Survivor All-Stars was the 8th season of Survivor and with next season being Survivor 16 I think we’re due for another All-Stars edition. Wikipedia also says next season might take place in Palau again and I think a repeat location lends itself well to an All-Star season.
Let’s say that there will be 21 players spread across three teams. Let’s also say that no one who competed on the first Survivor All-Stars can come back again.
So who would you want in All-Stars 2? Does Stephanie get a third shot? Will rockle make lusty noises as she writes down Ian’s name? What about my man Yau-Man? Or does someone from way back when strike you as a contender?
I’ll start us off and say that Tom, Yul and Earl need to come back. The three classiest Survivors ever, they would make an unbeatable alliance, so let’s say they’re “captains” of each of the three teams.
If you are the type who likes spoilage, there’s discussion about it all over the place with people tracking which former survivors are “unavailable” during the time of filming.
Please, please, please, if they absolutely must do an ASS2, let there be no past winners. Just like last time round, no-one’s going to let them win again, so it pretty much makes their participation pointless.
Though having said that, I would like to see Yul and Jonathan team up again, perhaps forming an alliance with Yau-Man, Ian the Dolphinboy and Cirie. That would be an alliance made of awesome covered with awesomesauce.
If they give Stephenie and Bobby-Jon a third chance, someone needs to be shot.
If they’re going to be all-stars, I think it should be all the past winners against each other. See which of them has the balls to do it all again now that they’ve already got a million dollars.
Hot Amanda and Parvatti
An all-winners season would be too awesome, but very unlikely unless the prize were 5 millions or some other ridiculous amount.
Nah, a post tax 1 million isn’t all THAT much, I’m sure most of the winners could easily be convinced to participate for another million.
On the other hand, I would pay $1 million to see: “Survivor - All Star Bastards of Palau.” I mean come on, we mostly watch the show to see who we really hate. It gets really boring when all the bastards are voted off and only the timid and super nice are left to rock/paper/scissors who is going to win. My choice from this season would be Jean-Robert and Jaime.
Jaime also qualifies for the hottie season. I am not sure why she got so much hatred (although I missed the thrown challenge episode). I think she was just your average pretty and not too smart always follower never leader kinda gal.
I think she got hate because she acted like she was a leader (bossing around Eric and acting like a co-leader with PG by throwing the challenge), but then she opened her mouth and the sounds of an idiot came out.
How about this concept? There’s two separated groups of all baddies and all hotties. They are separated into competing tribes (two tribes in each group, so four total) and are unaware of the other group. Viewers see both groups each week, and we see someone voted out of both groups. Two merges happen, when both are around 10 each. They’re still unaware as they whittle each other down and jockey for position. Then, everybody is blindsided when the veil is lifted and everybody merges again.
So, you’d have major upheaval and drama as the people you’re trying to Pagong are now your allies against the other group. And in the back of their minds, players are wondering if there’s another hidden merge on the horizon.
Who was the third guy who was a demon at challenges? I can only remember Tom and Terry. The third guy was young; I think I remember him shimmying up a coconut tree at one point.
My preference for all-stars would be all the best challenge demons as half the cast and all hot chicks as the other half. Jaime and the other cute blonde chick that everybody hated would both be musts. (What was her name?)
And no matter what the criteria, if Parvati didn’t make it I’d be pissed.
