I am and I will. I’m really sorry. I got a notification from NAF about being modkilled I could tell his frustration. It’s understandable. Three people are trying to manage 55 players and all we have to manage is ourselves, but can’t even do that.
I’m going to look over Hooker and SnFaulkner’s helpful voting summaries and come back Day 6 playing.
Short answer: when I did the initial write-up based on yesterDay’s results, I was frustrated with how useless I was finding the list and didn’t see the benefit of adding the dead. If you think it will be helpful, I’ll see about adding them on the next update, probably toMorrow because the bulk of the work for a Dawn update will be colorizing the dead.
[ul] 31 living players
3 Wolves
5 Mafia
4 LUTHA
19 possible Town?
“power” ROLES ALIVE
9 TOWN The Watcher
The Basement-Based Tinkerer master switcher/1 shot tracker
3X A Mason
The Understudy
The Patsy miller
The Zoning Inspector ROLE BLOCKER
Alternate Universe Batman vig
5 MAFIA The Godfather
The Bodyguard
The Hitman
The Mook 1X MIMIC
The Enforcer 1 CYCLE BLOCKER
3 WOLVES The Alpha Wolf
The Bloodhound TRACKER
The Trickster 1 CYCLE BLOCKER
4 LUTHA
[/ul] MY COUNT. ** Paul ** you left off the Wolves?
There are eight scum alive. There are five mafia and three wolves.
I think you’re pretty townie, paul, but this reads like a slip. It reads like you only counted one of the two scum teams there. Am I misunderstanding your post?
It’s not a slip. There are 8 total scum. But the wolves win condition is at 3 instead of mafia at 5. Right now lylo is determined by the number of mafia because they outnumber the wolves.
Now do you see why it is important for us to attempt to discern between wolf and mafia? If we have two potential lynch candidates and one is a suspected wolf while the other is suspected mafia, it would make more sense for us to Lynch the suspected mafia right now.
If we kill a wolf, LYLO does not move back at all because mafia will still win when there are 10 players remaining. If we kill all the wolves, mafia will still win when there are 10 players remaining.
You seriously didn’t realize this was what was determining lylo?
** Paul ** snuggling wolves are you?
No really
as I asked before how the hell can Town tell who is a Wolf or a Mafa ? Voting records * might * help but - really-
Now if you want to do the home work and determine a pattern- go right ahead.
Any Scum we kill removes a power role from their ranks =all good for me.
and whilst I am thinking about it you posted your tinfiol hat theory about the cult being a Scum ploy ( the way I read it) But you danced with your nails on my idea about having another claim to remove them from the wolf pool ( confusing to me)
You will of course use your own judgement, but I think if a player under pressure claims LUTHA * then * you can take a peek in their closet. if they pass then they can check the next one - just an idea- you run with yours .
It seemed there are more and more players suggesting that a player could be mafia but not likely wolf… it was discussed numerous times in the case of Prof P. You yourself have just posted quite a delightful smudge of me implying I am a wolf without actually accusing me of it. So obviously it’s not beyond you to attempt to discern wolf from mafia. And yet you continue to question whether or not it’s even possible. This pings me as you pushing back against my opinion that we should give priority to mafia lynches. IIRC you got quite upset the last time I was talking about the mafia needing a killing also. The wolves sure took my encouragement to heart, and town is better off for it.
Now you seemed to not understand what determines lylo in this game. As town I know I’m keeping a watchful eye on that number, your confusion at my estimation of lylo makes me wonder why you arent.
Did you read his own comment that he was frustrated with how useless it turned out to be? Or are you just trying to come up with reasons people shouldn’t like me at this point?