Is it necessary to lynch Koldanar now? I think we should leave him alone for now and look for scum elsewhere. I would be in favor of a Koldanar lynch only if two other cult members claim. If we go for a Koldanar lynch we might be making another mistake over bullshit meta game analysis.
I say there is no rush to lynch Koldanar. If he is scum, we have five more scum to try and kill. Koldanar can wait.
But if the role blocker claims, there are 2 Scum role blockers alive that can effectively neuter the power.
of course that could keep them off your back.
BAH yep- I didn’t recall that critter at the time of my typing. thank you.
Still it is a very different PM from the other switch PMs we have seen, non?
and yet I see no reason to fake it. so- null
Very odd that a cult member would disparage another cult member’s claim with so little evidence. Especially when their win condition allegedly requires them to stay alive in the end. Seems like a risky move.
If anything, Sinjin looks a lot more fake and scummy than Koldanar does.
If anything, your claim makes me feel even stronger that Koldanar is a Cultist. He shared at least two bits of information (The role name of the serial killer, the fact only two cultists had a number associated with them) that I wouldn’t expect scum to know.
You’re conflating his switch claim with his role claim. I’d be willing to bet that scum had some switches. Scum could have easily received a Glados switch and Koldanar could easily have modified that bit that he underlined about the cult. Perhaps it originally said, “It’s is absolutely not something that will help the mafia. Likely something that would kill you all.”
And only two cultists have a number??? I don’t remember that bit of info. Where did you see that?
His PM power section was unlike the other LUTHA and, in fact, unlike any others in the game. And the fact that Crys died just as she was investigating Koldanar seems awfully suspicious to me.
The first two cultists revealed were the first deacon and second deacon. My assumption (perhaps not everyone else’s) was that the rest would be 3-5. One of the surprising parts of Koldanar’s claim was that he didn’t have a # and had a different power then the revealed cultists. Sinjin, if we take things at face value, also has no # and has a different power. So for this to work the scum would have needed to know that not all cultists were the same. I’m not sure why they would know that.
This is false reasoning. His Glados bit of information is from his switch. I had information on my switch as well and I assume that everyone else who had a switch knows who it controls. He never stated that only two cultists had a number associated with them. Why did you assume that?
Because they are making it up. I am a cultist which will become apparent when I die. I have no idea if there are more than two deacons. The Lutha have no idea who the other Lutha are. How would one of us know how many deacons there are. This is a false trail.
