Advanced Search
Preferences
Web
Information No results found for “holy-water tipped spears wielding Predator”.
<giggles>
Really? Because I’m still shaking with laughter!!!
Nine! I forgot pedescribe. Sorry dude.
I think the Predator vs Alien franchise is mercifully dead now, but I for one would pay good money to see Predator vs Poltergeist.
Need answer fast!
Given 9 unconfirmed and 3-4 mislynches left, we could always just lynch them in some order (alphabetic? :D) and let the scum do their thing until the player pool gets smaller. 
I’m betting on 2-3 scum left. We’ve had a fair number of power roles but so have they–and assuming the high side keeps us from getting complacent.
I disagree. A typical number for 25 is 5 scum, and for 27 is six. Given that all the scum have had power roles so far, but that we’ve only had about half of ours have power roles so far, I’m guessing there are 2 left, maybe 1.
so we have the singing, but where’s the nudity?
any thoughts on the idea that lynched Betas take out mostly dead Scum?
**Chucara **died and **buffy **completely died at the same time.
Interesting, but there’s only one way to test it. If you’re wrong, it costs us a mislynch. It looks like we could afford that just now, but I’d rather still go for scum.
On which note:
I can see the case against special ed; obsessively trying to side with known town is poor play, and I didn’t like his saving of MHaye.
Brewha I’ve been suspicious of for a while and I didn’t find his recent defence( that he wasn’t reading my posts in context when he built a sloppy case against me) to be very convincing. Reading back, the fact that JSexton defended him doesn’t look too good either.
**Millit **has been bugging me for a while; he’s become a lot more active since MHaye died; at least in his attacks on me he was following JSexton’s lead.
zeriel still isn’t posting very much; ditto Nanook.
**Rapier **I’m leaning more town on now, but that’s more gut plus absence of obvious scumminess than anything else. Similarly, I’ve long felt that **Natlaw **was acting pro-town, but I should probably check that before I do something stupid.
I’m also struck by the Day Four end votes:
Blaster Master (7): Natlaw, dotchan, Millit the Frail, brewha, JSexton, Hockey Monkey, Mhaye
Given that scum had a definite interest in lynching rather than NK-ing Blam, and that it did run close with Hal for a while, I think there’s a good chance that at least one of the unknowns is scum.
I’m going to hold back from voting just now, in the interests of maybe hearing more from people.
Since I did not make it clear in my previous post: I think any power roles (doctor, vigilante) should not worry about this too much and just keep using their powers. Scum could create a four player LyLo by simple not killing the Night before (if that is an option for them).
Millet and brewha seem to be under scrutiny at the moment so as I’ve already had some suspicions of millet I’ve done a bit of a read through. I’ll try and do brewha as well but I’m supposed to be working.
And crap - I just tried to post it and was told it was too long so I’ll break it up into two. Sorry - it’s a long one as the actress said to the elephant:
(bolding mine)
I brought this point up when she first posted it but this wording still seems very strange to me. Not only that, the whole post is basically disagreeing with name claims while calling them roleclaims while asking for reasons to claim while saying it might out power roles - no real solid opinions. I don’t get the being wary of naming people part either.
Vote number 9. Voting for scum at this point doesn’t make her scum certainly but there’s no town motivation there either. A null tell.
This post implies the scum were either not voting for macey or early voters who couldn’t reasonably get off the wagon. Excuses her late vote.
Again the implication is scum were among those not voting macey - convenient. Also a subtle smudge against me “voted Millet the Frail then quickly unvoted”. Actually I unvoted after she responded to my suspicions but hey, what’s a little smudge in mafia.
Firstly he wouldn’t have got a TRUE because story, while awesome, isn’t as far as I know able to divine intentions. The rest of this post is basically casting doubt on NAF’s claim without actually coming out and saying you don’t believe him.
This is not a proper town claim IMO so it was fairly safe to make it. You did reclaim on Day/Night Four but by then NAF had already said who he’d be investigating the next two Days so it was safe to do so as you planned on him being dead by then.
So you were suspicious of NAF but now you’re inclined to trust him but now you’re suspicious of Diggit?
And now you give Diggit the benefit of the doubt while implying there’s a scummy plot going on - whether this includes NAF or not isn’t clear.
(snipped)
And now you believe both roleclaims.
And now you don’t trust him as much but want to.
It’s weird, you’ve been in and out the trusting NAF and Diggit camp yet you trust cookies. You can only trust cookies if you trust NAF. Or if you have another reason to have trusted her you should spell it out which you didn’t do here or previously. You make some new accusations. MHaye and JS are at the bottome of the list with Nanook, Hal and amrussel at the top. Your case against Nanook is for lurking, Hal for voting cookies. You mention amrussel as doing decent analysis (very different from your later post about him).
With MHaye you manage to say what he’s done does look suspicious but maybe there are reasons for it and he isn’t necessarily the scum investigator and Hal’s just trying to make MHaye look bad.
With JSexton - well he went after Pleo and Blam quite hard but that’s about it.
Both scum. Both somewhat protected by you.
Crikey - you accuse amrussel of poo flinging? Now you’re after Special Ed for me-too voting. Also your wording of your case against him is pretty extreme. He’s turned into a champion bandwagon jumper. While I don’t personally agree with voting alongside confirmed town unless I think their candidate is scummy, doing so isn’t necessarily a scum move, especially as two of those “bandwagons” were on scum. As for his voting Hal - he’s already said but I don’t think it’s been recognised that he made a case against Hal initially so wasn’t just bandwagon jumping in that instance.
Brewha you say made you suspicious but you get a “townie feeling” from him. So that’s one of the players garnering suspicion out of the way. Then you back up your reasoning by saying scum wouldn’t have voted for macey so early on in the game yet in one of the posts I’ve quoted above you say the exact opposite.
Basically Mr Special Ed can’t do right for doing wrong. He votes MHaye before his claim, unvotes him afterwards and goes back to voting for him along with the confirmed town later on. The reasons you give him for doing so are very inventive though.
So the Mr Special Ed bandwagon hasn’t worked and now you’re onto amrussel. You totally contradict your earlier assessment of him too - this has already been brought up by amrussell so I won’t go into details.
Um - were you actually hoping anyone would buy this?
(snipped and bolded)
I repeat… “for us”?
And this looks like total track covering to me.
You amaze me. You’d be looking at zeriel or Nanook. You’ve retracted your vote for amrussel now and you’re back to Mr Special Ed - well he’s garnered a bit of suspicion so it may actually work this time.
All in all, for the category of poo flinging champion of this game I think the shiny brown turd gong should be awarded to you. I’m tempted to reread your posts all over again and if there’s someone you haven’t mentioned in a negative light I’m going to guess they’re scum.
…I’m still satisfied with my vote. My opinion has changed…but I’m still satisfied.
:smack: With all my posting I completely forgot to actually vote!
At least until I’ve looked at brewha properly:
vote Millit the Frail
Um I spect you’d rather I didn’t repeat my reasons 
I’m impressed AH. That was quite a lot of digging you did there. And damn if the things you bring up don’t look amazingly suspicous when you lay them out next to each other like that. Millit’s been bugging me as well, for much the same reason as Natlaw, but there’s certainly a lot more meat to what you’ve brought up than to my more nuanced case.
Unote Natlaw
Vote Millit
Repeating the Mrs. part for amrussell ;). The other reason is I totally missed Millits claim about having Alpha/Beta status (thus most likely vanilla town), even though I quoted her post right after.
NAF investigated Cookies as town Day Four and told us Night Five. NAF was confirmed Dawn Day Five by turning up dead. Millits post you’re responding to here was from Day Five, so yes Cookies was pretty much confirmed at that point (unless Godfather or NAF had a failure rate, etc).
I’ll go read part two now :).
NETA: (thus most likely vanilla town) should be (thus most likely a vanilla town claim)
and in the second part it should be: NAF told us Night Four.
I’m not sure what you’re referencing but the point I was making was about Millit’s response to NAF’s point here: (snipped)
You’re right - my bad. The rest of my points stand but that particular post was made after NAF died - the perils of looking through a single person’s posts rather than the whole thread.
That were just a note for amrussell who called Millit a he and a note for myself, because I hadn’t notice that claim of Millit.