This is how I’m feeling about the cultists right now. Koldanar’s claim was a real blow to the tentative trust I had in them. Their claims have gotten iffier and iffier in my book. There was some discussion when crys claimed of waiting to deal with cultists and seeing how they shook out, but the waiting game may need to end. If we get a double lynch toMorrow, a cultist is a good candidate.
I don’t particularly think cookies is going to flip LUTHA, and I don’t think she’s going to blow all of us up. At most, she might blow one of us up, so I do agree with mhaye not being on that train, and I think closer to EOD some players should step off of it as well, to reduce any risk there. It doesn’t always take a village.
I feel the need to repeat, again, that other than Mhaye people moving their votes off Cookies is a terrible idea. Let’s say she isn’t a bomb. Anyone that moves off is more likely to be a power role, which makes it easier for scum and there’s no benefit to Town. On the other hand, let’s say she is a bomb. We still expose power roles as before, AND we get the added downside of any power roles that choose to stay on her(for hiding purposes) are now more likely to be the one blown up. Where exactly is the upside to this plan? Mhaye is of course an exception, since he’s already revealed and therefore doesn’t have to worry about being exposed to scum by moving his vote.
Your objection makes no sense. His claim isn’t that he redirects his targets ability, he redirects abilities away from his target. So yes, targeting his claimed teammate would be the best choice, since it protects against things like vigs, SKs, roleblocks, etc.
This is my guess for a bomb as well. Blow one player up. I think it’s most likely that there’s no bomb and we’re reading way too much into flavor. The next most likely is a one or two player bomb. Least likely is a massive bomb, but we can mitigate even the massive bomb safely.
I’ve stated a few days ago, I was suspicious of you. I’ve picked anyone where I felt more was going on than they were letting on, hoping that a swap would provide information, in some way.
OOG : And I probably won’t be able to post until Monday, unless I can late nights this weekend - we’re throwing my son’s 3rd birthday party, and still dealing with getting the house painted.
No I am a complete idiot and posted that after more than a little wine:o I misread how Kodanar’s power works. I thought it redirected incoming powers from A to B not A’s power redirected to B. Doh!
There is no bomb, just me. And the list isn’t a list. When thinking about who to kill, MHaye just wasn’t coming to mind in such a way that I’m now kicking myself for not smelling that he had something on me and snuffing him before he could go blabbing. There are a few niggling ‘what ifs’ but nothing like that.
Did sachertorte mention having a switch? That would fit my theory that each team holds a switch for their team’s powers and 3rd party having the other switch.