Now that I can tell you. There are only 5. I didn’t want to do it before, but I will now to show that I am willing to share information. I’m not lying and you will find that out more likely than sooner or later.
I’m not going to sit here and sulk and fight for my skin. I’m going to place my vote now
**Captain Klutz. **
[/QUOTE]
His wording on his pm was significantly different than mine for the switch.
I flipped the bodyguard switch last night so if the other switch wasn’t thrown I could have just very well saved someone’s behind at the end of day today. If that isn’t trying to protect towns interest idk what is.
Brewha is a lying liar, but not 3rd party (assuming THAT isnt also a lie), but does that mean he is instantly scum? No. Though trust is thin, he did fess up about his lie when called out. I’m gonna put a stankeye on him for now.
Now crys, I 99% believe she is telling the truth since she provided a pm from a role that isn’t common knowledge. Her role claims “non hostile”, whatever that really means. We need to kill scumbos, which she almost certainly isn’t. But how can we trust her to always vote in town’s best interest?
Just remembered that there is a resolution order to wins, but I can’t go look it up now. I’m at the Canes/Penguins game, (I’m a hockey monkey after all).
It’s like asking what if the sun doesn’t rise in the morning. It’s hard to wrap my head around.
We pick one for him, I suppose. Probably someone he loves. And maybe his dog too.
I’m not criticizing your vote, because I might join you, but your reasoning seems…weird. you think she fabricated that entire pm that she posted? I’m not saying it’s impossible, but just not very likely.
Redacted, maybe. But I simply cannot see two masonic groups like these, both being on the town side. And we KNOW there is a legitimately townie masonic group out there.
One of the pointers to said redaction is that we have the win conditions which explicitly state (bleached):
Crys tells us her win conditions are
one of the two must be wrong. And I am betting there was a modification in the latter one.
So the cult of Lutha sounds like a group of survivors, with limited investigations thrown in? (Actually the investigation is only for looking for other cultists.) I am not sure what advantage knowing who another member of the cult actually has, though. To create some sort of ad hoc mason group?
I am going to
Unvote ToeJam
Only because it looks like it will be probably be mod-handled. But i need to digest and probably research the 3P role that ahs been revealed. Don’t cultists usually recruit?
That doesn’t seem contradictory to me. Maybe I am missing something, but a survivor would win with whoever wins, as long as they are alive when the game ends. this is a (supposedly) a group of survivor-types, who all win as lon as one of them survives. The win condition for the group, in other words, is keep at least one member alive to end game, whether end game is Town outnumbering scum, or scum outnumbering Town and other scum.
It’s tough to read, did you find anything? Any suspicious key moments? Trends?
Have you attempted to make sense of D1 yet?
I think it gets discussed later but cannot find it now, why would Klutz assume it was a town power, and not a false claiming scum or third party?
Was this a smudge or awe?
Was this about not reading the rules?
Choice wording.
Looks like you’re confusing known knowns and unknown knowns here.
+1 This, but not herding cats which can give people an easy out, plausible deniability? If a double lynch comes along naturally, I don’t think we should limit or restrict it, the public record is there.
Probably flogging a dead horse but this is sufficiently different. Idle (used to/usually) asks Town to ignore his claim, leaves the wifom for scum. He always does it. It’s neither anti-game nor does it hurt town.
More dead horses but this puts Bufftabby and Prof.P’s posts into a whole different light, what an omission!!!
As I was reading I did about six 180s regarding the Chronos/brewha plan. It’s moot now, but was fun to read… I am curious if power roles are informed that their power is switched off, if they were blocked, or simply hear nothing - probably nothing.