I cannot say I was expecting Paradise Lost, but I feel opportunities were squandered, considering the source material (Satan! Mythology! Religion!), even compared to the comics many of the plot points were “stolen” from.
Not to get too deeply into it, but compare the “feel” of the following dramata:
Problem: the world is coming apart at the seams because humans are having their wishes granted.
TV solution: Lucifer convinces Amenadiel to become God and take care of it.
Comic book: Heaven begs Lucifer to take care of it, and to name his price. After investigating by hook and by crook, including in the depths of Hell, Lucifer manipulates a troubled young woman into guiding him to an antediluvian underworld in order to slay some primordial gods. [Whether or not it be as cool as it sounds, at least they were trying for the crazy stuff]