Snide Comment From Relative: Do you say something?

A close relative made a comment (on New Year’s Day at the family outing, thankyouverymuch) regarding a painful incident that happened to me over ten years ago. While the incident will never be forgotten, I have moved on and it is no longer something that is in the forefront of my daily thoughts.

  1. The offending relative had nothing to do with the incident

  2. Both people involved in the incident were present

  3. The comment came out of the blue. Literally, there was no conversation leading up to the insensitive statement. It was just blurted out with no connection to the conversation at hand.

Frankly, I’m pissed off. But I’m not sure I should call this person on their incredibly bad form or if I should just let it go. At the time, I was so stunned I said nothing.

Should I bring it up? I’d like to know why this person chose to do this. I really have no feel as to how much of a shitstorm could be stirred up should I actually have a dialog about it.

Opinions?

After collecting my jaw up off the floor I’d have told the person it was not their place to say anything, the incident was long past, and if anything needed to be said it certainly was not by them.

I would talk to the relative about it, and sooner rather than later. If you wait too long the relative may deny saying anything or say something like, “I am sure I didn’t say it like that.”

If you don’t talk to them about it then for the rest of your life everytime you see/think of that person you will remember what they said.

Yeah - I’d say something. The best would probably have been to respond tersely publicly. Then you would have had the benefit of witnesses to the reasonableness of your response.
But I’d still say much the same stuff. Just “While that was unpleasant, X and I have made our peace, and consider that water under the bridge. I would appreciate you not bringing this up as a topic for general discussion as you did on NYD.” Anticipate that she will resist, deny the appropriateness of your response. I recommend preparing a follow-up comment, along the lines of “I would hope relatives such as us would not go out of our ways to bring up subjects they knew were hurtful to each other. I’m disappointed that you do not feel the same. Good bye.”
Depending on the person, hopefully she will realize how jerky she was. But another type of person will take anything you say - however measured and reasonable - as provocation. You will have to be on your toes to conduct yourself in the future in a manner that will not support anything nasty this person may say or do to follow-up out of embarrassment, anger, etc.
Depending on the personalities, you may also wish to tell the other relative, “I thought it unfortunate and inappropriate that Y brought that up. I assume you agree with me that that is a closed chapter and we have moved on? I wanted to let you know that I told her that I personally wished she would not bring it up in the future - especially not in public settings. And my hope is that the matter be dropped.”
(Just blathering off the top of my head, hoping I type something that will help you put your reasonable feelings into words!)

I’d just let it go. That works for me.

I have a couple of insensitive relatives who love to make snide and sarcastic comments about things that happened ten or twenty or more years ago. I’ve found it’s best to just let them go. I should point out that no other family member present joins in with them. And if I’m the target, I make no statements or rebuttals that could lead to fights or arguments, although I will occasionally hit them a withering stare.

I have a few reasons for not rising to their bait:

– We’re generally at a family gathering; there is no reason to turn it into an unpleasant time for all.
– I don’t want the family members whose company I enjoy and whose opinions I respect (who are obviously not these folks) to think less of me if I react in a less-than-adult way.
– Their remarks are similar to those you might hear children say in a schoolyard. I’m an adult. I’m not going to regress to childish rebuttals. (“Am not!” “Are too!”)
– Anything they can say about an error or gaffe I made twenty years ago is more than eclipsed by the successes I’ve had during those twenty years.
– These people generally don’t figure into my daily life, my work, my friends. I can totally ignore them the other days of the year. And I do.

Some things to think about anyway.

I’d say something.

As for how much of a shitstorm it might stir up, it is obvious that the relative who made the snide comment didn’t care - why should you?

Failing that, I’ll beat 'em up for you if ya want… :wink:

I knew you’d have my back, sis!

Do you think it was said out of stupidity / ignorance or malice? If he said it purposefully to get a rise out of you ignoring it might be the best way to go, or just calmly saying “that was inappropriate.” If if he is just stupidly blurting out something, I would just shame him a little by saying something like “that’s really none of your business” or “that isn’t really your problem.”

But I agree that if you are going to say something, do it sooner rather than later.

Life’s too short not to let shit like this roll off your back.

I’d say something and not feel the least bit bad about it. Like Missy said, she didn’t feel bad when she made the remark to you.

I agree with Poysyn, with the caveat that talking with the person may not go the way you want it to. I think ultimately your response should depend on how healing (for lack of a better word) talking about it would be.

I experienced something like that earlier this year, and still haven’t sorted out my feelings regarding it. Heck, maybe I’m being petty – I don’t know.

My dad died in April. We had a small memorial for him up at our cabin with our extended family, exactly as Dad wanted. One of my uncles was seriously ill at the time, no doubt in pain and facing his own mortality.

To honor Dad, we all built wishboats (out of driftwood, candles, flowers and leaves). After sunset, we lit the candles and launched our boats. The currents in front of our cabin swept the boats up the beach past us, and looped at the point and took the boats past us again and on out into the straits. It was lovely… except, my boat capsized almost immediately. Mine was the only one that tipped. Its candles were doused and the shells I’d collected fell off. I was already sobbing at that point, and that made it worse. Loudly enough for everyone to hear, my uncle called out, “Physics lesson for Wendy!”

My uncle posted photos of the wishboats on his website, with a caption for each one. The caption for mine was, “Wendy’s doomed craft.” That incensed my sister enough that she emailed him and asked him to change the caption, which he did immediately but not without telling my sister all about how I should have tested the boat earlier in the day (true, but I had other things on my mind, you know?).

My uncle died in June. I didn’t speak with him in between – I didn’t acknowledge his comment, and hugged and kissed him when I left. He was a great guy, always loving, funny, a know-it-all, a great father and intelligent. That incident was the only time I’ve ever been angry with him, and what sucks is that I think of THAT first when I think of him, rather than all the numberless fun and loving times we’ve had together.

That turned out to be a longer story than I’d intended. I guess my point, assuming I have one, is that those cutting remarks do impact how you think of your relatives. I wish I’d spoken with my uncle about it – I think it would have helped expunge the memory of his remark. I trust that in time I’ll be back to remembering him at his loving best rather that at his sharpest.

I went to visit my grandma over the long weekend after Thanksgiving and she managed to not tell me about my great-aunt having died on Thursday despite us going through old photos and stuff Friday night. She only mentioned it when she got a call about the funeral on Saturday.

I’m really pissed but she is proper and we’ve never argued about anything. Just politeness for the duration of the rare visits, and for phone calls. She’s 88, why bother, but I’m not sure how to get over her being so petty.

In my family, it’s best to let something die without response. If someone let on that a comment bothered them, they’d be razzed on it mercilessly. There are some real assholes in my family.

I think she had a bug up her ass about something else and rather than confront, she tossed this remark into an unrelated conversation. The issue I imagine she had her bowels in an uproar about is miniscule compared to what she said. She made her comment to hurt, embarrass, and humiliate.

Well, I sent an email asking why she said it and what prompted it. I’ll keep y’all posted.

That’s a good response - not accusing her, but asking why she said it. I have learned in situations like this it is better to be seen as the calm one and make the other person look like the crazy one all by themselves. :slight_smile: Then when they go off like this and other people are around they shake their heads and look at you in silent sympathy. If you strike back, then everyone just thinks you two just go at each other.

I haven’t heard back yet…hmmmm…

Similar in my family, typically there’ll be some snide comment about how oversensitive I am. I still bring those issues up though, and over time I am starting to make an effect on them. My mom & sister have slowly been convinced that bringing up certain topics is verboten now, and it makes gatherings far easier.

Hell, the same grandma I mentioned above thought it was rude of me to ask my mom how my father proposed–too private a topic!! You can imagine how restricted the topics of conversation are.

Because the rabbit done died?