mafia, but they killed her over somebody who at least one of them was apparently convinced I was the enemy? This is some occam’s Razor stuff.
Anyway, there are three kills and at least one reveal between now and when voting starts back up. You’re more or less king townie for now, so if you want to drive the train there’s not much I can do but keep making cases for after my reveal. We’ll see what happens come Dawn
So this seems to be both a typo AND a case of miscounting.