Hi, I’m back as well and trying to make sense of all the roles and their possiblities.
This game does seem really quiet in comparison to other games though.
Well, with no vanilla’s in the game, any forced role claim from a nonscum will out a town power role. I am not sure how to proceed on day 1 in this case. Would we be better going no lynch and seeing what happens tonight, or would this be bad thing?
Ok,
Win conditions: From Pleonast’s rules, for the town it looks we have to keep the witches alive to win. Could we end up with a situation where no-one wins?
I think we will have to be very careful of rushed lynches. If the Vicar has decided to bless someone and we suddenly rush lynch someone else due to roleclaim, we could end up with an unprotected corpse. Not a good situation. Of course, we don’t know who the Vicar has decided to protect each day, but it could get nervy towards the end of each day.
More as I think on it.
Not that I disagree with your point about rush lynches, but I don’t think we need to worry about your scenario. Here’s what **Pleonast **said just above:
So it would appear that the vicar can just pick whoever gets lynched, rather than having to specify the actual person (unless I am reading **Pleonast **wrong).
I think we have to lynch, because we get information from lynches (not as quickly as we would in other games, but still.) If we don’t lynch, we’ll be in exactly the same situation on future Days as we are today, only with fewer townies left alive.
You are reading correctly.
I see your point. Our first day ends day after tomorrow I believe.
Could we get the current votecount please Pleonast?
I somehow edited out an important rule.
A Player who is killed, but comes back to life because of a Witchdoctor’s enchantment, will know the Identity of his killer.
Current vote count is in the Players link in my sig.
Edit: vote list is also in the Mirror link, if you can’t access Google docs. I’ll put the final vote count in this thread.
Vote Nesta
This one can make the Witch Doctor(s) very powerful if they guess right. It means that a night killer could effectively be caught a couple of days after they have killed, effectively giving the town some real assistance.
Here’s hoping they guess right. 
Given the aggressive deadlines to this particular game we need everyone voting. As things stand MHaye gets lynched with a crummy 2 votes and we would get precious little information from the lynch. Let’s see some votes people!
(Color removed to avoid confusion)
Any reason? Random? Trying to get Nesta talking?
I ask because while voting records are good for analysis, actual reasoning is more helpful.
I don’t think either Mad or nesta are part of this game.
Oops nevermind. I was looking at the wrong player list. :smack: Sorry!!!
Damn …outed already…I am The Player That Doesn’t Exist.I can’t be killed so don’t bother voting for me.
**vote MHaye **
For the “don’t lynch people based on what happened in other games comment.”
Unbelievable.
Are you seriously advocating that we should carry grudges from game to game? That just because someone was scum in the last game, that they must be scum in this one?
You can’t see that voting this way is a recipe to kill your own side?
Or have you forgotten, as One and Only Wanderers evidently has (or has not bothered to learn) that I was not in fact scum last game to finish, so I’m not actually running scared of someone voting me because I got them killed last time out?
Well, other than Idle Thoughts, when I called him a liar for claiming Monk and he got hanged as a result - but that’s because IT was scum.
And if you’re voting me for this, why didn’t you vote for me last game?
I was willing to cut some slack. I thought people were joking. Not any more. You’re willing to lynch on a piece of good game advice? That’s anti-town.
I’ll vote later.
It’s time for the first installment of “Who’s Not Playing?” Here’s a list of people and their posts so far, divided into Fluff and Game posts. Fluff posts (the first number) are just fun stuff; Game posts (the second number) are actual gameplay. (I tried to be very loose in my definition of Game). Sorry, I don’t know how to do a table or chart. I apologize in advance for any miscounts.
- Idle Thoughts 1 4
- Diomedes 3 14
- Kat 1 2
- Hockey Monkey 1 8
- CatinaSuit 1 2
- HazelNutCoffee 2 4
- Hal Briston 2 0
- DiggitCamara 0 2
- Drain Bead 2 1
- Blaster Master 0 0
- Rysto 0 16
- nesta 0 1
- amrussell 0 4
- fluiddruid 0 0
- Pygmy Rugger 1 0
- Fretful Porpentine 0 3
- MadTheSwine 1 2
- Zoggie 3 6
- MHaye 0 2
- sachertorte 1 4
- One and Only Wanderers 0 5
- ShadowFacts 1 7
Fluidruid and **Blaster Master ** have no posts of any kind.
Hal Briston and Pygmy Rugger (who was away) have no Game posts.
Drain Bead and Nesta have 1 Game post.
So, with that in mind:
Unvote MHaye
Vote Fluiddruid
I expect Blaster Master will be in here at any time with an information dump. His weekends are pretty full. I will give a tentative first vote to Fluiddruid. This is subject to change as I have no evidence for the vote other than lurking. This is just to jump start some discussion so we can hopefully find a good decision be Wed.
In accordance with Pleonast’s rules…bolded and on a separate line:
Vote Fluiddruid
Actually, I can get behind that sentiment. If only to get some kind of response from someone who hasn’t posted yet.
Vote Blaster Master