I use this all the time. Its from the Halloween special DVD where Mr Krabs is telling Spongebob a ghost story in the lobby of the Krusty Krab after closing time, using various fast food condiments for props.
He was telling Spongebob about getting his soul stolen and waving a couple pickle chips back and forth and Spongebob interrupts and asks him “Are souls really shaped like pickles?” and Mr Krabs says “Aye, as a matter of fact they are!”.
Later in the story Squidward pops up from behind a barrel and says “I’ve come for your pickle!” and Spongebob leaps out of his seat in terror. That’s a really good one! And so is the payback Spongebob gets later in the episode.
I can watch that episode (“Chocolate With Nuts”) over and over again. It was the old woman’s daughter that was saying CHOCOLATE. The exchange went like this:
Mary (to her mother, in strong Brooklyn-type accent): They’re selling chocolate!
Mary’s mother (basically just a dried-up backbone and skull with skin): What? What did you say?
Mary: They’re selling CHOCOLATE!
Mary’s mother: I can’t hear you.
Mary: THEY’RE SELLING CHOCOLATE!!!
Mary’s mother: I remember when they first invented chocolate. Sweet, sweet chocolate. I ALWAYS HATED IT
I like to say “What?? What did he say?” in that raspy voice.
This is the first scene I ever saw: “Spongebob, if we’re underwater, how do we have a fire?” [fire goes out]
When I’m getting the kids ready for school, I’ll often quote Spongebob the morning after he forgot how to tie his shoes:
“I’m read- [trip] . . . I’m read-[trip] . . . I’m re-[trip], etc.”
For some reason, Mrs* Puff’s exasperated exclamation “Why, Spongebob, Why?” (after he causes yet more devastion and destruction to Bikini Bottom during his driving lessons), is suitable for many occasions…
*IIRC, Mr Puff was stuffed and made into a lamp - wnich is why Mrs Puff “doesn’t like to talk about it”.
Plankton: “It’s evil. It’s diabolical. It’s lemon-scented. This Plan Z can’t possibly fail!”
SpongeBob, explaining to Patrick: “The Patty Wagon. Mr. Krabs uses it for promotional reasons. Let me show you some of its features: Sesame seed finish; steel-belted pickles; grilled leather interior; and under the hood, a fuel-injected French fryer with dual overhead grease traps.”
Old lady in the crowd: “Knucklehead McSpazatron!”
Patrick, after crashing: “Did you see my butt?”
Plankton, being arrested: “Come on, can’t you take a joke? Wasn’t that funny? With the monuments and the buildings? Wasn’t that hilarious…? *I will destroy all of you!” *
Not so much a quote, but in “One Krab’s Trash” Spongebob and Patrick are at a cemetery, and we see Squidward crying over a headstone. The “camera” moves over to the stone, revealing the inscription “Squidward’s hopes and dreams”
Cop 1: “Well, buckle up and we’ll drive real smooth-like.”
-Punches the gas pedal.
Cop 1: “Don’t worry, SpongeBob. He won’t be able to strangle you.”
Cop 2: “Yeah, we got him chained up real good. He’ll never get away.”
Cop 1: “Oops, not again…”
Cop 2: “Yep, he got away.”
Cop 1: “We’re gonna straighten you out!”
-whacking something with her police baton.
Cop 2: “This’ll fix ya!”
-Also hitting something with his baton.
Cut to bent parking meter being straightened.