I know she’ll do “Wicked Game,” but if Siobhan does “Baby Did A Bad Bad Thing” she gets my vote until she’s gone.
Simon cannot abide any kind of independent creative spark in his little monkeys. I can tell he doesn’t like it if they can even play an instrument reasonably well. He would have hated Jimi Hendrix.
Wow, Siobhan nailed that.
Liked Siobhan! One of my favorite songs and she didn’t butcher it too bad. The very beginning was a little rough.
She doesn’t know what “dark horse” means? Ok, so Siobahn is stupid. Maybe she’ll be another Pickler.
Voice sounds ok. A little yodelly. Basically just more karaoke.
Is “glassblower’s apprentice” a real job, or is that some kind of, like, Ren Faire thing or something?
I thought Siobhan was the best of a weak night (thus far). Actually she was very good.
I’m four singers in so far, and the only one I’d stop and listen to is Lily. I really liked her take on ‘Fixing a hole’. Like the judges said, she actually sounds like she has her own voice. The first three can just home home now. I can barely even remember their names.
Dio: When Janell was singing, I turned to my wife and said, “That sounds exactly like what you’d hear at karaoke night in a bar. A bit awkward, reasonably okay in pitch, but totally amateurish otherwise.” I see you had the same impression.
Maybe it’s just nerves, but these girls so far have been bad to mediocre.
I think Siobahn was ok, but not that good. There’s just a really low bar tonight. Anyone who stays in key sounds good.
Liked that a lot. Siobhan did something nice to her hair too. I’ll ignore that she didn’t know what “dark horse” meant.
Crystal is good, but her harmonica is no Taylor Hicks.
Crystal found a box of Crest Whitening Strips! No more distracting yellow. She’s one of my favorites of this season.
I wish Bowersox wouldn’t keep using her kid every chance she gets.
Not a fan of the song choice either, and that around the neck harmonica thing is really obnoxious and affected. She sounded good. Best of the night. But I don’t care at all for her personality.
Crystal. Tonight’s winner so far IMHO.
Another good performance. Think AI put all the good ones at the end of the show?
Don’t particularly like Alanis, don’t particularly like Crystal’s interviews/backstory, but I guess I have to say I liked that. At least in comparison to the others tonight.
She doesn’t “take us on a journey,” Kara, shut the fuck up.
Crystal Rowsbower, I liked her voice a lot. The harp was horrible. I hope she goes through, as I want to hear her do some more.
Anyone who doesn’t like Jagged Little Pill is a poopypants. There, I said it.
Hey, Katie…
FUCK your grandma!
Who?
That was the most ‘show’ of all of them.