Mafia Reunion - Day One

The “other top suspect”? By whose reckoning is Johnny Bravo the “other top suspect”? the vote count as of septimus’ post:

Colby - 9
septimus - 6
ToeJam - 3
Lakai 3
Normal - 2
Angel - 2
7 people - 1

If there’s an “other top suspect” it would be septimus himself (though I suppose that asking for a self-vote is a bit much…). If not him, then *maybe ***ToeJam **or Lakai…but I fail to see how Johnny Bravo, tied for 7th place with 1 vote, qualifies here as a “top suspect”.

I have no particular problem with the fact that septimus voted for a ‘non-contender’ here, but his reasoning stinks.

There was something about this post that bugged me, but I couldn’t figure it out…until I took a good look at **Plumpudding’s **posting history in this game.
209 comment about Colby
214 comment about being on vacation
215 comment about the Patsy role
342 comments about editing, color, the Patsy…has no suspicions
344 comment about town mechanics
358 comment about playstyle
365 comment about being logged in to the board
372 comment about page refreshes on the board
384 comment about Investigative roles and the Patsy
386 comment about the Patsy
401 defense against not having voted yet
408 comment about a previous post
412 vote for Biotop (for being “chatty”? It’s hard to tell for certain, because he refers to a previous comment by Guiri, but doesn’t link the specific post he is referring to)
414 comment about the Patsy
415 continuance of post 414 (I think )
422 comment about Investigative roles and the Patsy
423 comment about Investigative roles and the Patsy
425 comment about Investigative roles and the Patsy
426 comment about Investigative roles and the Patsy
430 comment about Investigative roles and the Patsy
432 comment about Investigative roles and the Patsy
435 comment about Investigative roles and the Patsy
440 off-topic joke post?
458 joke post
470 unvote Biotop (understands his (Biotop’s) real-life participation issues)
472 vote for Prof. Pepperwinkle (for not participating in the conversation)
473 correction of typo in post 472

That’s 27 posts, almost all of which are discussions of mechanics, playstyle, game setup, etc. The only real ‘substantive’ posts are the ones in which he places votes. Interestingly, both votes are based on the player in question posting “fluff” or not participating fully…while Plumpudding himself has basically spent the Day doing exactly that. Also of note is that both votes are one-offs; the players in question are in absolutely no danger whatsoever of being lynched Today.

In short, Plumpudding has ‘good statistics’ toDay: lost of posts, a couple votes…but nothing with any actual weight. Just like Scum would want to do, so that they ‘look good’ while taking no chances of posting anything that might come back to haunt them later.

unvote Colby11
vote Plumpudding

I still think that Colby is Scum, and I’m suspicious of septimus as well. I’m placing this vote in order to get it on record, but should my potential vote on either Colby or septimus become ‘significant’ near EoD, I will change it.